Poll: Should Valerian Ismael be sacked?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes, sack him.
85.82%
121 85.82%
No, needs time yet.
14.18%
20 14.18%
Total 141 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Sack Val poll.
#51
(01-27-2022, 09:41 AM)HeavyWoollenBaggie Wrote: No, if only because this shitshow merry-go-round of managers has to stop and I have less than zero confidence that the next managerial appointment would be any kind of improvement on this one.  End of the season  and review then for me.

That said, I fell asleep for the entire second half and probably would have done so had I been in the ground.  It's been a long time since I've been so bored with the Albion-£250 for train and match tickets for me and HWB Jnr on Saturday and I honestly have no idea why we are bothering other than the day out to London.  Shame there's a football match in the middle of it really.

1. How did you fall asleep? It was freezing.

2. Too late now but have you looked into split tickets? £250 seems extreme for two people off-peak even coming from West Yorks.
Reply
#52
(01-27-2022, 07:50 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: I couldn't see him improving the situation in the last poll. I certainly can't now...

This. I was secretly hoping he would prove me wrong as it would mean we were enjoying some success but there is no chance of this IMO. Even the win against Posh that seemed to stir The Clappers into action was a very poor show. I have followed the Albion since 1968 Nd have been watching regularly via one method or another since that time. I have never seen us play so consistently poorly at any time during this period and yes that includes Buckley and Little.
Reply
#53
Anyone know what the results of the other poll were in comparison? Does 1 one way and 1 one the other mean we've actually voted to keep him?
Reply
#54
Was heavily keep him last time. 2 weeks it's swung to this...
Reply
#55
(01-27-2022, 12:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Was heavily keep him last time. 2 weeks it's swung to this...

Last I saw it was almost spot on 66% keep and 33% go. Boris will shit himself when he sees how quickly things can change.

(01-27-2022, 12:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Was heavily keep him last time. 2 weeks it's swung to this...

Last I saw it was almost spot on 66% keep and 33% go. Boris will shit himself when he sees how quickly things can change.
Reply
#56
(01-27-2022, 11:57 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: I have followed the Albion since 1968 Nd have been watching regularly via one method or another since that time. I have never seen us play so consistently poorly at any time during this period and yes that includes Buckley and Little.

Oh come on, that's gross hyperbole. During that time we got relegated winning just 4 games in 85-86, got relegated to the old Div 3, lost 5-1 at home to Crewe, lost 4-2 at home to Woking and managed to throw away a two goal lead against Port Vale at home, with them scoring the first goal when they had 10 men and the second when they had 9.  We were always poor under Pulis, but were so defensive that we managed to scrape 1-0's as per his godawful modus operandi.

Those are just a handful of examples, there are plenty more. We've just broken the club record for unbeaten home games from the start of the season and are still in a play-off place, so saying it's been the worst ever in over 50 years is simply not true.
Reply
#57
(01-27-2022, 12:19 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 11:57 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: I have followed the Albion since 1968 Nd have been watching regularly via one method or another since that time. I have never seen us play so consistently poorly at any time during this period and yes that includes Buckley and Little.

Oh come on, that's gross hyperbole. During that time we got relegated winning just 4 games in 85-86, got relegated to the old Div 3, lost 5-1 at home to Crewe, lost 4-2 at home to Woking and managed to throw away a two goal lead against Port Vale at home, with them scoring the first goal when they had 10 men and the second when they had 9.  We were always poor under Pulis, but were so defensive that we managed to scrape 1-0's as per his godawful modus operandi.

Those are just a handful of examples, there are plenty more. We've just broken the club record for unbeaten home games from the start of the season and are still in a play-off place, so saying it's been the worst ever in over 50 years is simply not true.

Little had a cracking start to one season and did that unbeaten run thing... thing is those kinds of records mean jack all if you're just scraping draws...

Fulham have lost more at home than we have, yet they took more points.

I'm with Swag, this has been the worst football in decades.
Reply
#58
I was out, now I'm out, out!

I honestly think his sacking will be like a weight's been lifted all around the club, not least the players. His style seems to have been dictatorial, which just doesn't translate to modern business and rightly so.
The next bloke has to simply come in and lift the players that he has, look at their strengths and weaknesses and develop a plan that gets the best from them.

Val's tenure can be summed up with one simple metaphor.
Imagine him trying to knock a square peg (his system) into a round hole (the squad) over and over again. Same peg, same hole, same hammer over and over and over again, with everyone around him looking on in bemused bewilderment, giving inconspicuous nods at the round peg which is in easy reach, but not having the guts to tell him.
Last night's crowd reaction was a communal, final straw, outpouring of "Use the fucking round peg you fucking imbecile, it's right fucking there!!"
Reply
#59
Short termism in football has been perfectly highlighted on here over 2 polls, 2 weeks apart.

2 weeks ago the majority were in the "patience camp", today majority are in the "Booo hissss, Val out camp" (I know people haven't actually said boo hiss).

However I would like to know how many of the vote across the 2 polls were form the same poster? I would imagine the old bored tradition of things being more popular when they are bad may be playing a part. Birdy can you tell behind the scenes?
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#60
(01-27-2022, 12:25 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I was out, now I'm out, out!

I honestly think his sacking will be like a weight's been lifted all around the club, not least the players. His style seems to have been dictatorial, which just doesn't translate to modern business and rightly so.
The next bloke has to simply come in and lift the players that he has, look at their strengths and weaknesses and develop a plan that gets the best from them.

Val's tenure can be summed up with one simple metaphor.
Imagine him trying to knock a square peg (his system) into a round hole (the squad) over and over again. Same peg, same hole, same hammer over and over and over again, with everyone around him looking on in bemused bewilderment, giving inconspicuous nods at the round peg which is in easy reach, but not having the guts to tell him.
Last night's crowd reaction was a communal, final straw, outpouring of "Use the fucking round peg you fucking imbecile, it's right fucking there!!"

I do believe you win the internet for today...Great analogy. Hit the round peg firmly on the head I think.

Hearing him speak and everything it's hard to see him as a dictator, but it certainly seems like it must be something like that. Although it sounds like SJ and certainly Snodgrass didn't mind telling him. (Although he's said Sj will play again in 2 games time, how oddly specific is that?!)

(01-27-2022, 12:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Short termism in football has been perfectly highlighted on here over 2 polls, 2 weeks apart.

2 weeks ago the majority were in the "patience camp", today majority are in the "Booo hissss, Val out camp" (I know people haven't actually said boo hiss).

However I would like to know how many of the vote across the 2 polls were form the same poster? I would imagine the old bored tradition of things being more popular when they are bad may be playing a part. Birdy can you tell behind the scenes?

I voted out twice.

I don't want the revolving door, but equally how long does someone who is not doing their job well deserve to be given just to prevent the revolving door? That's what sways me, he can't be allowed to stay just because we don't want the revolving door. To me that is a daft and dangerous course. Some of us have said it looks like the players hate his style for a while, many more since last night have too... It's dangerous to leave that kind of thing in play.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: