Housing Policy
#51
(02-12-2020, 02:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 02:20 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: Putting all cakes on the table and going back to the original title of this thread; why can't we have a housing policy which starts with a rule that you are responsible for your own housing rather than the state? This being with fairness in mind to the elderly, sick or any adult unable to care for themselves. Why should a local authority pick up the cost of housing someone?

Possibly because we are not starting from a level playing field. Look at it from both ends of the spectrum, the youth of today have a starting average house price of nearly £300k and an average salary of around £30k. When I started out in the 90s I had a salary of £15k on a house of £45k which was just about affordable, kids today haven't got a chance unless they take out debt for a lifetime.

Then you could look at the elderly, my old man served his country in the war, paid all of his taxes throughout his life and was promised cradle to the grave care. Unfortunately that didn't happen and he ended up having to pay for something he didn't buy into. My uncle, a bevan boy no less, is facing having to sell his house to pay for any care. He was hoping to leave his house to his grandkids to start them off in life (see above).

Then there are people who, through no fault of their own, can't work, what should they do?

Social housing worked through the 50s, 60s and 70s because it mixed different types of people together to provide a community and provide a foot on the ladder for people to move on from. On the estates where I grew up there were policemen, nurses, factory workers and all other trades together. Kids grew up watching folk go to work and set the norm to aspire to. Nowadays, because there are so few houses available the majority all go to those in greatest need and we have created sink estates where no-one works and kids see folk getting away with life without going to work and, lo and behold, they aspire to that.

And one important point in all of that, the local authority isn't picking up the full bill because the tenants would pay rent.

There is, and has been since the financial crisis, a very simple solution for this. Finance public housing by issuing bonds to institutions and individuals paying a long term 3% coupon. With interest rates so suppressed the pension funds would be all over this as would savvy individuals seeking fixed income. You'd raise billions.
Reply
#52
One point with that is the cost of funds for the local authorities and having to pay out that dividend on an annual basis from the income statement. Now if the government did that and provided a 'National House Service' without penalising LAs then you might be onto a winner although how they managed the distribution of funds is another matter (Boris does have his favourites doesn't he). Asking LAs to manage that whilst making cuts elsewhere is not going to happen.
Reply
#53
(02-13-2020, 10:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: One point with that is the cost of funds for the local authorities and having to pay out that dividend on an annual basis from the income statement. Now if the government did that and provided a 'National House Service' without penalising LAs then you might be onto a winner although how they managed the distribution of funds is another matter (Boris does have his favourites doesn't he). Asking LAs to manage that whilst making cuts elsewhere is not going to happen.

I wouldn't have the local authorities anywhere near housing. Drive it via housing associations - far more efficient users of funds.
Reply
#54
(02-13-2020, 12:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-13-2020, 10:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: One point with that is the cost of funds for the local authorities and having to pay out that dividend on an annual basis from the income statement. Now if the government did that and provided a 'National House Service' without penalising LAs then you might be onto a winner although how they managed the distribution of funds is another matter (Boris does have his favourites doesn't he). Asking LAs to manage that whilst making cuts elsewhere is not going to happen.

I wouldn't have the local authorities anywhere near housing. Drive it via housing associations - far more efficient users of funds.

That I will disagree with you on having investigated them in my time across the midlands. Another artificial construct that we could do without. Corrupt, badly run and nepotistic in the extreme were what I found.
Reply
#55
(02-13-2020, 01:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Corrupt, badly run and nepotistic in the extreme were what I found.

Imagine what would happen if their funding were overseen by the FCA rather than, say, the government...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: