Are we a boring team now?
#51
(10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.

I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games. 

Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.

It's worth pointing out the the research and stats based "Val-Ball" approach had us 5th in the league, while the "I reckon I know best because I've had 1000 games in management, so I'll go with my gut" approach from Bruce-Ball took us into the bottom 3.
Reply
#52
(10-06-2024, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.

I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games. 

Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.

It's worth pointing out the the research and stats based "Val-Ball" approach had us 5th in the league, while the "I reckon I know best because I've had 1000 games in management, so I'll go with my gut" approach from Bruce-Ball took us into the bottom 3.
No it’s not worth pointing out.

Val ball had been found out and the results had fallen off a cliff. We were in bottom 6 form for about 10 games.

He was an appalling appointment on a stupid contract.

The fact Bruce was even more rubbish doesn’t change anything.

Anyway this is about now and how we are as a team.

Corberan has a lot of good will in the bank despite the poor week we’ve had.
Reply
#53
(10-06-2024, 10:26 PM).Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.

I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games. 

Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.

It's worth pointing out the the research and stats based "Val-Ball" approach had us 5th in the league, while the "I reckon I know best because I've had 1000 games in management, so I'll go with my gut" approach from Bruce-Ball took us into the bottom 3.
No it’s not worth pointing out.

Val ball had been found out and the results had fallen off a cliff. We were in bottom 6 form for about 10 games.

He was an appalling appointment on a stupid contract.

The fact Bruce was even more rubbish doesn’t change anything.

Anyway this is about now and how we are as a team.

Corberan has a lot of good will in the bank despite the poor week we’ve had.

Of course it does.

Everyone was bleating on here about how 'playing to the percentages doesn't matter' and 'any half decent manager will have us promoted'. Obviously both were a load of bollocks and having that squad 5th in the league was an achievement in hindsight.

The point is "I reckon this is what will get results, I'm just going to use my eyes" doesn't work. Luckily neither our owner nor current manager have that philosophy.
Reply
#54
Both Ishmael and Bruce poor appointments by our incompetent Chinese owners. Thankfully they got Corbs in and he’s been brilliant.
Reply
#55
When the opposition park the bus you have to move the ball quickly and prevent them all getting lined up. We are giving them far too much time. Carlos can be stubborn and refuse to push on, I can't say this approach is wrong as we're still flying high. I don't see the promotion door being open for us unless we add more to our game.
Reply
#56
(10-06-2024, 10:47 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 10:26 PM).Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The thing with relying on stats to prove or justify any tactic or selection is humans aren’t robots and form is not an exact science. The human element of the game is what makes it interesting, It’s what separates it from more formulaic, technical sports, it’s why relying on them too heavily leads to Val-Ball ineffectiveness once found out.

I don’t share the view that teams cannot mix tactics up because the games too fast. It’s hardly beyond the wit or ability physical and mental to ask the team to hit longer down the channels or speed the play up. If you can change formation you can change other elements within the management of games. I keep hearing we can bring Dike in as a battering ram. If this is true it’s going to take an eternity to get the player anywhere near the door let alone knock it down in some games. 

Also going back to the point about set pieces, whether create enough of them or not is a moot point when we are so poor at them relatively speaking, given the types of players we have at our disposal. That is something than can and should be improved pn regardless of how difficult it may or may not be to change other elements of the game as it unfolds.

It's worth pointing out the the research and stats based "Val-Ball" approach had us 5th in the league, while the "I reckon I know best because I've had 1000 games in management, so I'll go with my gut" approach from Bruce-Ball took us into the bottom 3.
No it’s not worth pointing out.

Val ball had been found out and the results had fallen off a cliff. We were in bottom 6 form for about 10 games.

He was an appalling appointment on a stupid contract.

The fact Bruce was even more rubbish doesn’t change anything.

Anyway this is about now and how we are as a team.

Corberan has a lot of good will in the bank despite the poor week we’ve had.

Of course it does.

Everyone was bleating on here about how 'playing to the percentages doesn't matter' and 'any half decent manager will have us promoted'. Obviously both were a load of bollocks and having that squad 5th in the league was an achievement in hindsight.

The point is "I reckon this is what will get results, I'm just going to use my eyes" doesn't work. Luckily neither our owner nor current manager have that philosophy.

Apologies sliced. I’d misread your post. I’ve reread it and totally agree. I’d initially thought you were defending Valball.

This has been a very decent discussion and the general consensus is we need to take more risks in the final 3rd. Saturday was totally lacking in imagination.

As has been said the so called highlights demonstrate just how rubbish we were for a team with 83 percent possession. Even a few shots from
25-30 yards might have seen a deflection past the keeper or a ricochet falling to one of our players in the area.

Instead we were tipping and tapping around and creating no chances at all.
Reply
#57
I don't find the way Carlos sets us out boring, but we do need to create more chances at home by moving the ball quicker and moving more off the ball.

It hasn't helped that the wide men have been nullified the last couple of games. We're having a dip in form, but I'm confident King Carlos will turn it around. An early goal in a game and it changes the approach the opposition have to take. We need to really attack for the first 15 or 20 minutes, and come out swinging, before we then take a more measured approach.
Reply
#58
If you want boring look at the opposition, Pulis would have been proud of that shower of shit. That's the problem though, we are a big fish and teams will come here and put men behind the ball, so we have to find a way of combatting that. Currently, our main M.O seems to be getting the ball wide, but it's too predictable now and teams with limited ambition can afford to double up on the wingers.
We need someone who can carry the ball through the middle to draw defenders, which Grady does brilliantly but just doesn't know when to release and when he does his passing is often not good enough. Swift is the opposite in that he is slower on the ball and doesn't really take players on, he can, however pick a pass. We need a hybrid of the two. Long term, Racic may be the answer, but, at the minute he's struggling with the pace of the Championship IMO. I would be tempted to drop Racic back with Mulumby and push Mowatt forward, when teams sit in.
Reply
#59
(10-06-2024, 03:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 03:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 02:35 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 02:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You can’t really compare Racic and Molumby’s stats to that of Diangana they are being asked to play very different roles. Grady loses the ball consistently in whichever position he’s asked to play, I appreciate that picking the ball up offensively centrally is going to lead to more mistakes as you have less time on the ball, space and time to appreciate what’s going on around you but I don’t see Diangana offering more than sporadic moments of class at best.

I didn't want to limit the comparison to just Swift, as I am making the point about the balance of the team against stubborn, unambitious opponents.

Grady is the only true '10' we have, and those sorts of players are most important when trying to break deep blocks down.

It’s a bit of cliche to say you need a tricky/fast footed number 10 to perform a moment of skill to unlock a defence sitting deep and putting men behind the ball. Particularly if we are saying Diangana is that player to be able to do this consistently, something he’s not achieved since he signed permanently. 

One of best opportunities to unlock a stubborn team showing little sign of attacking ambition is to make the most of set pieces and we are not great at them despite having some big and powerful players in the team. More should be done on this aspect of our game no matter how unfashionable it is. Also patiently building from the back hoping forlornly that a team suddenly abandons its game plan and piles players forward inevitably leads to ludicrous levels of possession but very little in dangerous areas. 

This isn’t a criticism of CC really, it’s more about the formulaic, group think around contemporary coaching. There is very little variety of play, teams play out from the back, playing little triangles with the keeper, when that fails to produce any space ideas dry up as teams fail to have any other way of playing.

I don't particularly disagree with both of these points. It's interesting to see however that we have the 6th lowest number of players being fouled which count as a shot creating action. Which shows we are not drawing enough fouls in dangerous areas, when teams are sat in deep. 

We are also 15th in the league for 'Takes Ons Attempted', and 14th in terms of general number of fouls against. 

So whilst we need to improve our output from set pieces we need to increase the number of offensive dead ball opportunities we create. And it is this which calls for 'tricky, fast footed, forwards'. 

Number of fouls against our players this season per 90:

Grady - 2.38
Fellows -1.69
Wallace - 1.58
Furlong - 1.56

Those are the fouls actually given Smile

Seems like Fellows has been fouled many more times each game than that.

Agree about how poor we look on set pieces this season. 
So many corners and Furlong throws yet so poor at get first to balls in the box.
Millwall seemed to win 95% of all headers in the box in Saturday.
Reply
#60
(10-07-2024, 07:55 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you want boring look at the opposition, Pulis would have been proud of that shower of shit. That's the problem though, we are a big fish and teams will come here and put men behind the ball, so we have to find a way of combatting that. Currently, our main M.O seems to be getting the ball wide, but it's too predictable now and teams with limited ambition can afford to double up on the wingers.
We need someone who can carry the ball through the middle to draw defenders, which Grady does brilliantly but just doesn't know when to release and when he does his passing is often not good enough. Swift is the opposite in that he is slower on the ball and doesn't really take players on, he can, however pick a pass. We need a hybrid of the two. Long term, Racic may be the answer, but, at the minute he's struggling with the pace of the Championship IMO. I would be tempted to drop Racic back with Mulumby and push Mowatt forward, when teams sit in.

At the start of the season this wasn't the case. We had a much lower number of crosses per 90 than we did last season and we were getting our rewards. 

The last 3 games our number of crosses has gone up and thus our xG and the quality of our opportunities and approach play has been poorer. 

This is why I would shift Fellows to RWB against tough, deep, unambitious teams. It would allow him to arrive later into those crossing positions, which may mean we've commited more men forward which would increase the chances of a successful delivery.

Regarding CM. I think when we come up against a Millwall we need to look at Styles alongside Mowatt. He seems capable of picking a neat pass and certainly has an eye for a long range dig too.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: