Poll: Should Valerian Ismael be sacked?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes, sack him.
85.82%
121 85.82%
No, needs time yet.
14.18%
20 14.18%
Total 141 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Sack Val poll.
#61
(01-27-2022, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 09:41 AM)HeavyWoollenBaggie Wrote: No, if only because this shitshow merry-go-round of managers has to stop and I have less than zero confidence that the next managerial appointment would be any kind of improvement on this one.  End of the season  and review then for me.

That said, I fell asleep for the entire second half and probably would have done so had I been in the ground.  It's been a long time since I've been so bored with the Albion-£250 for train and match tickets for me and HWB Jnr on Saturday and I honestly have no idea why we are bothering other than the day out to London.  Shame there's a football match in the middle of it really.

1. How did you fall asleep? It was freezing.

2. Too late now but have you looked into split tickets? £250 seems extreme for two people off-peak even coming from West Yorks.

1.  I was in my living room !!!!

2. £60 for the match tickets and 2 bloody expensive train fares bought far too late in the day.   My fault, obviously.
Reply
#62
(01-27-2022, 12:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:25 PM)Lurker#3Short termism in football has been perfectly highlighted on here over 2 polls, 2 weeks apart. Wrote: 2 weeks ago the majority were in the "patience camp", today majority are in the "Booo hissss, Val out camp" (I know people haven't actually said boo hiss).

However I would like to know how many of the vote across the 2 polls were form the same poster? I would imagine the old bored tradition of things being more popular when they are bad may be playing a part. Birdy can you tell behind the scenes?

I voted out twice.

I don't want the revolving door, but equally how long does someone who is not doing their job well deserve to be given just to prevent the revolving door? That's what sways me, he can't be allowed to stay just because we don't want the revolving door. To me that is a daft and dangerous course. Some of us have said it looks like the players hate his style for a while, many more since last night have too... It's dangerous to leave that kind of thing in play.

You only have to listen to him and Sam last year to realise that teh players are not capable to carrying out instructions. 

I very much doubt Vals tactics are "Chip aimless balls forward, do not challenge, and do not run hard". In fact I think this the absolute opposite of his philosophy. 

Your opinion on this matter are consistent MD, and I respect that, but they do point towards short term success being the primary motive. If thats what matter to you as a fan, great, and it seems its what most demand. I am just different I guess.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#63
(01-27-2022, 12:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:25 PM)Lurker#3Short termism in football has been perfectly highlighted on here over 2 polls, 2 weeks apart. Wrote: 2 weeks ago the majority were in the "patience camp", today majority are in the "Booo hissss, Val out camp" (I know people haven't actually said boo hiss).

However I would like to know how many of the vote across the 2 polls were form the same poster? I would imagine the old bored tradition of things being more popular when they are bad may be playing a part. Birdy can you tell behind the scenes?

I voted out twice.

I don't want the revolving door, but equally how long does someone who is not doing their job well deserve to be given just to prevent the revolving door? That's what sways me, he can't be allowed to stay just because we don't want the revolving door. To me that is a daft and dangerous course. Some of us have said it looks like the players hate his style for a while, many more since last night have too... It's dangerous to leave that kind of thing in play.

You only have to listen to him and Sam last year to realise that teh players are not capable to carrying out instructions. 

I very much doubt Vals tactics are "Chip aimless balls forward, do not challenge, and do not run hard". In fact I think this the absolute opposite of his philosophy. 

Your opinion on this matter are consistent MD, and I respect that, but they do point towards short term success being the primary motive. If thats what matter to you as a fan, great, and it seems its what most demand. I am just different I guess.

I've said many times for me the primary motivation is to enjoy going to games again. That's my main area where I will always praise Bilic and Moore, between them they gave me pride and enjoyment back.

I've said elsewhere about the short term views, I honestly think promotion is a necessary evil in order to stop us doing a Blues / Derby. That's all. I actually quite enjoyed watching Preston last night.
Reply
#64
(01-27-2022, 12:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 12:25 PM)Lurker#3Short termism in football has been perfectly highlighted on here over 2 polls, 2 weeks apart. Wrote: 2 weeks ago the majority were in the "patience camp", today majority are in the "Booo hissss, Val out camp" (I know people haven't actually said boo hiss).

However I would like to know how many of the vote across the 2 polls were form the same poster? I would imagine the old bored tradition of things being more popular when they are bad may be playing a part. Birdy can you tell behind the scenes?

I voted out twice.

I don't want the revolving door, but equally how long does someone who is not doing their job well deserve to be given just to prevent the revolving door? That's what sways me, he can't be allowed to stay just because we don't want the revolving door. To me that is a daft and dangerous course. Some of us have said it looks like the players hate his style for a while, many more since last night have too... It's dangerous to leave that kind of thing in play.

You only have to listen to him and Sam last year to realise that teh players are not capable to carrying out instructions. 

I very much doubt Vals tactics are "Chip aimless balls forward, do not challenge, and do not run hard". In fact I think this the absolute opposite of his philosophy. 

Your opinion on this matter are consistent MD, and I respect that, but they do point towards short term success being the primary motive. If thats what matter to you as a fan, great, and it seems its what most demand. I am just different I guess.

I've said many times for me the primary motivation is to enjoy going to games again. That's my main area where I will always praise Bilic and Moore, between them they gave me pride and enjoyment back.

I've said elsewhere about the short term views, I honestly think promotion is a necessary evil in order to stop us doing a Blues / Derby. That's all. I actually quite enjoyed watching Preston last night.
I don't think it will be Blues/Derby, because Lai won't spunk his own cash (if he has any). It will be a self financed shit storm.
Reply
#65
(01-27-2022, 12:58 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I don't think it will be Blues/Derby, because Lai won't spunk his own cash (if he has any). It will be a self financed shit storm.

if anyone can, Lai can!
Reply
#66
A weird one! If he goes I would be dissaponted but also very relieved.

The squad needs an overhall and needs a footballing identity. We've gone Pullis (defensive) to Pardew (No fking idea) to BD (play from the back) to Billic (open and attacking) to BS (loans) to Val (direct pressing). What a fking shambles. Val seemed an ideal candidate to do this. Young, modern philosophy, keen to use academy, stands for no crap!

Unfortunately, his style of football and apparent inflexibility has split the fan base almost from day one and certainly from week 4. I owe my boy and nephew a day at the Hawthorns as part of a Christmas present but I've been avoiding it as I knew the crowd was about to turn. Not wanting to go to the football!! We all hoped Dike would be the catalyst for improvement and it's unlucky to lose him BUT should any club be that reliant on one player to make things work?

I'm still saying more time needed. For my readoning above HOWEVER this may be because I personally couldn't go last night as i have COVID and my stream dropped out. So I didn't actually watch the game. I can imagine the poor sods that went are literally left with no choice to make as it sounded awful.
Reply
#67
(01-27-2022, 12:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote:  I actually quite enjoyed watching Preston last night.

I see what you mean, but i would have preferred watching them beat someone else. Big Grin
Reply
#68
(01-27-2022, 07:17 AM)Squid Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 04:29 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I've turned to yes.

It's not going to work, it's a poor fit all round.

Shame, I like his principles and what he wants, and at another time may have been a good choice, right now, just doesn't work.

I'm probably here now. I think it's very sad because he's a decent bloke and our problems go much deeper. Much deeper. I also don't trust the decision-makers to make a decent decision with an even smaller budget.

We've effectively put all of our eggs into one basket - 4 year deal, squad full of good stats and minimal ability (or any ability is being coached out of them), youth team coached the same way, the law of diminishing returns (ever decreasing budget due to mistakes)... therefore for reasons of pragmatism than hope or performance, he has to stay.  And will stay imo.
Reply
#69
I think it would have been announced by now tbh. Unless we are trying to get his replacement sorted before any announcement?
Reply
#70
(01-27-2022, 01:29 PM)Peachy Wrote: I think it would have been announced by now tbh. Unless we are trying to get his replacement sorted before any announcement?

Agree - if it was going to be today it would have been by now.

Millwall it is then...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: