02-02-2023, 10:29 PM
(02-02-2023, 09:56 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:(02-02-2023, 09:09 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:(02-02-2023, 08:11 PM)Duffers Wrote:(02-02-2023, 08:06 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:(02-02-2023, 07:58 PM)Duffers Wrote: In the face of things this is exactly what has happened.
I find that sad, but I can only assume (if true) the victim would have agreed to it, and as such is happy with the 'justice' received.
I'm not sure why the charge can suddenly be dropped. Surely the police would have investigated, and gathered the majority of evidence they need to convict him, so why does it matter if the victim drops the charge, could the police not carry out the charge on the basis of gathered evidence?
The conclusion of this doesn't sit right with me.
If the victim refuses to give evidence in court then what can they do?
But wouldn't the police have the evidence already? We've all heard the audio clip, which I guess could be edited or even be someone trying to impersonate him, but how likely is that?
I just can't get my head around how this has developed!
(02-02-2023, 08:35 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:(02-02-2023, 08:06 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:(02-02-2023, 07:58 PM)Duffers Wrote: In the face of things this is exactly what has happened.
I find that sad, but I can only assume (if true) the victim would have agreed to it, and as such is happy with the 'justice' received.
I'm not sure why the charge can suddenly be dropped. Surely the police would have investigated, and gathered the majority of evidence they need to convict him, so why does it matter if the victim drops the charge, could the police not carry out the charge on the basis of gathered evidence?
The conclusion of this doesn't sit right with me.
Material witness decided to revoke her cooperation. In addition new evidence came to light.
The thing that always concerns me (I trained as a lawyer) is audio and video evidence captured by one party can have inherent bias and clipped accordingly.
No doubt he’s a bad egg. No doubt he’s a misogynist. The thing that stands out to me is the CPS statement that new evidence came to light.
This is interesting. How does the law work in such a criminal case? I understand that the police/prosecution lawyer would have spent their time since charges were brought gathering evidence. So my above question is what happens to that evidence? Surely someone else can step in and prosecute him, even if the victim drops a charge? Let's say the evidence 100% proves he is a rapist. Do we have a justice system that lets a rapist walk free, even with evidence?
I'm of course assuming he's guilty, without knowing what new evidence has come to light. But I'm still interested in the general question I'm asking.
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) have dropped the case as there is in their legal opinion a low probability of prosecution and therefore not in the public interest to pursue. Basically wasting tax payers money as they are highly confident the case will not end in successful prosecution.
In this case what has happened is firstly one of the material witnesses has recused themselves or probably more accurately will not support the case in court. We do not know who this is or why. However, the prosecution case is just that a case, until the evidence is heard and judged in court the accuracy and veracity of that witness is untested - until that point it’s an opinion of the prosecution (CPS) that their evidence supports a successful conviction. By removing that evidence, whoever they were or whatever they knew it weakened their legal opinion and thus their case.
Secondly, the new evidence is just an unknown. For example, the plaintiff could have changed their story, more audio or video could come to light, the reliability of the witness(es) could be challenged or something more sinister eg like in the case of Ched Evans where the alleged victim had accused different men using the same pattern and playbook - suggesting her story was untrue.
Either way, when the CPS looked at their evidence after these events, the loss of a witness and new evidence, their legal opinion changed and they no longer believed a conviction was possible. As such the charges were dropped.
That isn't what happend in the Ched Evans case. Two men miraculously came forward and said that the victim had said the same things during sex with them that she allegedly said during sex with Ched Evans, therefore Ched Evans couldn't be a rapist. Extremely iffy reasoning IMO
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016...-reporting


