Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
No one can fault his effort. However, he is not a goal scoring centre forward. He is instinctive but not quality when putting away half chances and some gilt edged ones either.
His benefit as a goal scoring forward is low but his presence and play benefits others around him.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-07-2026, 10:15 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (09-07-2026, 10:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:41 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I think, yet again, the sanctimony of the "elite", needs to be reigned in. Maybe actually read the first line of the thread and the subsequent responses. Heggebo has received far more praise than criticism, yet some still "need" to come across as superior.
Just accept all players have strengths and weaknesses, the only time I can see any merit in overly criticising players is if they aren’t putting in any effort, or they’ve stopped doing the things they are good at. Again.
You seem to focus entirely on his strengths and refer to anyone calling out his weaknesses as "braindead". Maybe take your own advise.
Do you think for one second that Mozza, Gill and co. are not looking at ways to improve Heggebo's goal output? Of course they are, as, I'm sure, is the man himself.
It’s simple, he gets chosen to play because of his strengths not his weaknesses. I’m sure he and the coaches will be working to improve his overall game, but he’s never going to become a prolific goalscorer, more a 9-10 goal a season centre forward.
Posts: 30
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2026
Reputation:
0
The contrast between the Charlton and Watford games is pretty clear.
v Charlton, the wing play was rapid and exciting but each time they got within 10 yards of the goal line, they'd turn around and play back to the midfield as the centre backs were able to drift over towards the wing of attack and close off.
v Watford, Heggebo was occupying at least one of the CBs and, while he may not have got on the end of any crosses (which were either behind him or 3 yards in front of him), keeping the CB in the middle of the park allowed the winger to have more options.
He takes a bit of a pounding from defenders but it allows the wingers and midfielders to do their thing. Very valuable.
When at Falkirk, Barney played in a 4-2-3-1 as the one; doing pretty much the same thing, running defenders around the pitch and allowing the midfielders to get into goal scoring positions, as well as being a goal scoring threat himself.
I would be asking Heggebo to run himself into the ground for 70 minutes and, just as he's beginning to tire and the defenders are getting comfortable, bring on Barney with fresh energy to do more of the same. At least it would demoralise the defenders or force a defensive substitution by the oppo.
Posts: 701
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
6
I cant think of a goal that he has scored where he has had multiple touches - however i do feel that he is given extra attention by most Defenders because of the task he conducts in the team.
That said, when he has scored, most have them have been really good goals from good play and he has had great off the ball movement.
Posts: 8,004
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(09-07-2026, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-07-2026, 10:15 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (09-07-2026, 10:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-07-2026, 09:41 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I think, yet again, the sanctimony of the "elite", needs to be reigned in. Maybe actually read the first line of the thread and the subsequent responses. Heggebo has received far more praise than criticism, yet some still "need" to come across as superior.
Just accept all players have strengths and weaknesses, the only time I can see any merit in overly criticising players is if they aren’t putting in any effort, or they’ve stopped doing the things they are good at. Again.
You seem to focus entirely on his strengths and refer to anyone calling out his weaknesses as "braindead". Maybe take your own advise.
Do you think for one second that Mozza, Gill and co. are not looking at ways to improve Heggebo's goal output? Of course they are, as, I'm sure, is the man himself.
It’s simple, he gets chosen to play because of his strengths not his weaknesses. I’m sure he and the coaches will be working to improve his overall game, but he’s never going to become a prolific goalscorer, more a 9-10 goal a season centre forward. I will re-iterate the first line of the thread for clarity:
"Better with him starting, just gives us better shape"
Most people have endorsed this view so not sure who exactly is braindead.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
I also reject the line that Heggebo's role in the team is to score goals - his role in the team is to help the side win matches. I would sooner he went the entire season without scoring a single goal but we won every match than Heggebo get 20 and we get relegated.
I know it's an extreme example, but football is more complex than strikers are poor if they don't get 20 goals.
Heggebo scores the amount of goals he should score from the number of chances he gets, and he does so at a rate above average for the division he's playing in. On top of this his duels, ball winning, pressing and hold up play numbers are amongst the best in the division.
Last season he scored 10 because we didn't fashion enough chances for him.
His chance against Watford had an xG of 0.5 meaning it's 50/50 if a striker finishes it, and on target of 0.84. He got it on target and their keeper made a save. It wasn't a horrendous miss, it was a good chance that their keeper saved. A poor striker wouldn't have got it on target.
Does he have weaknesses? Sure... but if he was managing to score 20 goals in a team last season he'd have cost 40M not 4M.
Posts: 8,004
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(09-07-2026, 11:18 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I also reject the line that Heggebo's role in the team is to score goals - his role in the team is to help the side win matches. I would sooner he went the entire season without scoring a single goal but we won every match than Heggebo get 20 and we get relegated.
I know it's an extreme example, but football is more complex than strikers are poor if they don't get 20 goals.
Heggebo scores the amount of goals he should score from the number of chances he gets, and he does so at a rate above average for the division he's playing in. On top of this his duels, ball winning, pressing and hold up play numbers are amongst the best in the division.
Last season he scored 10 because we didn't fashion enough chances for him.
His chance against Watford had an xG of 0.5 meaning it's 50/50 if a striker finishes it, and on target of 0.84. He got it on target and their keeper made a save. It wasn't a horrendous miss, it was a good chance that their keeper saved. A poor striker wouldn't have got it on target.
Does he have weaknesses? Sure... but if he was managing to score 20 goals in a team last season he'd have cost 40M not 4M. I'm sure that is still the aim of him and the coaches, for this season, and that's the point that's being missed. A lot of the criticism being cited doesn't actually exist on the thread. Instead it is more an acknowledgement of his strengths and value to the team, but that should not mean improvement shouldn't be sought and the only way to seek improvement is to identify weaknesses.
I'm sure there are conversations going on, between the player and his coaches, along the lines of " Doing great Aune, workrate amazing, good movement, but we want to find a way of increasing your goal contribution"
Yet, someone infers the same on here and they know fuck all about football!
|