Argentina
#61
Maradona the greatest ever
Reply
#62
(11-22-2022, 04:23 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Another good comparison to look at is rugby. A couple of years ago, there was a piece on BBC Sport around the average size of rugby players fom the early 90s when the game turned professional, to then. Almost all positions were several inches taller, several stone heavier. Just no chance of comparing eras.

That's right plus kids are getting bigger and stronger so big injuries happen now at younger ages. We bumped into Marcus Smith at Gatwick airport over Easter and my 14 year-old got a selfie with him and the lad was taller (not 6'1") by about an inch or more. So fair fuggs to him for taking down opposition players who are built like a freight train!
Reply
#63
I only saw footage of Pele but what a player he was, to win 3 World Cups and his goal scoring record is amazing. He even found a way to miss goals spectacularly.

Maradona is the best player ive seen but again only on telly and for all his character weaknesses he was a fantastic player

Messi and Ronaldo have never scored a goal between them in knock out rounds of a world cup which knocks the shine off their abilities

Diego still #1 for me
Reply
#64
(11-22-2022, 04:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-22-2022, 03:34 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-22-2022, 03:11 PM)Duffers Wrote: Maradona joined Napoli from…. You guessed it, Barcelona.

Barcelona then were not what they are now in terms of dominance. None of the big clubs were. Teams like Verona, Forest, Real Sociedad, Stuttgart all won titles then. 

No one is denying the brilliance of Messi, but can you not see that the best teams now are on a different planet to what they were then. The shear weight of money has transformed the game and made domestic leagues far less competitive.

Players are bigger, stronger and better coached than they were and that's human advancement but not seeing the other mitigating factors is just ridiculous. The conditions have been set up for the best to excel.

By the way I'm sure Tyson Fury would demolish Ali. He's 4 inches taller and 4 stone heavier. This is reading for Duffers. https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/foot...30431.html

I know exactly how fucked the modern game is, I don’t any further reading on the subject.

It just amuses me how certain people refuse to see past their own nostalgia.

I had a nostalgic uncle. He was a real twat who would talk of Tom Finney, Nat Lofthouse etc - he was a racist working class cock from Walsall., who mostly didn't work.

He used to come out with shit about black players back in the late 70s. Crap like: "They'll be no good in the cold." He didn't like it when I spoke of the brilliance of Regis and Cunningham.

That is what I call refusing to see past nostalgia. There was no basis for argument, no facts to mull over etc.

I think you've been presented with the simple fact that on a level playing field with the best of Germany, France, Brazil, Italy around them neither Ronaldo or Messi have yet grabbed a World Cup by the scruff of the neck and shone like Maradona did or Pele before, when they've been in similar quality sides.

There is also the indisputable fact that if you read (sorry you know it already) the sheer weight of stats supporting the uncompetitiveness of modern club football you will see that Messi and Ronaldo have been massive benefactors by playing for these modern multi billion dollar global giants.

It's a bit different to misty eyed nostalgia about a 5ft 8 forward in hobnail boots from the 50s running rings around the best of now whilst sipping a pint of mild and smoking Woodbines.

As I said you can only be the best in your own era and no denying the brilliance of Ronaldo or Messi. However, they do not have the same admiration to me as the likes of Federer, Djokovic and Nadal who on a level playing field against other men, not with 10 superstars around, have been brilliant and on a new level to all before.

Those 3 put Borg, Connors, Laver etc into the shadows, no matter how much many of us enjoyed them in days of yore.
Reply
#65
(11-22-2022, 04:37 PM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Maradona the greatest ever

Recently read a book about Argentine footbalL, `Angels With Dirty Faces`, great book, as much about the history of Argentina as about the football.
Interesting that , England fans will never forgive Maradona for his `Hand Of God`goal, but, several of Englands players, donkeys like Butcher, Peter Reid, Terry Fenwick etc all say that in the build up to his second goal, they all tried to deliberately foul him, but,just bounced off him, or were too late as he had already got past them.
Reply
#66
Cruyff, Neeskins, total football but got done by the Germans in 74.
People either have short memories or believe football didn't exist before the Premier league.
Reply
#67
(11-22-2022, 05:33 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(11-22-2022, 04:37 PM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Maradona the greatest ever

Recently read a book about Argentine footbalL, `Angels With Dirty Faces`, great book, as much about the history of Argentina as about the football.
Interesting that , England fans will never forgive Maradona for his `Hand Of God`goal, but, several of Englands players, donkeys like Butcher, Peter Reid, Terry Fenwick etc all say that in the build up to his second goal, they all tried to deliberately foul him, but,just bounced off him, or were too late as he had already got past them.

Not forgetting stupid, Tory fuckwit Peter Shilton getting out jumped by the smallest bloke on the pitch.
Reply
#68
Al Hilals team is 9 of those players that started today plus Matheus Pereira and Bafetimbi Gomis
Reply
#69
(11-22-2022, 02:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: We live in an era where the biggest clubs have such obscene wealth that they can build a team of superstars worth a billion pounds around them.

Both Messi and Ronaldo have been benefactors of this lopsided footballing travesty that has made domestic leagues far less competitive than they were.

They've also been helped by having their skills in an era where pitches are like bowling greens. To add to this modern media means we see every bit of their brilliance. The media hype also adds to this.

Maradona to me is the best, as he put Napoli on the map and lifted Argentina to the World Cup at a time when they looked quite ordinary bar his brilliance. To those who recall 86 they will all back up he was like from another planet.

Give him the protection afforded modern players, team mates who are galacticos and the pristine bowling greens and think he's have surpassed all that these 2 modern superstars have done.

Modern conditions have aligned to put them ahead of the rest, when really they are just the best of their incredibly privileged generation.

I'd like to have seen Ronaldo v the likes of Terry Butcher on a boggy sandy pitch in January.

Messi is undeniably a once-in-a-generation talent, all the points you make about the game being different to years ago apply to all players today and there's no-one who has been as good as him over the last 20 years. Only Zidane and (at a stretch) Ronaldinho have come anywhere near and it's arguable their best times came before Messi hit his peak.

Whether Maradona or Messi is the best is a bit moot anyway as surely the best of all time has to be Cruyff?  Big Grin
Reply
#70
It's a nonsense argument simply to assume today's players are better, or that the likes of Best, Mathews, Pele, Duncan Edwards or even Maradonna wouldn't have been able to cope with discipline, diets and fitness. You can only beat what is there at the time. All else is speculation but those I've mentioned were top, top players who surely would have been even better with modern methods.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: