05-17-2021, 08:21 PM
(05-17-2021, 03:33 PM)steviedm Wrote:(05-17-2021, 12:57 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:(05-17-2021, 07:24 AM)steviedm Wrote:(05-17-2021, 12:25 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm a committed supporter of VAR because i firmly believe it is important to arrive at the correct decision - but days like today are hugely dispiriting. The decision to disallow the goal was rotten, imO
So you genuinely believe VAR arrives at the correct decision? In a game as subjective as football, it's never going to happen. The majority of VAR decisions could easily be given the other way and there'll be arguments on both sides. It's just kicking the can down the road and asking someone miles away to adjudicate. VAR also largely supports original decisions and doesn't have the balls to overturn them so what's the point? If it worked, yesterday would have seen our goal given by VAR once it was established Allison's view was not impeded and possibly their first goal would be ruled out due to the ref allowing them to take a free kick incorrectly. In the women's Champions League final, the penalty awarded by the ref early on was clearly a shit decision yet again VAR did nothing to correct the error. Let the game be played as it always has been. Refs and linos will make mistakes, we'll berate them, it won't even itself out but at least we'll be spared this absolute monstrosity of a system.
Majority of decisions could easily be given the other way? I don't think so. Some yes. But the more they get right, surely that's a good thing. I think there was an instance at the weekend where Anthony Taylor awarded a penalty and VAR told him to look again and he reversed it.
The problem with VAR is the rules and the people applying them. I'd give it 5 seasons and allow them the chance to refine the system. It's far from perfect but I do think it's a bit better than last season.
And as for this idea that these things even out across the season, do you really believe that? Whether consciously or subconsciously, I think some refs are biased in favour of the big clubs (Webb and Styles spring immediatelyto mind). Plus their mistakes used to get scrutinised every week in the TV studios so I think it's only fair they are aided by video technology in trying to make the right decision.
Clearly not as my original post reads 'it won't even itself out'.
I watch a lot of non-league football these days (well, before lockdown) and I see some absolutely horrendous decisions. The players and managers have a moan at the time and then just get on with it. The games tend to have one very wide camera so looking at incidents again later doesn't add much to the debate. Everyone accepts that mistakes get made but none are deliberate just incompetent or a matter of interpretation. One man's good tackle is another man's sending off - the rules can say what they want but the bottom line is that there are different interpretations and different levels of football apply different standards. There's more tolerance in the non-league game - lower levels of skill lead to more honest errors by players when tackling but they also don't generally scream like two years old when someone gives them a slight nudge.
VAR is going nowhere and at the top level will no doubt be finessed but there'll still be issues like yesterday's. The irony is that the linesman flagged and without VAR everyone would have been pissed off for a bit and cursing his ineptitude but it would've been more easily accepted. VAR just compounded the error.
I'm also sure that offside calls can be as objective as a ball over the line or many of the calls in cricket. The trouble is, if it means developing the game so that there are regular stoppages so someone can draw some lines on a screen to determine whether someone's big toe is further forward than someone else's arse while fans are unable to celebrate then I'm afraid I'm out and off to watch some proper football instead.
The final irony is that if VAR was brought in to sort out contentious decisions and resolve debates then it's done exactly the opposite. It may just be my perception but it seems to have at least doubled the number of arguments about decisions. When it was originally mooted years ago, I was all for it and annoyed when Sepp Blatter said it'd never be brought in. Lampard's non-goal in the World Cup changed that but I realised from the moment I first saw it used in the Liverpool v Albion cup game that it takes away pretty much everything I've always loved about football.
Apologies for misrepresenting you.
I acknowledge fans concerns about numerous stoppages and I also don't like the drawn lines. I still like it to be given a few more years to see if it can be refined. I'd like to see it used only at the request of the captain and limited to say 2 lives per match, like in cricket. Ditching it just plays back into the big clubs hands.


