Photo ID to be needed to vote in future
#51
(05-11-2021, 11:24 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Picking up a parcel, opening a bank account and instructing a solicitor aren't democratic rights, do not involve the interference of the state and do not cost the taxpayer money.

You could never be secure in the knowledge, the only way to be secure that you won't get caught is if they aren't registered to vote and if they aren't registered to vote you literally can't impersonate them to vote as they aren't registered to vote. The compounding of the probability of the variables makes it a basically nil chance of it working and there's basically no evidence of in person voter fraud ever being an issue despite 150 years of the system we have being deployed.

OK. We'll agree to disagree.

Just an interesting aside, the MP Nick De Bois reported to Parliament in 2011 that in the immigration cases coming through his constituency office more than 15% of those were on the electoral roll when they had no right to be there.
Reply
#52
Having to give basic details and names being crossed-off a list as they vote really isn't the deterrent he thinks it is. Yes, the number of allegations of personation are low but how many go undetected?

It is crazy that you need to give more information to join a library and take a book out in future than to vote.

It would have saved so much time had he not gone on these circuitous routes to try to maintain his argument when he know he has none.

Think this will be my last visit to this thread, there's no point trying to debate an issue with someone like that.
Reply
#53
(05-11-2021, 12:09 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Having to give basic details and names being crossed-off a list as they vote really isn't the deterrent he thinks it is.

It would have saved so much time had he not gone on these circuitous routes to try to maintain his argument when he know he has none.

Think this will be my last visit to this thread, there's no point trying to debate an issue with someone like that.

The fact that you've come to this conclusion and ignored all the other checks, balances and variables that I listed shows you've got no argument. How am I supposed to debate with someone that is quite obviously ignoring most of what I've said and bringing up the same thing over and over again despite the fact that I've reiterated other variables that you've not addressed? Fuck me.

(05-11-2021, 11:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
Just an interesting aside, the MP Nick De Bois reported to Parliament in 2011 that in the immigration cases coming through his constituency office more than 15% of those were on the electoral roll when they had no right to be there.

Were they EU citizens registered with the electoral commission for European Elections, Commonwealth citizens or Irish citizens?
Reply
#54
(05-11-2021, 12:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How am I supposed to debate with someone that is quite obviously ignoring most of what I've said and bringing up the same thing over and over again despite the fact that I've reiterated other variables that you've not addressed? Fuck me.

I don't think you've really addressed the point that activists like you and me had access to the marked register. This allows activists, year on year to mark the people who never vote. It's not a great leap of imagination that the unscrupulous might use that data for nefarious purposes, is it?
Reply
#55
I did address that point, I referenced to the point about certainty as likelihood to vote doesn't mean certainty to vote (hence me repeatedly talking about the only way to be certain someone isn't going to vote is that they're not registered to vote) on top of the anecdote about my mate who never voted but decided to vote last week because he was bored as evidence that those who usually don't vote and are registered to vote are always not going to vote.
Reply
#56
No - you have not explained how someone knowing someone else's details is prevented from attempting personation and prevented from succeeding if the person being personated doesn't vote (if they are registered). You also have not explained how anyone attempting it or succeeding it will be traced and prosecuted.

I keep bringing it up because you haven't answered apart from to keep uttering 'functional impossibility'.
Reply
#57
(05-11-2021, 12:39 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: No - you have not explained how someone knowing someone else's details is prevented from attempting personation and prevented from succeeding if the person being personated doesn't vote.

As I have already said:

They need to know they are registered to vote.

They need to know they haven't voted.

They need to know they won't vote.

They need to know the polling station they they're on the register of.

Then there's the obvious stuff that apply to all types of fraud like making sure you're not recognised, making sure you don't blab etc.

When you compound the probability of those variables you end up with essentially nil. That's why it's functionally impossible.

You also have not explained how anyone attempting it or succeeding it will be traced and prosecuted.

Why would I? It's irrelevant, the issue over traceability is to do with the ballots which are numbered based on the register so they can be traced. Prosecution lies with standard procedure for all crimes, that's the case with or without ID. It doesn't change.

I keep bringing it up because you haven't answered apart from to keep uttering 'functional impossibility'.

Yes I did, you just ignored what I said about the other variables and latched onto that variables that you perceive, giving your name and address, and not that ones you don't perceive because those processes are not in your control.
Reply
#58
You really haven't explained it.

1. People may know frieeds/family are registered to vote from orevious discussions as to how they voted
2. They may know that the person concerned is not going to and/or hasn't voted from a conversation
3. They know the person's details
4. They know the polling station used. It may even be the same as their own if they love close-by

What stops that person a) attempting it and b) succeeding if the person being personated hasn't voted?

You haven't explained how the personater will be traced and caught. It isn't irrelevant as this was a factor that you claimed earlier in the threads acts to dissuade those who would attempt it. So explain how it happens.

Your other variables don't apply in this example to stop it happening, so explain what will stop it, what will fkag it as an issue (particularly if the person being personated never knows that it has happened because they never attempted to vote) and how the criminal concerned will be traced and caught.
Reply
#59
In 2019, there were:

- about 47 million people registered to vote in general elections
- just 33 allegations of "personation" - the offence of pretending to be somebody else to vote
- one conviction - a man in West Yorkshire who admitted voting once in his own name and once in his son's in the European Parliament election
- one caution

how much money are we spending to prevent one conviction of voter fraud? value for money when funding is being cut across other services?
Reply
#60
1. They have no way of being certain that they won't vote. I've addressed this.

2. They have no way of being certain that they won't vote. I've addressed this.

3. They know what they are in control of saying, they don't know the factors that are not in their control. I've addressed this.

4. If it's the same one they risk being recognised by the people at the polling station.

What stops a person from robbing a bank? What stops a person starting a nuclear war? Risk. You're justifying your point by applying hypothetical situations when they're functionally impossible due to having such a low probability due to the variables that it is basically nil. It's certainly possible that you could fraudulently vote in someone else's name, much the same way as it's possible that you could forge a driving license and vote in someone else's name. Introducing ID doesn't eliminate all risk, if you're using that as a justification then why stop there? I've pointed out a flaw based around having voter ID, should we escalate it and require biometric data or something? No, the chance that someone will forge ID to vote in someone else's name is basically nil, as is the chance that someone will successfully pass through all the variables including those out of their control.

It's about probabilities, there's a reason why in-person voting has been successfully resistant to fraud for 150 years. The probabilities are backed by the miniscule evidence of it being a problem. Until there is actual evidence that don't align with the probability then I'll change by view but until then it's functionally impossible.

All requiring ID does is add another variable they changes it from basically nil to basically nil. Therefore it's pointless. If a change doesn't functionally alter the outcome then what is the point of it? It's bureaucracy for bureaucracy sakes. Introduce more costs and waste more time for the same outcome.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 8 Guest(s)