Here's the problem
#61
Why would you drop Styles from LB?
Reply
#62
(04-07-2025, 07:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Why would you drop Styles from LB?

Because I think we'd be better defensively. If we went three at the back, Styles would be back in as LWB.

I'd also like to see what Styles can add to our midfield.
Reply
#63
(04-07-2025, 07:15 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-07-2025, 07:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Why would you drop Styles from LB?

Because I think we'd be better defensively. If we went three at the back, Styles would be back in as LWB.

I'd also like to see what Styles can add to our midfield.

I don't disagree. But if you're going with a back 4, which is what you were proposing in your last post, then you have to go with Heggem as the left centre half and Styles as left back. 

I'm not sure on Styles in CM. I've no doubt he'd do a great job, but we have Diakite, Mowatt, Molumby and Price who are all very good players at this level. I don't see where you'd slot him in when we've got just as good, if not better, alternatives.
Reply
#64
(04-07-2025, 07:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-07-2025, 07:15 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-07-2025, 07:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Why would you drop Styles from LB?

Because I think we'd be better defensively. If we went three at the back, Styles would be back in as LWB.

I'd also like to see what Styles can add to our midfield.

I don't disagree. But if you're going with a back 4, which is what you were proposing in your last post, then you have to go with Heggem as the left centre half and Styles as left back. 

I'm not sure on Styles in CM. I've no doubt he'd do a great job, but we have Diakite, Mowatt, Molumby and Price who are all very good players at this level. I don't see where you'd slot him in when we've got just as good, if not better, alternatives.

That's my point mate, I'm not that convinced by him at centre half, yet. LB is a better place for him to continue to develop. Either way we need at least one centre half as a priority, to sign none would be negligent. 

Based on what I've seen, TM (assuming he's in charge next season) doesn't seem to fancy Diakite and I think Styles could be a better version of Molumby, who despite his committed running about, really doesn't help us pick teams apart. A midfield two of Molumby and Mowatt is two players doing the job of one. Price should be a shoe-in next season for one of the spots, the option of Styles in there doesn't hurt us.

A lot of focus has been on our goalscoring but the one big miss from last season is Kipre, who was excellent, it is no surprise that we've had trouble closing out games under CC and now Mowbray. If we have any designs on being towards the sharp end of the league, we need to be able to keep clean sheets again.
Reply
#65
Styles has been a pretty decent Townsend replacement. And his data, whilst no where near Townsend's yet as a full back is okay considering it's relatively new to him.

He wins his tackles, is surprisingly decent in the air for a small fella, and he passes the ball progressively. He obviously gets into decent positions as he has plenty of shots.

BUT - his actual output is really poor. Very few goals, assists and shot creating actions considering how much he is involved in the games. Summary, good defensively, great with his progressive possession both carrying the ball and passing, but terrible final ball/shots and that needs to improve, especially considering that'd the part of the game he should be good at being a natural 8/10.

Full summary link:
https://fbref.com/en/players/e96d5560/sc...ing-Report

With regards to the defence more generally. If we can replace Holgate and Ajayi with a player of a similar profile, but younger as Ajayi. We should be okay to go with Heggem, Bartley, NEW GUY, Taylor. Then we need a really attacking right wing back, and if Styles doesn't up his output, left wing back too.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#66
(04-06-2025, 10:11 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(04-06-2025, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-06-2025, 09:04 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-06-2025, 08:32 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-06-2025, 08:25 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As I said I’m on the fence with him as I’ve been right from the start. 
He’s a gent and well liked in the game and I hope it works out for us, because becoming a trigger happy club is a sad thing.
I suspect that the fallout from the Chinese balls up is being felt now. If Mowbray is the steady leader to take us back to a good place before moving on then I’ll happily watch the rebuild. 
This season though looks set to end disappointingly. I reckon where we are now is as good as it’ll get.
My money is on Boro and Cov for those last 2 spots.

What does this ‘good place’ look like? Since he left us to come second in a two horse race his record suggests we are going to be marooned at best in this division for years.
A good place to me is a rebuild with 4-5 new faces of the Heggem, Price calibre. It’s watching some young uns progress rather than expensive mistakes like Diangana or guys past their prime like Bartley and Ajayi. 
Simply I place some faith in the hierarchy at the club and I’ll take it on board that they have to get the building blocks in place. 
They inherited a shit show that had us fighting for existence. That’s very front of mind with me hence why I have a good bit of patience.

I don’t share your enthusiasm for rebuilding in the Championship. It will and has dragged us down to hoping we make the playoffs at best, this will get worse not better the longer we stay in this division. I don’t see anything but a midtable Championship future if TMs appointment is anything to go on. This season isn’t over, and it would be a failure if we don’t make the playoffs.

Derek, you’re a sensible guy, where do you expect us to rebuild, League 1?

Finances dictate what we can and can’t do. There was no guarantee we would make the play offs under CC.

Should he have been sacked for not winning the play offs.

Price and Bany are ours and look good.

Heggam and Styles have had very good seasons. If we sign another four like that pre-season it can only to be our benefit. The days of signing a Wallace and Swift on big wages are gone (thank god).

My cynicism with regards to rebuilding without parachute payments and now trying to cut the wage bill doesn’t solve many of our problems if we are genuinely ambitious for the future of the club. We can cut the wage bill, we can hope to find decent young players from here and abroad but without the club investing in other commercial activities outside of the football department all we are doing is cementing a upper midtable finish each season in the Championship with the hope we find a manager that can emulate what Megson did. Something I am very sceptical of with our first managerial appointment since the new owners have arrived. 

Income from tv, season tickets, flogging our best young talent will see us plateau and move backwards, I do look across at Blues and see a plan to increase revenue that will see the club and whole area grow, it will take that kind of approach to move us forward medium to long term. Moneyball is precarious business model relying on small margins of error in player recruitment, once it goes wrong there is very little else to back it up. 

Brentford are fortunate that the gap between the Championship and Prem is so large now that they are able to buy proven Prem quality players as are sadly Wolves (although that depends in the future with what their parent company decides to do). We are trying to play moneyball as far as I can see in a far tougher, financial basket case of a league where we are hoping each season one team that gets relegated totally messes up their transition and in turn gives others a chance. 

I’m a realist, I look at the teams coming down, I look at the likes of Blues and I realise we are going to have to perform to our very optimum across the whole football department to have a chance of promotion after this season, because our income revenue is bang average at best and we are now getting squeezed by every club in the Midlands bar fugging Walsall! 

There does seem to be this assumption that by building over numerous seasons we will eventually find a squad capable of promotion. It won’t be the length of time we spend in this division that determines our success it’ll be how much money we can invest and just trying to wheel and deal won’t be enough anymore imo.
Reply
#67
I don't think it's and "either/or" situation, Dekka.

We have to rebuild anyway. Whilst the ambition and target has to be promotion. We have no other choice. Also it's just the best way to run the club regardless of what league we're in.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#68
(04-07-2025, 08:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I don't think it's and "either/or" situation, Dekka.

We have to rebuild anyway. Whilst the ambition and target has to be promotion. We have no other choice. Also it's just the best way to run the club regardless of what league we're in.

I know we have to rebuild Lurker, it’s the level of investment we need to make us successful that matters. Every club has to rebuild every year it’s not a new thing, but we have to find revenue streams beyond flogging our best players to have a success. Relying on flogging a Fellows every year and hoping we get two equally good players for example is not a long term strategy for success.
Reply
#69
(04-07-2025, 08:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-07-2025, 08:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I don't think it's and "either/or" situation, Dekka.

We have to rebuild anyway. Whilst the ambition and target has to be promotion. We have no other choice. Also it's just the best way to run the club regardless of what league we're in.

I know we have to rebuild Lurker, it’s the level of investment we need to make us successful that matters. Every club has to rebuild every year it’s not a new thing, but we have to find revenue streams beyond flogging our best players to have a success. Relying on flogging a Fellows every year and hoping we get two equally good players for example is not a long term strategy for success.

Completely agree, fwiw, mate. But most clubs, including those in the Prem have to sell their better players on a consistent basis. We just need to get 2 that are better than what we have when we sell our prized assets.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#70
(04-07-2025, 08:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-07-2025, 08:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I don't think it's and "either/or" situation, Dekka.

We have to rebuild anyway. Whilst the ambition and target has to be promotion. We have no other choice. Also it's just the best way to run the club regardless of what league we're in.

I know we have to rebuild Lurker, it’s the level of investment we need to make us successful that matters. Every club has to rebuild every year it’s not a new thing, but we have to find revenue streams beyond flogging our best players to have a success. Relying on flogging a Fellows every year and hoping we get two equally good players for example is not a long term strategy for success.

You regularly cite Brentford as an example forgetting that up to the point they went shit or bust the summer they signed Mbeumo, Tony, Jansen, Norgaard etc they'd sold their best player every window in order to generate the cash to keep competing and get them to within striking distance of the PL.

Coventry have now built a side that has a really strong platform (if they don't go up this year), to compete at the top of the Championship next season by selling their two best players from a couple of years ago. They've reinvested that cash and now have found additional players that can be sold for profit if required, or if they perform well enough to be poached.

It's only unsustainable if the club makes a mess of setting the infrastructure up correctly. Given what Nestor will have seen from Bologna and the success they are now having, I'm hopeful. The only thing that worries me is the manager.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: