Alex Scott
#61
(11-28-2022, 11:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:38 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:34 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:17 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it's misogyny to question women commentating on men's football, what is it to question men commentating on women's football?

Why can't a woman commentate on men's football?
Who said they can't?

Why question it then? What exactly is the question being asked here?
Whether it constitutes misogyny and whether there is a difference with women complaining about men commentating on their game. 

I just feel misogyny is an overused word these days and we are at risk of diluting the real issue.

Questioning whether Alex Scott is any good at her job is not persecution it's just an opinion, same as saying Micah Richards is no good at his. They are both a matter of taste.

Women were effectively locked out of sports (especially football) broadcasting for decades and it appears from where I'm sitting some people take issue with women now being allowed onto the sofas and into the commentary gantries. Alex Scott watches the same game we all do and is just as capable as analysing and articulating what she sees as anyone else. Whether she is good at the job is another question, in my opinion female commentators/pundits get a rougher ride and harsher criticism than their male counterparts.

As for misogyny, years of reading this board have left me in little doubt that quite a few posters hold sexist and misogynist opinions. You get the same few comments from the same posters every time these sort of threads come along.
Reply
#62
If you want witness crap male football commentators then tune in on itv. Andros Townsend and Seb Hutchinson (who he?) take it to a new low.
Reply
#63
Bobby Cram - I never knew that. You learn something every day.
Reply
#64
(11-28-2022, 11:54 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:38 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:34 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:17 AM)Duffers Wrote: Why can't a woman commentate on men's football?
Who said they can't?

Why question it then? What exactly is the question being asked here?
Whether it constitutes misogyny and whether there is a difference with women complaining about men commentating on their game. 

I just feel misogyny is an overused word these days and we are at risk of diluting the real issue.

Questioning whether Alex Scott is any good at her job is not persecution it's just an opinion, same as saying Micah Richards is no good at his. They are both a matter of taste.

Women were effectively locked out of sports (especially football) broadcasting for decades and it appears from where I'm sitting some people take issue with women now being allowed onto the sofas and into the commentary gantries. Alex Scott watches the same game we all do and is just as capable as analysing and articulating what she sees as anyone else. Whether she is good at the job is another question, in my opinion female commentators/pundits get a rougher ride and harsher criticism than their male counterparts.

As for misogyny, years of reading this board have left me in little doubt that quite a few posters hold sexist and misogynist opinions. You get the same few comments from the same posters every time these sort of threads come along.
Agree with the first sentence and would agree that that was genuine misogyny.
I also have no issue with female pundits, many of them do better research and offer more insight, rather than the tired old cliches. To question whether all female pundits are there on merit though, is not misogynistic in my view.

I would definitely question the second highlighted statement though, I don't know a single male pundit who is regularly praised. All of Lineker, Neville, Richards, Keane, Souness, Murphy etc. etc. get pelters at every turn! 
For me, it's punditry itself that's the issue, there's just too much of it and it's poorly researched and lazy. Soccer Saturday has a lot to answer for.
Reply
#65
(11-28-2022, 12:32 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:54 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:38 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:34 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Who said they can't?

Why question it then? What exactly is the question being asked here?
Whether it constitutes misogyny and whether there is a difference with women complaining about men commentating on their game. 

I just feel misogyny is an overused word these days and we are at risk of diluting the real issue.

Questioning whether Alex Scott is any good at her job is not persecution it's just an opinion, same as saying Micah Richards is no good at his. They are both a matter of taste.

Women were effectively locked out of sports (especially football) broadcasting for decades and it appears from where I'm sitting some people take issue with women now being allowed onto the sofas and into the commentary gantries. Alex Scott watches the same game we all do and is just as capable as analysing and articulating what she sees as anyone else. Whether she is good at the job is another question, in my opinion female commentators/pundits get a rougher ride and harsher criticism than their male counterparts.

As for misogyny, years of reading this board have left me in little doubt that quite a few posters hold sexist and misogynist opinions. You get the same few comments from the same posters every time these sort of threads come along.
Agree with the first sentence and would agree that that was genuine misogyny.
I also have no issue with female pundits, many of them do better research and offer more insight, rather than the tired old cliches. To question whether all female pundits are there on merit though, is not misogynistic in my view.

I would definitely question the second highlighted statement though, I don't know a single male pundit who is regularly praised. All of Lineker, Neville, Richards, Keane, Souness, Murphy etc. etc. get pelters at every turn! 
For me, it's punditry itself that's the issue, there's just too much of it and it's poorly researched and lazy. Soccer Saturday has a lot to answer for.

Questioning whether they are there on merit is one thing, I suspect some people simply have an issue with women being there at all, which is definitely misogyny. Even if there is an element of tokenism I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing. Usually at a WC or major BBC/Sky match you have a presenter and three pundits in the studio, at best one of those people will be female. It's no bad thing to have more women involved and as more do then the standard will improve too.

Punditry in general is pretty poor (except for the BT Goals Show) but that's a separate debate altogether.
Reply
#66
(11-28-2022, 11:58 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: If you want witness crap male football commentators then tune in on itv. Andros Townsend and Seb Hutchinson (who he?) take it to a new low.

Funny how people hear things differently, thought Townsend was a breathe of fresh air after the likes of Danny Murphy, Jermaine Penis etc.

And The Twatter seems to think they were also pretty decent so...
Reply
#67
(11-28-2022, 12:44 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 11:58 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: If you want witness crap male football commentators then tune in on itv. Andros Townsend and Seb Hutchinson (who he?) take it to a new low.

Funny how people hear things differently, thought Townsend was a breathe of fresh air after the likes of Danny Murphy, Jermaine Penis etc.

And The Twatter seems to think they were also pretty decent so...

That is a very low bar with Murphy and Jenas!! The 3rd goal for Cameroon ... even with the VAR replay Townsend went ''oh no it's offside''? It was not even close. A bit like Hartson the both were full of cliched comments.

Still we can all see it with different persepectives.
Reply
#68
I like Alex Scott.

She's far better than some of the absolute shit we have to suffer as pundits. She also seems like a genuinely good person, known a few who have met her and not a bad word said.

And yes, she's certainly far easier on the eyes than the usual ex players....
Reply
#69
(11-28-2022, 01:22 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I like Alex Scott.

She's far better than some of the absolute shit we have to suffer as pundits. She also seems like a genuinely good person, known a few who have met her and not a bad word said.

And yes, she's certainly far easier on the eyes than the usual ex players....

Also, to note, no speculation about John Hartson's sex life...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#70
(11-28-2022, 01:25 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(11-28-2022, 01:22 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I like Alex Scott.

She's far better than some of the absolute shit we have to suffer as pundits. She also seems like a genuinely good person, known a few who have met her and not a bad word said.

And yes, she's certainly far easier on the eyes than the usual ex players....

Also, to note, no speculation about John Hartson's sex life...

Is that why John Terry doesn't get the gig?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)