Reyes Cleary
#51
(01-14-2026, 11:37 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(01-14-2026, 09:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(01-14-2026, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik

O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.

Wasn't Tim I released?  Or is that someone else?  I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.

Who is DVB?

In this instance, Morgan Rogers (who is/was an Albion fan).

Just looked up Roger’s Wikipedia and it says he never actually played for us but I’m sure he came on as a sub, at least once or have I dreamt it?
Reply
#52
So after all that....

Tim I - headhunted by them lot

Field O'Shea, Palmer sold (After all had played for the first team)

Cleary - we offered a new contract (apparently according to his Wiki) he decided to go to Barnsley instead.

I'm not actually remembering who Taylor is / was...

So, not so much we didn't give them chances, just that most were deemed surplus to requirements or we needed the money for them....

We need a better list of youths who weren't given a chance...
Reply
#53
Again people just ignore what's said and respond the argument to nothing, so I'm out.
Reply
#54
Is there really six pages of debate over a kid we had for years, couldn't get in under half a dozen mangers and was let go without ever scoring a league goal?

The way some are going on we've let the next Messi go, rather than a kid who has 5 goals in 22 games for Barnsley.
Reply
#55
Cleary of course left us twice and the first time he came back because there were no other takers. I don’t think we did much wrong and it was always possible he would eventually catch up somewhat on lost potential
Raw Sausage
Reply
#56
There are quite a few who have been able to "catch up somewhat on lost potential"

The argument is we have let far too many young players go without giving them a chance and/or sold too cheaply .
Reply
#57
I agree but just wouldn’t say Cleary was anywhere near the top of that list
Raw Sausage
Reply
#58
(01-14-2026, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: Is there really six pages of debate over a kid we had for years, couldn't get in under half a dozen mangers and was let go without ever scoring a league goal?

The way some are going on we've let the next Messi go, rather than a kid who has 5 goals in 22 games for Barnsley.

He wasn’t let go he turned down a new contract.he left of his own accord.
Reply
#59
His explosiveness and finishing for the U18s and then U23s was fantastic and easily enough to know that there was a player worth investing in. Which we did as we continued to offer him new contracts.

Cleary was very unfortunate in the timings of his injuries with us. Just when it looked like he might get opportunities with other players out he picked up a nasty injury. That's primarily the reason why he didn't get more chances for us. There was talk over a "Billy Big Bollocks" attitude when his contract ran out and he was potentially looking for another club but he ended up signing with us so I'm not sure how true that was.

Then when he finally overcame his injury he joined Walsall which some claim wasn't good but he found himself behind the Stoke lad who was on fire. Quite rightly he opted for another loan to get minutes and ended up at Hartlepool. This is where things finally seemed to happen for him. The manager played him as a left wing back/left forward, he played every game and was brilliant for them with goals and assists and a strong work ethic. Their manager claimed he was going to be a top player.

And here in lies my issue. We had an option for a further year last summer but didn't exercise it. Just at a time when he was really starting to prove himself. After all that investment we'd made surely another year on peanuts money made sense?

Obviously he's now gone to league one, been great, and is now being heavily linked to Championship clubs so we are potentially missing out on valuable money as that could have been coming out way had we loaned him to Barnsley instead of letting him walk.

Azaz is the other one we really dropped the ball on. We apparently offered him a contract but by the time we did he'd become so disillusioned with the lack of opportunities he decided to jump ship. Villa snapped him up, put him straight out on loan and made a nice turn on him. Then he becomes a £10m player.

The long and the short of it is, like Birdy says, we have to get better at giving our very best identified youngsters first team football at 18/19 and see how they fair. Once you have done that you then sort the wheat from the chaff. Who's good enough to stay amongst it, who's not quite ready but get them out on loan etc.

It ain't rocket science and is surely what Bilkul want us to do given our lack or resources and their moneyball approach.
Reply
#60
If we even think a aher MIGHT, MIGHT make it with us at 17 we must at least give them a debut and a couple of games, see how they fare mentality and physically. That gives them a path to get in and stay in the team.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)