Today
#61
I'm biased because I heard our fans make racist comments about Moore in the Hawthorns. So I do think for a few there was an element of that with him because I heard it.
Reply
#62
(01-23-2022, 02:38 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 02:04 PM)richbaggie Wrote: It's not just Ronnie that hates him, I've got friends who can't stand him. They are so far entrenched in their view of him, we could win every game between now and the end of the season and they'd still want him out.

I am away at moment do missed yesterday and followed on twitter. It was very interesting to see the split. Neutrals (journo's) and pro ( or rather not anti Val) felt we played ok and 3 nil was very fair. The anti Val were saying it was the worst this season yet. It does feel like the hatred can cloud their judgement of what they watch.

Personally I don't understand the hatred, especially given some of the awful characters we've had as managers over the last few years. I do understand the dislike of the style but not the man. He votes across as a pretty decent bloke, who cares passionately.

This is what perturbs me.

In recent times we've had a manager who was called a liar by a high court judge, Alan "If you're the King, you can do anything Pardew and a manager who managed to be the subject of a newspaper sting and was sacked from the England job after one of the shortest ever tenures.

Yet it's Val who people detest and hate. Who is "clueless". Who isn't passionate, but "angry" (some of the comments after Cardiff were laughably hypocritical, if Slav did that, people would have loved it.).

It doesn't sit well with me and reminds me a lot of the stick Darren Moore got from day one.

To be clear. I am not saying there aren't valid criticisms of Val or Moore, there certainly is. But there is something about the tone and vitriol of those criticisms, the way both Moore and Val were spoken of as if they were a lower form of life which disturbs me. I don't think people realise they are doing it, but it's there. Interesting there was a reader comment in the E&D saying the same.

What tone and vitriol against Darren Moore?  He is a loved icon.  Regardiing Val, what "tone" and "vitriol"?  He was an unknown quantity but my recollection was one of optimism and based on football alone.  You keep making implied accusations against a large section of our supporters.  Back it up or please desist from slurring our supporters.

(01-23-2022, 03:06 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm biased because I heard our fans make racist comments about Moore in the Hawthorns. So I do think for a few there was an element of that with him because I heard it.
Really?  Well, sad and depressing but I didn't and could only have been a few.  I have never heard such stuff. The implication was, however, that the "tone" was/is of far greater significance than views held by a few cavemen.
Reply
#63
(01-22-2022, 09:14 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-22-2022, 08:56 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Personally I didn’t boo them off at half-time.  Did I sing… “your football is sh**”. Absolutely I did… as it is! 

I was bored.
I was frustrated. 

We had 71 min of crap to put up with, but 3-0 is exactly that….3-0. Pleased to see them off today. Now it’s all about if we can build on that today. Val couldn’t have wished for a better opponent to get a win under our belt. 

Doesn’t change my view on VI. I want him gone!  However I’m a WBA fan first and foremost so will always be pleased with a win. 

What I do find pathetic is people not accepting or understanding that people don’t like the footy or the manager.  I certainly have no issue with others liking Val, enjoying the football (mmm) and those who have come to accept he’s the right manager.   Each to their own. 

I hate everything about him (VI) and his style. 

Really pleased Grady showed up.
Robinson f***s me off no end trying to get the crowd going. After his unforgivable showing at QPR last week, keep your arms and gestures to yourself and focus on the job you’re paid to do. 

Livermore was excellent today. Top notch performance and a captains performance. 

Onto Preston….. another must win for me.  

See you Wednesday.

What a daft thing to say. There's no whiff of scandal about him (unlike other managers we've had), he's trilingual and has been willing to learn his trade as a manager in several countries. 

Dawn Astle full of praise for him taking time to talk to her today. The press find him polite and pleasant to deal with (unlike Nuno, whom they hated). 

He's giving the youth a chance and they seem to be doing well with their opportunities. 

I get that we've had some poor results. I get that the football isn't to everyone's taste, but some of the things people are saying about another human being are frankly disgusting.

Robinson f***s me off no end trying to get the crowd going. After his unforgivable showing at QPR last week, keep your arms and gestures to yourself and focus on the job you’re paid to do. 

He did focus, he had two assists in the short time he was on - game changer
Reply
#64
Never hated any of our managers. A far too emotive description. Though thoroughly disliked a few like Gould, later days Buckley, Little, Pardew, later days Pulis and Big Sam.
I'm really hoping Val gets it right even though I'm yet to be convinced by him; I quite like his passion for the team but needs to be more flexible and coach the attacking play much better than we have seen so far.
So, yesterday, eventually, was a good start at recapturing some form and momentum to challenge for second in this mediocre division (though Boro were dire).
But, we thought the Cov/Reading games were a reset before the mess of the Christmas and the New Year garbage so let's see how we have done by the time the Millwall game has finished.

Leicesterbaggie Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
RonnieWallwork Wrote:Personally I didn’t boo them off at half-time.  Did I sing… “your football is sh**”. Absolutely I did… as it is! 

I was bored.
I was frustrated. 

We had 71 min of crap to put up with, but 3-0 is exactly that….3-0. Pleased to see them off today. Now it’s all about if we can build on that today. Val couldn’t have wished for a better opponent to get a win under our belt. 

Doesn’t change my view on VI. I want him gone!  However I’m a WBA fan first and foremost so will always be pleased with a win. 

What I do find pathetic is people not accepting or understanding that people don’t like the footy or the manager.  I certainly have no issue with others liking Val, enjoying the football (mmm) and those who have come to accept he’s the right manager.   Each to their own. 

I hate everything about him (VI) and his style. 

Really pleased Grady showed up.
Robinson f***s me off no end trying to get the crowd going. After his unforgivable showing at QPR last week, keep your arms and gestures to yourself and focus on the job you’re paid to do. 

Livermore was excellent today. Top notch performance and a captains performance. 

Onto Preston….. another must win for me.  

See you Wednesday.

What a daft thing to say. There's no whiff of scandal about him (unlike other managers we've had), he's trilingual and has been willing to learn his trade as a manager in several countries. 

Dawn Astle full of praise for him taking time to talk to her today. The press find him polite and pleasant to deal with (unlike Nuno, whom they hated). 

He's giving the youth a chance and they seem to be doing well with their opportunities. 

I get that we've had some poor results. I get that the football isn't to everyone's taste, but some of the things people are saying about another human being are frankly disgusting.

Robinson f***s me off no end trying to get the crowd going. After his unforgivable showing at QPR last week, keep your arms and gestures to yourself and focus on the job you’re paid to do. 

He did focus, he had two assists in the short time he was on - game changer

Good point about focus as I think he does lack that throughout games and is very wasteful most of the time.
But, when he's tuned in, I really think we a have a quality player on our hands at this level but need it consistently from him.

MassDebater Wrote:
wba13 Wrote:What was wrong with the football today, we played it on the ground passed it around then used both wingbacks to get crosses in along with Kipre and Clark passing was excellent. As for Livermore he looked reborn. Also 2 of the 3 goals were excellent passes one from Robinson and one from Livermore. They did not deserve any boos on today’s performance.

Today's 'performance' was boring crap. Simple as that, at no point in the first 70 minutes did we really cause the worst defence in the league any problems at all.

The 'football style' has sucked the life out of the fans, today was more of the same, but we managed a Grady inspired win that makes things appear to be more rosy than they really are.

Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Well within your rights to make that statement of course.  But, simple question. WHY?   

Why do you hate everything about him?  Genuine question as I just don't get it.  I'm baffled by the animosity towards him.  Help me out?

Just giving it a bump as I'd really like to know.

Whilst I'm not the original poster here are my un-asked for answers:
He is useless, clueless and yet insists his way is the only way. He comes across as arrogant and like he had earned the right to behave how he does, yet he had a modicum of success at Barnsley, and then has turned us into the most boringly ineffective team that I have ever seen.

His 'tactics' are one dimensional. Even against a team that concedes at least 2 goals per game, we looked toothless. His changes today were forced by the injury to Dike (who looked like an expensive Hugill, but hey he got onto 3 crosses which is more than the rest have done all season). Grady, yes, you can claim tactical nous from Six for winding him up, came on and changed the game single handedly. Some of us know that Grady can do that and we don't rewrite history into saying he was an expensive mistake of a signing. Strangely today, Grady got to play like Grady can play, why? Enforced changes due to injury.

Fans are now almost celebrating beating Posh, like it's some sort of major proof that Six knows what he is doing. Simple fact of the matter, any decent side should be beating them.

One final thing, his 'football style' has alienated MANY fans that have gone in the past, the sheer amount of empty seats shows this. Blame Covid (odd that it never affected the attendees at its peak), or whatever, it's the utter lack of entertainment, that Six has bought in, that is leading to this feeling of animosity.

Not sure why that should affect (or why any of our fans would use that as an excuse) us yet no other club as our neighbours seem to have no trouble packing their stadia unfortunately.
Reply
#65
I wonder if we stumbled on a new position for Robinson, he was playing just in front of Livermore and played two wonderfully executed passes for two of the goals. With no Dike on Wednesday could we play Robinson a bit deeper. I doubt it but it could work.
Reply
#66
(01-23-2022, 07:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: I wonder if we stumbled on a new position for Robinson, he was playing just in front of Livermore and played two wonderfully executed passes for two of the goals. With no Dike on Wednesday could we play Robinson a bit deeper. I doubt it but it could work.
I genuinely think that if we persist with playing 3 wide players as strikers, one needs to play a tad deeper. I this is tried. JRod would be perfect in this role.
Reply
#67
There is some Johnson-esque world beating rewriting of history on this thread. Where were some of you when Pulis, Pardew and Allardyce were appointed? Pulis was hated from the moment he arrived by many on here. I’ve had several physical threats, verbal abuse and dubious bans to prove it. My crime was to defend his tenure when he was steering us to safety and comfortable midtable finishes, long before the wheels fell off. Allardyce similarly had ludicrous criticism thrown at him for not keeping us up with a top Championship side that only looked capable of competing in the Prem thanks to the players brought in during the January transfer window. Now some of his ardent critics are suggesting that 80% of the squad we had then and now aren’t good enough to get promoted but were expected to get results against midtable Prem teams.

We appointed a manager with a very marmite style of play. It was easy to predict that if results faltered there would be little if any patience by many fans. The fact we have a very decent squad, in a very weak Championship only adds fuel to the criticism when we are struggling against the likes of a financially crippled Derby etc.

I’m sure there are less savoury reasons for some peoples criticism but they will be in the minority. My personal opinion is this, if he gets us up he’s succeeded, if he doesn’t he’s failed. Ive said this about every manager since Megson when we have the advantage over other teams parachute payments allow. I see nothing unreasonable, inconsistent or hypocritical about this position, I can’t say that of others.
Reply
#68
As quite often Derek, nothing wrong with that at all.

I do remember too well, defending Pulis on here was akin to saying you murdered puppies.
Reply
#69
(01-23-2022, 02:38 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 02:04 PM)richbaggie Wrote: It's not just Ronnie that hates him, I've got friends who can't stand him. They are so far entrenched in their view of him, we could win every game between now and the end of the season and they'd still want him out.

I am away at moment do missed yesterday and followed on twitter. It was very interesting to see the split. Neutrals (journo's) and pro ( or rather not anti Val) felt we played ok and 3 nil was very fair. The anti Val were saying it was the worst this season yet. It does feel like the hatred can cloud their judgement of what they watch.

Personally I don't understand the hatred, especially given some of the awful characters we've had as managers over the last few years. I do understand the dislike of the style but not the man. He votes across as a pretty decent bloke, who cares passionately.

This is what perturbs me.

In recent times we've had a manager who was called a liar by a high court judge, Alan "If you're the King, you can do anything Pardew and a manager who managed to be the subject of a newspaper sting and was sacked from the England job after one of the shortest ever tenures.

Yet it's Val who people detest and hate. Who is "clueless". Who isn't passionate, but "angry" (some of the comments after Cardiff were laughably hypocritical, if Slav did that, people would have loved it.).

It doesn't sit well with me and reminds me a lot of the stick Darren Moore got from day one.

To be clear. I am not saying there aren't valid criticisms of Val or Moore, there certainly is. But there is something about the tone and vitriol of those criticisms, the way both Moore and Val were spoken of as if they were a lower form of life which disturbs me. I don't think people realise they are doing it, but it's there. Interesting there was a reader comment in the E&D saying the same.

You don't think Pulis or Pardew were hated? Big Grin

The things I read and heard about Pulis from our fans is far worse than anything with Val. Allardyce was very much disliked especially during the time when we were getting thrashed every week, I personally can't stand either bloke and hate that they managed us. 

Your comments about Val make no sense when he was very popular in his first few months. The simple fact is fans are frustrated with the style of football, lack of goals and poor form recently. To make it anything to do with race is out of order really.
Reply
#70
(01-23-2022, 07:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is some Johnson-esque world beating rewriting of history on this thread. Where were some of you when Pulis, Pardew and Allardyce were appointed? Pulis was hated from the moment he arrived by many on here. I’ve had several physical threats, verbal abuse and dubious bans to prove it. My crime was to defend his tenure when he was steering us to safety and comfortable midtable finishes, long before the wheels fell off. Allardyce similarly had ludicrous criticism thrown at him for not keeping us up with a top Championship side that only looked capable of competing in the Prem thanks to the players brought in during the January transfer window. Now some of his ardent critics are suggesting that 80% of the squad we had then and now aren’t good enough to get promoted but were expected to get results against midtable Prem teams.

We appointed a manager with a very marmite style of play. It was easy to predict that if results faltered there would be little if any patience by many fans. The fact we have a very decent squad, in a very weak Championship only adds fuel to the criticism when we are struggling against the likes of a financially crippled Derby etc.

I’m sure there are less savoury reasons for some peoples criticism but they will be in the minority. My personal opinion is this, if he gets us up he’s succeeded, if he doesn’t he’s failed. Ive said this about every manager since Megson when we have the advantage over other teams parachute payments allow. I see nothing unreasonable, inconsistent or hypocritical about this position, I can’t say that of others.
Nailed it Derek. Agree 100% with all of that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: