Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
12-18-2024, 05:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 05:19 PM by GunsOfNavarone.)
(12-18-2024, 05:07 PM)Jacko Wrote: (12-18-2024, 04:09 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (12-18-2024, 11:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Still 55% of the season to go. It's still fair too early to judge.
Heggem is clearly a success. I'm pretty sure Styles will be, too.
We all know what Johnston is capable of, so I won't be told that's a poor signing, because absolutely no one questioned it at the time. In fact - it was the opposite. Everyone was buzzing. Ditto Holgate. So that's 4 signings right off the bat I would deem good and sensible.
With regards to Racic, Diakite, and Cole. They've not really figured much, but I've seen glimpses in their play to suggest each one could be a good or solid player given a run of games to allow them to get up to speed. But they simply need more time to judge.
Dobbins, jury is very much out.
Frabotta - bizarre. Good CV, but has seemingly been frozen out.
In summary, too early to judge. 4 good signings, 3 signings where you need more opportunity to judge. 2 apparent busts, but similarly they need more opportunity.
Also, I seem to recall most reasonable people agreed we had an excellent summer, transfer business wise. I still believe that to be the case.
Frabotta has played for 10 clubs yet never played more than 22 games for any of them. He could do with staying with one club for sometime
A bit disingenuous. 7 of these were loans. He's played for Bologna, Juve and now us as parent clubs. As an example Leicester City were Chris Wood's 10th club, after 6 loan spells from us. 23 games on loan at Blues was his most.
We need to try Frabotta at centre forward..... just in case  .
Posts: 26
Threads: 4
Joined: May 2024
Reputation:
1
Probably get a load of abuse on here as I put on socials, but I’ll put on here too.
Merry Christmas to everyone. Including the moaners ?
Sure as night follows day the owners are now getting stick
What is it people don’t get?
They’ve come in and told us straight what will happen and they’ve done exactly what they’ve said.
We had no choice but to get bodies in. We were well short, and the pool we were fishing in I think we’ve done pretty well.
We’ve now as a fanbase made our mind up about players after less than half a season.
This wasn’t a quick fix. They’ve done what they said and have done a lot more than any of us thought was possible in one transfer window.
There’s no silver bullet. There never was. These players we bought in were always going to be gambles.
There’s a saying about paying peanuts. For every Heggem there’ll be a Frabotta.
That’s where we are.
We’re not a Premier League club with Premier League money anymore. We’re fighting with one hand tied behind our back because of PSR.
I trust them implicitly to get it right, but as they said when they came in, it will take time.
If you don’t like or understand that I’m not sure what can be said.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(12-18-2024, 05:23 PM)SedgleyAlbion Wrote: Probably get a load of abuse on here as I put on socials, but I’ll put on here too.
Merry Christmas to everyone. Including the moaners ?
Sure as night follows day the owners are now getting stick
What is it people don’t get?
They’ve come in and told us straight what will happen and they’ve done exactly what they’ve said.
We had no choice but to get bodies in. We were well short, and the pool we were fishing in I think we’ve done pretty well.
We’ve now as a fanbase made our mind up about players after less than half a season.
This wasn’t a quick fix. They’ve done what they said and have done a lot more than any of us thought was possible in one transfer window.
There’s no silver bullet. There never was. These players we bought in were always going to be gambles.
There’s a saying about paying peanuts. For every Heggem there’ll be a Frabotta.
That’s where we are.
We’re not a Premier League club with Premier League money anymore. We’re fighting with one hand tied behind our back because of PSR.
I trust them implicitly to get it right, but as they said when they came in, it will take time.
If you don’t like or understand that I’m not sure what can be said.
Darn right.
Posts: 13,570
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(12-18-2024, 05:23 PM)SedgleyAlbion Wrote: Probably get a load of abuse on here as I put on socials, but I’ll put on here too.
Merry Christmas to everyone. Including the moaners ?
Sure as night follows day the owners are now getting stick
What is it people don’t get?
They’ve come in and told us straight what will happen and they’ve done exactly what they’ve said.
We had no choice but to get bodies in. We were well short, and the pool we were fishing in I think we’ve done pretty well.
We’ve now as a fanbase made our mind up about players after less than half a season.
This wasn’t a quick fix. They’ve done what they said and have done a lot more than any of us thought was possible in one transfer window.
There’s no silver bullet. There never was. These players we bought in were always going to be gambles.
There’s a saying about paying peanuts. For every Heggem there’ll be a Frabotta.
That’s where we are.
We’re not a Premier League club with Premier League money anymore. We’re fighting with one hand tied behind our back because of PSR.
I trust them implicitly to get it right, but as they said when they came in, it will take time.
If you don’t like or understand that I’m not sure what can be said.
This ay Twatter mon
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(12-18-2024, 05:23 PM)SedgleyAlbion Wrote: Probably get a load of abuse on here as I put on socials, but I’ll put on here too.
Merry Christmas to everyone. Including the moaners ?
Sure as night follows day the owners are now getting stick
What is it people don’t get?
They’ve come in and told us straight what will happen and they’ve done exactly what they’ve said.
We had no choice but to get bodies in. We were well short, and the pool we were fishing in I think we’ve done pretty well.
We’ve now as a fanbase made our mind up about players after less than half a season.
This wasn’t a quick fix. They’ve done what they said and have done a lot more than any of us thought was possible in one transfer window.
There’s no silver bullet. There never was. These players we bought in were always going to be gambles.
There’s a saying about paying peanuts. For every Heggem there’ll be a Frabotta.
That’s where we are.
We’re not a Premier League club with Premier League money anymore. We’re fighting with one hand tied behind our back because of PSR.
I trust them implicitly to get it right, but as they said when they came in, it will take time.
If you don’t like or understand that I’m not sure what can be said. Not sure the owners are getting any stick though.
A bit contradictory as well as you criticise others for judging new players, then refer to Frabotta as a “monkey” , as the saying goes.
Posts: 26
Threads: 4
Joined: May 2024
Reputation:
1
(12-18-2024, 05:53 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (12-18-2024, 05:23 PM)SedgleyAlbion Wrote: Probably get a load of abuse on here as I put on socials, but I’ll put on here too.
Merry Christmas to everyone. Including the moaners ?
Sure as night follows day the owners are now getting stick
What is it people don’t get?
They’ve come in and told us straight what will happen and they’ve done exactly what they’ve said.
We had no choice but to get bodies in. We were well short, and the pool we were fishing in I think we’ve done pretty well.
We’ve now as a fanbase made our mind up about players after less than half a season.
This wasn’t a quick fix. They’ve done what they said and have done a lot more than any of us thought was possible in one transfer window.
There’s no silver bullet. There never was. These players we bought in were always going to be gambles.
There’s a saying about paying peanuts. For every Heggem there’ll be a Frabotta.
That’s where we are.
We’re not a Premier League club with Premier League money anymore. We’re fighting with one hand tied behind our back because of PSR.
I trust them implicitly to get it right, but as they said when they came in, it will take time.
If you don’t like or understand that I’m not sure what can be said. Not sure the owners are getting any stick though.
A bit contradictory as well as you criticise others for judging new players, then refer to Frabotta as a “monkey” , as the saying goes.
They’re getting stick for the recruitment. The Frabotta comment was based on him not making hardly any appearances. That might have more to do with him being from a foreign country and settling in. As somebody reminded me, we hardly saw Molumbu for 6 months while he got used to English football. I was referring to players not being oven ready to compete at the top half of the Championship
Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
12-18-2024, 06:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 07:03 PM by albion_pigeon.)
Racic - shit
Johnston - shit
Styles - exactly what we needed
Maja - boss
Cole - waste of space (and money)
Frabromboli - jury's out
Heggem - Boss, not sure what his best position is though, seems better at LB to me
Diakite - two left feet
McNair - dogshit
Posts: 480
Threads: 7
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
7
12-18-2024, 07:22 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 07:25 PM by B68Baggy.)
(12-18-2024, 06:59 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Racic - shit but cost nowt. Gamble. All talent no engine.
Johnston - shit but might be good again. Paid cash, but how could we not??
Styles - exactly what we needed. BaRGAIN
Maja - boss. Been ere ages Pigde
Cole - waste of space (and money). Cost nowt, worth nowt but fustrating this one. Why?
Frabromboli - jury's out. Gamble. Cost nowt.
Heggem - Boss, not sure what his best position is though, seems better at LB to me. BaRGAIN.
Diakite - two left feet. Gamble. Cost nowt. Might come good?
McNair - dogshit. Looked very tidy then crocked. Cost less than nowt.
When I say cost nowt....I mean in the context of modern football. We know they all probably get paid more in a month than i do in a year but no capital outlay and I dont imagine there were huge agent fees flying about either.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(12-18-2024, 05:23 PM)SedgleyAlbion Wrote: Probably get a load of abuse on here as I put on socials, but I’ll put on here too.
Merry Christmas to everyone. Including the moaners ?
Sure as night follows day the owners are now getting stick
What is it people don’t get?
They’ve come in and told us straight what will happen and they’ve done exactly what they’ve said.
We had no choice but to get bodies in. We were well short, and the pool we were fishing in I think we’ve done pretty well.
We’ve now as a fanbase made our mind up about players after less than half a season.
This wasn’t a quick fix. They’ve done what they said and have done a lot more than any of us thought was possible in one transfer window.
There’s no silver bullet. There never was. These players we bought in were always going to be gambles.
There’s a saying about paying peanuts. For every Heggem there’ll be a Frabotta.
That’s where we are.
We’re not a Premier League club with Premier League money anymore. We’re fighting with one hand tied behind our back because of PSR.
I trust them implicitly to get it right, but as they said when they came in, it will take time.
If you don’t like or understand that I’m not sure what can be said.
About right. Modern football fans, eh.
Posts: 7,409
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Pinched this off .com, normally a very reliable source.
To be fair to Dood there is some truth in what he says.
Dobbin certainly is likely to go back, Racic we would like to get rid of but there are penalty fees.
If we can sign another centre half then expect Frabotta to be loaned out too, McNair obviously goes to America pretty soon.
We are desperate to shift Grady and Swift, ideally both but one for definite in January, the issue is they can sit tight and become free agents in the Summer, so we would likely have to waive a chunk or all of any transfer fee we may of got to pay the and get rid of them.
There is abit of tit for tat at the moment, there is supposed to be a few different departments invovled in transfers, Howver CC used the credit he has to bring Dobbin in solely on his recommendation, we never expected to get Johnston but then we had bonus funds and he became available, the club were hoping to get another striker and leave some extra funds for January but CC really pushed for Johnston so we put all out eggs in that basket, thus making the Dobbin signing earlier inthe window not really needed.
Unfortunately as it stands neither Dobbin or Johnston halfway through the season have really hit any sort of form, so with Dobbin likely to go its not a great reflection on CC's transfer calls.
On the flipside to that, CC had said he wanted another left back and dynamic midfielder in the summer and Nestor used the fact CC had bypassed the process to sign Dobbin to do the same thing and sign Frabotta and Racic, they are both solely on him and again its fair to say they havent worked out.
Nestor supposedly did it to make a point he is the main main, he had already held fire with CC contract talks (as far as i know that is still the case, i was told if there are contract talks they are top top secret, more than any other time)
I was told that Nestor is relaxed about CC leaving as he wants the club to change its setup and approach, it may not happen right now if CC goes, but the next manager choice after that will be a bit leftfield oversea coach and not one of the usual names trotted out, it may even happen this time but after the upheaval the last year or so it would be 50:50 whether we went with the leftfield or a proven english coach.
Nestor supposedly has a certain way of doing thigns which has had previous success (i dont know a lot about him but thats what i was told) and going forward we will identify certain types of player profile and then get coaches to work with that rather than letting Coaches dictate things)
As a side note if CC is still in charge in January, expect a loan signing off Chelsea (if the others in the process approve it!)
|