The Colston Four
#61
(01-06-2022, 01:43 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Currently there is one of those pesky experts some amongst dislike… after we’ve all had enough of them, on the radio.

He is giving explanations as to why the jury may have come to the conclusion they did. They seem perfectly acceptable reasons. If you want to find out why / what those were please listen to Shelagh Forgarty on LBC catch-up Thurs 6th Jan around five to ten minutes into the program.

Anyway related to this but not directly, a statue that celebrates a known slave trader could be argued to cause public offence / outrage surely?

Something causing public outrage / offence needs to be dealt with by the Police though. Vigilantes have never been allowed over here, as far as I know?

(01-06-2022, 01:33 PM)SophLad Wrote: Mandated???

Some fairly clear descriptions of slavery as seen by the bible on the wiki:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bible_and_slavery

The bad Biffs. Great yarn though, the Old Testament.
Reply
#62
(01-06-2022, 01:55 PM)SophLad Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:43 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Currently there is one of those pesky experts some amongst dislike… after we’ve all had enough of them, on the radio.

He is giving explanations as to why the jury may have come to the conclusion they did. They seem perfectly acceptable reasons. If you want to find out why / what those were please listen to Shelagh Forgarty on LBC catch-up Thurs 6th Jan around five to ten minutes into the program.

Anyway related to this but not directly, a statue that celebrates a known slave trader could be argued to cause public offence / outrage surely?

Something causing public outrage / offence needs to be dealt with by the Police though. Vigilantes have never been allowed over here, as far as I know?

(01-06-2022, 01:33 PM)SophLad Wrote: Mandated???

Some fairly clear descriptions of slavery as seen by the bible on the wiki:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bible_and_slavery

The bad Biffs. Great yarn though, the Old Testament.

Proper stuff in that Old testament, none of this wishy washy be nice stuff like the new one...
Reply
#63
(01-06-2022, 02:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:55 PM)SophLad Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:43 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Currently there is one of those pesky experts some amongst dislike… after we’ve all had enough of them, on the radio.

He is giving explanations as to why the jury may have come to the conclusion they did. They seem perfectly acceptable reasons. If you want to find out why / what those were please listen to Shelagh Forgarty on LBC catch-up Thurs 6th Jan around five to ten minutes into the program.

Anyway related to this but not directly, a statue that celebrates a known slave trader could be argued to cause public offence / outrage surely?

Something causing public outrage / offence needs to be dealt with by the Police though. Vigilantes have never been allowed over here, as far as I know?

(01-06-2022, 01:33 PM)SophLad Wrote: Mandated???

Some fairly clear descriptions of slavery as seen by the bible on the wiki:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bible_and_slavery

The bad Biffs. Great yarn though, the Old Testament.

Proper stuff in that Old testament, none of this wishy washy be nice stuff like the new one...

Yeah, bog off Jesus with that wokery.
Reply
#64
(01-06-2022, 01:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:34 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:10 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 12:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not sidestepping, you're arguing a false equivalence and suggesting this sets a precedent even though no jury decision can bind any other jury.

The context of the personal involvement of the individual, the context of the campaign to remove the statue and the frustrations, the context of the flashpoint that caused it being thrown are not transferable. That's why the jury would likely come to a different conclusion.
Glad you have clarified the pulling down a statue of a slave trader is more justifiable than the pulling down of statues of people responsible for the deaths of millions of Indians. 
And choosing glib responses until pushed to respond to the point at hand is sidestepping.

Glad that you have deliberately misread everything I wrote to suit your narrative and projected some complete bullshit.

The cheek to say I'm sidestepping!

I'm a bit confused how you could argue that i've suggested yesterdays result sets a precedence when i've actually argued that it doesn't as i said i am 99.999999% certain i would be convicted

The cheek to say i've deliberately misread everything you put!

You wrote: "Glad you have clarified the pulling down a statue of a slave trader is more justifiable than the pulling down of statues of people responsible for the deaths of millions of Indians."

Please, do quote me on where I wrote that.

I will quote where you implied that this sets a precedent: "Given today's verdict and all the stuff that happened in Britain and abroad under her rule, it can't be a crime?". What other context would "given today's verdict" possibly mean aside from in relation to setting a precedent?

So yes, I most certainly can argue that you wrote yesterday's result sets a precedent. As for why you wrote it (correct me if I'm wrong), I believe you wanted to complain about your scenario being treated differently to this through breaking the set precedent as to which I pointed out that it's a false equivalence, Queen Victoria is not Edward Colston, there are specific circumstances which contributed to that statue being thrown in the river which don't apply to your scenario and the basis of no jury being able to bind another jury, this act of jury nullification does not apply to any other decision by any other jury.

So no, I wasn't sidestepping anything.

How many times can you misread what i wrote?
Attached to the words you bolded were also the words "all the stuff that happened in Britain and abroad under her rule". That clearly states that there are also specific circumstances that could lead to the pulling down of statues of both Churchill and Queen Vic. Therefore it is reasonable to assume there is a moral equivalence between the Colston case and the scenario i proposed. That doesn't mean any judicial precedence has been set, merely that the 2 scenarios are so similar that it should be reasonable to expect the same result but that i had doubts that would happen in practice.
The fact it took a number of responses before you even addressed the point i was making does suggest you were sidestepping the issue.
Reply
#65
(01-06-2022, 03:08 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:34 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:10 PM)Sotv Wrote: Glad you have clarified the pulling down a statue of a slave trader is more justifiable than the pulling down of statues of people responsible for the deaths of millions of Indians. 
And choosing glib responses until pushed to respond to the point at hand is sidestepping.

Glad that you have deliberately misread everything I wrote to suit your narrative and projected some complete bullshit.

The cheek to say I'm sidestepping!

I'm a bit confused how you could argue that i've suggested yesterdays result sets a precedence when i've actually argued that it doesn't as i said i am 99.999999% certain i would be convicted

The cheek to say i've deliberately misread everything you put!

You wrote: "Glad you have clarified the pulling down a statue of a slave trader is more justifiable than the pulling down of statues of people responsible for the deaths of millions of Indians."

Please, do quote me on where I wrote that.

I will quote where you implied that this sets a precedent: "Given today's verdict and all the stuff that happened in Britain and abroad under her rule, it can't be a crime?". What other context would "given today's verdict" possibly mean aside from in relation to setting a precedent?

So yes, I most certainly can argue that you wrote yesterday's result sets a precedent. As for why you wrote it (correct me if I'm wrong), I believe you wanted to complain about your scenario being treated differently to this through breaking the set precedent as to which I pointed out that it's a false equivalence, Queen Victoria is not Edward Colston, there are specific circumstances which contributed to that statue being thrown in the river which don't apply to your scenario and the basis of no jury being able to bind another jury, this act of jury nullification does not apply to any other decision by any other jury.

So no, I wasn't sidestepping anything.

How many times can you misread what i wrote?
Attached to the words you bolded were also the words "all the stuff that happened in Britain and abroad under her rule". That clearly states that there are also specific circumstances that could lead to the pulling down of statues of both Churchill and Queen Vic. Therefore it is reasonable to assume there is a moral equivalence between the Colston case and the scenario i proposed. That doesn't mean any judicial precedence has been set, merely that the 2 scenarios are so similar that it should be reasonable to expect the same result but that i had doubts that would happen in practice.
The fact it took a number of responses before you even addressed the point i was making does suggest you were sidestepping the issue.

What, you mean the bit that also confirms that you're applying the same circumstances between the two scenarios? That somehow means you weren't implying it sets a precedent? Seriously? And I'm the one who misread what you wrote? You've basically just confirmed that I correctly inferred from what you wrote.

Why do you think that I said try it and find out? Because the core premise of this acquittal is the use of jury nullification, therefore no equivalence has been set in law and therefore no direct comparison can be made with anything in spite of your attempts. That is not sidestepping the point you were making, it is calling out your comparison of the situations.
Reply
#66
(01-06-2022, 03:04 PM)SophLad Wrote: Yeah, bog off Jesus with that wokery.

Top 'arfs, comment of the year so far for me Big Grin
Reply
#67
Its all about the posh kids having a new cause to fight & protest for

Slavery has gone on for 1000's of years & will most probably continue for 100's more

We as a civilised nation don't thankfully 

But modern examples can be found in Syria Iraq & other middle eastern countries 

On the home front many curry house restaurants & car washing stations use 'modern slaves' to do their work
Illegals that come over on the boats disappear into the black market economy 

If Tarquin wanted to raise the issue of slavery why didn't they smash the windows in the Star or Bengal 
Or raid Irish Traveller Sites that have used slaves to do work on farms or roads ?

Its widespread yet the plod don't like to talk about it much for fear of upsetting certain people
Bit like the kids in Rochdale a few years back

https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales...l-11393518
Heres one example
Reply
#68
(01-06-2022, 01:03 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 12:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Obviously good that they've not been sent to prison, but my god the names of the four of them are like something from a sketch show.

Milo Ponsford wouldn't have lasted five minutes inside.

Quite. It never ceases to amaze me how some white middle class folk get so outraged by their wholly unlived experience of structural racism.

Are middle class white people not allowed to be outraged by the slave trade?

If they were consistent they'd be far more offended by modern slavery, you know - shit that's actually happening now. I'd be far more impressed if they were boycotting and protesting against tech firms and the fashion industry with operations in Xinjiang, not getting their cars washed by Iraqi Kurds living in squalor, refusing to buy veg picked or prepared by labour under gangmasters etc.

If I'm honest this bunch of Tarquins remind me of the climate protestors who expect me and you to wear a hair shirt whilst ignoring President Xi. They can fuck off.
Reply
#69
The colston four? sounds like a brass band.
Reply
#70
(01-06-2022, 05:17 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 01:03 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 12:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-06-2022, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Obviously good that they've not been sent to prison, but my god the names of the four of them are like something from a sketch show.

Milo Ponsford wouldn't have lasted five minutes inside.

Quite. It never ceases to amaze me how some white middle class folk get so outraged by their wholly unlived experience of structural racism.

Are middle class white people not allowed to be outraged by the slave trade?

If they were consistent they'd be far more offended by modern slavery, you know - shit that's actually happening now. I'd be far more impressed if they were boycotting and protesting against tech firms and the fashion industry with operations in Xinjiang, not getting their cars washed by Iraqi Kurds living in squalor, refusing to buy veg picked or prepared by labour under gangmasters etc.

If I'm honest this bunch of Tarquins remind me of the climate protestors who expect me and you to wear a hair shirt whilst ignoring President Xi. They can fuck off.

Your post sounds very 'whataboutery'. Do you expect people who have an opinion on the slave trade to also not use an iPhone, Android phone? To buy organic veg, boycott Amazon, etc etc for them to have an opinion?

Re your President Xi comment, it's so nonsensical. How do you suggest that 4 people in Bristol confront the leader of the Chinese communist party?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: