Ratings…
#51
I wonder whether Nathan Jones was able to do so well at Luton because it was a young side and willing to hear/listen/bend to his will and ideas. At Stoke the team was full of a lot of older experienced pros who may have just thought they didn't fancy what he wanted them to do and/or didn't rate his lack of experience against their own.

As for Bruce, he has been there and done it as a player - albeit a long tine ago - so it's unlikely players can profess to know more about the game than he does. Also he's clearly no shrinking violet and I suspect his being in their faces at half time was distinctly unpleasant for those on the receiving end. It's clear he can and will kick arses and for me that does make me a little more hopeful about his slowly realising who he thinks is up for the fight.

More than willing to admit I might be wrong but the players he's brought in did well and it will be interesting to see who he picks in front of the defence when Okay is fit. I'd like to think we won't need two holding players but who knows?
Reply
#52
(08-01-2022, 09:32 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 12:20 AM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(07-31-2022, 11:40 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Nathan Jones a better manager than Bruce?? Big Grin

Well, he outperformed him last season and with what most people would say was a weaker squad. Bruce’s only success in recent years was taking Villa into the bottom half of the Championship ( well,I consider that a success!) We have a squad capable of at least a top 6 finish - I fear we have a manager who isn’t.

If he outperforms Bruce this season then you'll have a point. Bruce had Val's squad last season. Now he's starting to get his own players in. Funnily enough two of our better attacking players on Saturday were Bruce signings and MOTM was a player Val had sitting on the bench until Bruce came in.

In terms of Bruce's recent success, he finished 12th and 13th in the Premier League with Newcastle and did a good job in the little time he was at Sheff Wed (only lost 3 in 18 games). Also Villa were a mess before he came in and he got them to a play off final although the following season obviously wasn't as successful. I understand some of the criticisms of Bruce but some seem to want to ignore the success he has had because it doesn't fit their agenda.

He’s simply not fashionable enough for some of our fans.
Reply
#53
(08-01-2022, 11:52 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I wonder whether Nathan Jones was able to do so well at Luton because it was a young side and willing to hear/listen/bend to his will and ideas.  At Stoke the team was full of a lot of older experienced pros who may have just thought they didn't fancy what he wanted them to do and/or didn't rate his lack of experience against their own.

I think Jones may have hinted at this after he left. Certainly wouldn't surprise me. There may have been something similar here with Val. Although he played for Bayern!
Reply
#54
(08-01-2022, 11:52 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I wonder whether Nathan Jones was able to do so well at Luton because it was a young side and willing to hear/listen/bend to his will and ideas.  At Stoke the team was full of a lot of older experienced pros who may have just thought they didn't fancy what he wanted them to do and/or didn't rate his lack of experience against their own.

As for Bruce, he has been there and done it as a player - albeit a long tine ago - so it's unlikely players can profess to know more about the game than he does.  Also he's clearly no shrinking violet and I suspect his being in their faces at half time was distinctly unpleasant for those on the receiving end.  It's clear he can and will kick arses and for me that does make me a little more hopeful about his slowly realising who he thinks is up for the fight.

More than willing to admit I might be wrong but the players he's brought in did well and it will be interesting to see who he picks in front of the defence when Okay is fit.  I'd like to think we won't need two holding players but who knows?

Jones walked on water at Luton…. The squad did everything he asked and he had total control over every inch of the club. Stoke were a mess and have proved to be a managerial graveyard for the past decade really. 

If Bruce were to leave, I’m not sure Jones is who I’d want as we have a “strong” dressing room that I think would soon spit him out for making them press and run. However, for him to finish in the playoffs with the smallest budget in the league, I’d certainly be more excited about having him oversee us next summer should we stay down than I would Bruce for instance.

Given their levels of experience and budgets, it’s hard to compare but I’d wager had Bruce had Luton’s squad they wouldn’t have made the playoffs but had Jones had ours I’d expect us to have been better than 10th.
Reply
#55
(07-30-2022, 06:50 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Button 6 Kicking shit but ok, feel more comfortable with balls in the box than Johnstone
Furlong 2 Awful for far too long now
Ajayi 8 Excellent, especially second half
OShea 7 Struggled a bit 1st half but superb 2nd
Townsend 7 Very disciplined, held his position and dropped in when Ajayi got forward
Livermore 4 Timing is shot so constantly off the pace and his passing as poor as ever
Molumby 5 Passenger 1st half, better 2nd but can't play him and Livermore together
Swift 6 Great goal but didn't get enough of the ball due to the inability of Livermore and Molumby to find him on a regular basis
Wallace 8 Very good debut, keep him fit and we will always have a chance
Phillips 3 Offered nothing going forward and failed to cover the woeful Furlong
Grant 4 Out of position and it showed, anonymous

Dike 7 Looks a beast although a bit raw, but I remember when that was said about Big Cyrille
Diangana 5 Needs too much time on the ball

Bruce 4 Terrible starting 11 which warranted a 1, but pulled it back slightly with his half time team talk

When you consider the shambles of last season and the 'performances' some of the above put in on Saturday, it doesn't bode well.  

Hopefully when things settle down we'll have Dike up top, Grant wide left, Okay a new RB (O'shea could play there if we get Clarke back). 

We still need more in central midfield and a couple of forwards to replace Robinson and Zohore who we just need to get rid of and bite the financial bullet - must be absolutely stinking the place out on his 26k a week.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)