Sweeping Generalisation
#61
(08-29-2020, 01:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: As an observation there are seven pages of engagement on this thread.

So your pathetic trolling OP is an attempt at engagement?

Engagement would be easier and more productive if you, for once, viewed the world as it is rather than through the prism of your own perceived moral and intellectual superiority.
Reply
#62
(08-29-2020, 04:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 01:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: As an observation there are seven pages of engagement on this thread.

So your pathetic trolling OP is an attempt at engagement?

Engagement would be easier and more productive if you, for once, viewed the world as it is rather than through the prism of your own perceived moral and intellectual superiority.

Proth I’m not taking lectures on humility off someone who consistently suggests that I’m intellectually, culturally and politically inferior to himself. As I said on the first line of the thread...

Before anyone gets upset and defensive this is clearly a sweeping generalisation. 

(08-29-2020, 03:13 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 02:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Why does this place so often descend into abuse just because of differing opinions? People slate twitter for this but there’s a lot on here that are no better. On all sides of any given argument.

Been this way for a long time  - more Propaganda than Politics board - often a thread isn't started to hear different views but to state a position as the only valid one and attack anyone who thinks different as thick or immoral etc - or so it seems - and we end up at this point time and time again.  

I guess Politics does that though and I'm sure I've been sucked into the cycle on here too often - and no doubt will be in the future, if I'm not careful! Perhaps this mirrors society and is why Twitter is the same.

Oh well. No one is forced to post on or read this board and you can see why many don't - footballers as pasta is an easier topic.

The politics board had about two or three posts a month for maybe the first twelve months when it first started. It was hardly booming with respectful debate or a queue to take part. Before that it was on the main board and got banished because it ended up with posters getting banned regularly and others moaning that the site should just be about football. 

This site has been renowned and enjoyed its reputation for petty sniping in its various incarnations since it’s Rivals days. It’s also seen people banned almost weekly, certainly monthly on the football side of the board. It seems a bit harsh to level criticism at the politics section when posters have been threatened for disagreeing about a player or manager on numerous occasions over the years etc. 

We have an adversarial political system and a divided country so it’s not surprising that there is a polarisation of opinion on here. It’s simply mirroring the current political discourse and landscape which is not conciliatory in victory or defeat. The only people who can alter that are the politicians and media but is that in their interest? I’d love the country to return to the centre of politics because nothing good comes from lurching too far to either the right or left.
Reply
#63
(08-29-2020, 06:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We have an adversarial political system and a divided country so it’s not surprising that there is a polarisation of opinion on here. It’s simply mirroring the current political discourse and landscape which is not conciliatory in victory or defeat. The only people who can alter that are the politicians and media but is that in their interest? I’d love the country to return to the centre of politics because nothing good comes from lurching too far to either the right or left.

Correct, and what I should have added in my previous post is that 'agendas', insofar as they exist at all, will inevitably gain more traction at a time when there is a vacuum where we would expect to find government.
Reply
#64
(08-29-2020, 06:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 04:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 01:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: As an observation there are seven pages of engagement on this thread.

So your pathetic trolling OP is an attempt at engagement?

Engagement would be easier and more productive if you, for once, viewed the world as it is rather than through the prism of your own perceived moral and intellectual superiority.

Proth I’m not taking lectures on humility off someone who consistently suggests that I’m intellectually, culturally and politically inferior to himself. As I said on the first line of the thread...

Before anyone gets upset and defensive this is clearly a sweeping generalisation. 

(08-29-2020, 03:13 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 02:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Why does this place so often descend into abuse just because of differing opinions? People slate twitter for this but there’s a lot on here that are no better. On all sides of any given argument.

Been this way for a long time  - more Propaganda than Politics board - often a thread isn't started to hear different views but to state a position as the only valid one and attack anyone who thinks different as thick or immoral etc - or so it seems - and we end up at this point time and time again.  

I guess Politics does that though and I'm sure I've been sucked into the cycle on here too often - and no doubt will be in the future, if I'm not careful! Perhaps this mirrors society and is why Twitter is the same.

Oh well. No one is forced to post on or read this board and you can see why many don't - footballers as pasta is an easier topic.

The politics board had about two or three posts a month for maybe the first twelve months when it first started. It was hardly booming with respectful debate or a queue to take part. Before that it was on the main board and got banished because it ended up with posters getting banned regularly and others moaning that the site should just be about football. 

This site has been renowned and enjoyed its reputation for petty sniping in its various incarnations since it’s Rivals days. It’s also seen people banned almost weekly, certainly monthly on the football side of the board. It seems a bit harsh to level criticism at the politics section when posters have been threatened for disagreeing about a player or manager on numerous occasions over the years etc. 

We have an adversarial political system and a divided country so it’s not surprising that there is a polarisation of opinion on here. It’s simply mirroring the current political discourse and landscape which is not conciliatory in victory or defeat. The only people who can alter that are the politicians and media but is that in their interest? I’d love the country to return to the centre of politics because nothing good comes from lurching too far to either the right or left.

I was on about the whole forum to be honest, not just the politics board. And I think it goes beyond petty sniping and well into abuse territory. I agree with your points about nothing good comes of lurching too far left and right. Trouble is I think abuse has that exact effect, on both sides.

Im not talking about strong opinion, it’s the name calling that I can’t get my head around, that’s all. It’s probably not that many posters tbh, just seems it when reading the forum sometimes.
Reply
#65
(08-29-2020, 07:51 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 06:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 04:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 01:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: As an observation there are seven pages of engagement on this thread.

So your pathetic trolling OP is an attempt at engagement?

Engagement would be easier and more productive if you, for once, viewed the world as it is rather than through the prism of your own perceived moral and intellectual superiority.

Proth I’m not taking lectures on humility off someone who consistently suggests that I’m intellectually, culturally and politically inferior to himself. As I said on the first line of the thread...

Before anyone gets upset and defensive this is clearly a sweeping generalisation. 

(08-29-2020, 03:13 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(08-29-2020, 02:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Why does this place so often descend into abuse just because of differing opinions? People slate twitter for this but there’s a lot on here that are no better. On all sides of any given argument.

Been this way for a long time  - more Propaganda than Politics board - often a thread isn't started to hear different views but to state a position as the only valid one and attack anyone who thinks different as thick or immoral etc - or so it seems - and we end up at this point time and time again.  

I guess Politics does that though and I'm sure I've been sucked into the cycle on here too often - and no doubt will be in the future, if I'm not careful! Perhaps this mirrors society and is why Twitter is the same.

Oh well. No one is forced to post on or read this board and you can see why many don't - footballers as pasta is an easier topic.

The politics board had about two or three posts a month for maybe the first twelve months when it first started. It was hardly booming with respectful debate or a queue to take part. Before that it was on the main board and got banished because it ended up with posters getting banned regularly and others moaning that the site should just be about football. 

This site has been renowned and enjoyed its reputation for petty sniping in its various incarnations since it’s Rivals days. It’s also seen people banned almost weekly, certainly monthly on the football side of the board. It seems a bit harsh to level criticism at the politics section when posters have been threatened for disagreeing about a player or manager on numerous occasions over the years etc. 

We have an adversarial political system and a divided country so it’s not surprising that there is a polarisation of opinion on here. It’s simply mirroring the current political discourse and landscape which is not conciliatory in victory or defeat. The only people who can alter that are the politicians and media but is that in their interest? I’d love the country to return to the centre of politics because nothing good comes from lurching too far to either the right or left.

I was on about the whole forum to be honest, not just the politics board. And I think it goes beyond petty sniping and well into abuse territory. I agree with your points about nothing good comes of lurching too far left and right. Trouble is I think abuse has that exact effect, on both sides.

Im not talking about strong opinion, it’s the name calling that I can’t get my head around, that’s all.

I think I’ve taken it too far on occasion on here and I did try and stop doing it but it’s easy to get dragged back into the name calling and nonsense. I will try again as it doesn’t actually make posting a pleasant experience on occasion. I apologise for my part in this and it takes someone who doesn’t engage in this side of the board as often to pull you up on it so thank you.

I don’t subscribe to the notion that what is posted is propaganda on here because that suggests that the stories are meant to influence when from a personal point of view most of my posts are in the main because of my sheer frustration at the political scene in this country. I’m biased and make no bones about that but so is everyone on here whether they admit it to themselves or not. 

I don’t like extremes in politics, lack of honesty, lack of responsibility or a lack of robust, transparent scrutiny of those that sought public office. I’m not sure why that should be so contentious or even naive wishes but it seems to be. I’ve said elsewhere the loudest voices currently are the two extremes of normal UK political spectrum, both of which bring with them very odd mix of interests I’ve outlined in the first few replies in this thread. For example who would have thought that a mass gathering in London today would see David Icke applauded for a speech about anti-vax, anti-mask conspiracy theories, but that’s where we are as a nation. He was a fringe individual now he’s sharing a platform with others attracting thousands of people. Until moderates in the centre who have pragmatic rather than ideological solutions to societal problems are heard as loudly as those to the right or left we shall see more division and real propaganda in our politics.
Reply
#66
Think Brexit is great
Dislike Meghan Markel 
Dislike face masks, and very anti-lockdown
Think Covid 19 is a hoax or just the flu
Support the Conservative’s without question 
Have British, US, Israeli avatars 
Want to ‘Defund the BBC’
Refuse to trust mainstream media but trust random blog and dubious social media links / ‘facts’
Think the climate change is a hoax or not that bad


From this original list I noted with interest it seems to suggest that people against masks, lockdown etc want to defund the BBC and don't trust mainstream media.

Is it that much of a surprise that on a day when a fair few thousand marched through London there is absolutely zero mention of it on Sky News or the BBC? Ironically the BBC website has a story about a similar march in Berlin but seems to have overlooked one in our own country. 
Reply
#67
(08-29-2020, 09:55 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: From this original list I noted with interest it seems to suggest that people against masks, lockdown etc want to defund the BBC and don't trust mainstream media.

Is it that much of a surprise that on a day when a fair few thousand marched through London there is absolutely zero mention of it on Sky News or the BBC? Ironically the BBC website has a story about a similar march in Berlin but seems to have overlooked one in our own country. 

There was a lovely three paragraph article about a dead Cornish cat, mind.
Reply
#68
[Image: 4PpHMJSlQ3CfjYTLHI2I_mail-sun-front_1598734959_001.png]

[Image: 12sMzkXTEKR5lF0qr8vg_a4-independentdigit...30_001.png]


Metro ...

[Image: PRC_162653115.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&z...C252&ssl=1]

A weekend in U.K.
Reply
#69
(08-29-2020, 08:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Until moderates in the centre who have pragmatic rather than ideological solutions to societal problems are heard as loudly as those to the right or left we shall see more division and real propaganda in our politics.

I think I'm pretty moderate. Modest tax, sound money, small state, individual liberty.

Unfortunately we live in an era where every political party in the UK is high tax, modern monetary theory (printing money) big state and authoritarian.

I don't think it's a question of left v right anymore, it's more a split of those who're happy with the state undermining the concept of money as a store of value  and being in virtually every aspect of our lives, and those (like me) who'd rather they emptied the bins and left us alone.

For the first time in my adult life, I truly think we're fucked as a nation.
Reply
#70
(08-30-2020, 09:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: [Image: 4PpHMJSlQ3CfjYTLHI2I_mail-sun-front_1598734959_001.png]

[Image: 12sMzkXTEKR5lF0qr8vg_a4-independentdigit...30_001.png]


Metro ...

[Image: PRC_162653115.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&z...C252&ssl=1]

A weekend in U.K.
Of course there isn’t a Guardian front page today to compare. But you can get this in the Mail’s online site

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article...ondon.html

There are more pages to a printed paper than the front one. Do you know what is in the insides?
Still doesn’t explain why there is no mention anywhere on the Beeb’s site.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: