Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(08-21-2020, 11:46 AM)74bus Wrote: I take your points, but just a thought. There are, on average, 5 road deaths every day on UK roads and countless more seriously injured. However, I still want to have the convenience of using my car despite the small chance that I might kill myself or someone else. And so do millions of others.
My point is, that life is a risk and in our efforts to eliminate all risk, we can lose sight of what life is about.
I do agree with that entirely 74 but, using your example, if someone said to you we have had 60 thousand road deaths in the 1st half of the year do you think that they should do something about it until they can work out how to stop it.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(08-21-2020, 12:19 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
I’m pretty sure teachers, catering, administrative staff have to work in schools. I’m sure they are touched by your consideration for others.
I was fully supportive of lockdowns to save the NHS and as the virus took it's grip. We are past that now, we have the data, we can see the real evidence of what happened and what is continuing to happen. Why are we not looking at other places and learning? One hospital alone has a backlog of 11,000 radiology scans (with 1,000 new ones every week). With the extra measures they can't even process the normal amount they would before COVID, why are COVID deaths more important to save than cancer deaths? (Which statistically can happen to a younger % of the population).
Simple question - at what point in your view is it safe for children to go back to school in an unrestricted manner? What's the measure or test that has to be reached or satisfied for you to say "okay it's now time for schools to be as they were in February"?
Great post. The radiology backlog is terrible. But so many people seem to have forgotten anything exists other than COVID. It’s bizarre.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
08-21-2020, 12:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-21-2020, 12:57 PM by baggy1.)
(08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
Schools are only off because it is the summer holidays, they go back in a couple of weeks don't they?
Positive case numbers rose because of more testing - you can't compare that with something when there wasn't testing. And the testing figures are pointless anyway until you find out a way of testing everybody regularly. Testing where you know there are cases will mean it is a distorted sample.
you obviously don't get the meaning of pandemic if you think it only applies to this country and you can opt in or out. The virus is still out there, the measures in place are controlling the sharp end of it and until there is a vaccine, this is the new normal. The fact that you can't go to Spain for your hols and have to go to Breen is now normal, as it was 40 years ago and we survived.
(08-21-2020, 12:42 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-21-2020, 12:19 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
I’m pretty sure teachers, catering, administrative staff have to work in schools. I’m sure they are touched by your consideration for others.
I was fully supportive of lockdowns to save the NHS and as the virus took it's grip. We are past that now, we have the data, we can see the real evidence of what happened and what is continuing to happen. Why are we not looking at other places and learning? One hospital alone has a backlog of 11,000 radiology scans (with 1,000 new ones every week). With the extra measures they can't even process the normal amount they would before COVID, why are COVID deaths more important to save than cancer deaths? (Which statistically can happen to a younger % of the population).
Simple question - at what point in your view is it safe for children to go back to school in an unrestricted manner? What's the measure or test that has to be reached or satisfied for you to say "okay it's now time for schools to be as they were in February"?
Great post. The radiology backlog is terrible. But so many people seem to have forgotten anything exists other than COVID. It’s bizarre.
The backlog is down to the staffing and infrastructure, not restrictions. We had to lockdown and as BJ says he was fully supportive of that, but doesn't appear to accept that because the facilities can only cope with so many at a time then there will inevitably be a backlog. If the government had focussed on proactive medicine, testing and patient well being years ago instead of consistently cutting costs then we would have dealt with this better, they didn't, we aren't. We simply haven't got the facilities and it will get worse as we head towards a privatised model.
Just googled scan backlogs and they were reporting a serious incident scan backlog in July 2019 - the lockdown has made things worse. Don't let them hoodwink into thinking that the reason for the delays is purely Covid, it is because of years of underinvestment.
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(08-21-2020, 12:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
Schools are only off because it is the summer holidays, they go back in a couple of weeks don't they?
Positive case numbers rose because of more testing - you can't compare that with something when there wasn't testing. And the testing figures are pointless anyway until you find out a way of testing everybody regularly. Testing where you know there are cases will mean it is a distorted sample.
you obviously don't get the meaning of pandemic if you think it only applies to this country and you can opt in or out. The virus is still out there, the measures in place are controlling the sharp end of it and until there is a vaccine, this is the new normal. The fact that you can't go to Spain for your hols and have to go to Breen is now normal, as it was 40 years ago and we survived.
(08-21-2020, 12:42 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (08-21-2020, 12:19 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
I’m pretty sure teachers, catering, administrative staff have to work in schools. I’m sure they are touched by your consideration for others.
I was fully supportive of lockdowns to save the NHS and as the virus took it's grip. We are past that now, we have the data, we can see the real evidence of what happened and what is continuing to happen. Why are we not looking at other places and learning? One hospital alone has a backlog of 11,000 radiology scans (with 1,000 new ones every week). With the extra measures they can't even process the normal amount they would before COVID, why are COVID deaths more important to save than cancer deaths? (Which statistically can happen to a younger % of the population).
Simple question - at what point in your view is it safe for children to go back to school in an unrestricted manner? What's the measure or test that has to be reached or satisfied for you to say "okay it's now time for schools to be as they were in February"?
Great post. The radiology backlog is terrible. But so many people seem to have forgotten anything exists other than COVID. It’s bizarre.
The backlog is down to the staffing and infrastructure, not restrictions. We had to lockdown and as BJ says he was fully supportive of that, but doesn't appear to accept that because the facilities can only cope with so many at a time then there will inevitably be a backlog. If the government had focussed on proactive medicine, testing and patient well being years ago instead of consistently cutting costs then we would have dealt with this better, they didn't, we aren't. We simply haven't got the facilities and it will get worse as we head towards a privatised model.
Just googled scan backlogs and they were reporting a serious incident scan backlog in July 2019 - the lockdown has made things worse. Don't let them hoodwink into thinking that the reason for the delays is purely Covid, it is because of years of underinvestment.
Birmingham is now on lockdown warning for guess how many hospital admissions? 7 day average across ALL East and West Midlands hospitals for COVID is 13. 13 people a day = lockdown. You guys might be okay with that I'm not.
Cancer screening should be back up at 100%, they aren't anywhere near that. My wife has had an appointment at a specialist unit (not cancer fortunately) in London pushed back 3 times since lockdown. The hospitals are empty. The NHS is set up to run at 80% bed occupancy, I'd be surprised if it was half of that at the moment.
On the testing yes as you test more you get more positive results but as a % of tests that are positive this is still way past it's peak. You aren't going to get to a COVID zero position, just as we haven't with Flu. Flu is currently killing 4x more people than COVID, why didn't you wear a mask for that last winter? Also the flu death rate in 1999 was pretty horrific (20K deaths), I don't remember one call for the Y2K celebrations to not go ahead do you?
I'm not forcing you to holiday in Spain, I'm not forcing you to go to a pub, I'm not forcing you to go to a sports event or concert. But why do you think that I shouldn't now we are down to the tail end of a virus.
Posts: 455
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(08-21-2020, 12:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:46 AM)74bus Wrote: I take your points, but just a thought. There are, on average, 5 road deaths every day on UK roads and countless more seriously injured. However, I still want to have the convenience of using my car despite the small chance that I might kill myself or someone else. And so do millions of others.
My point is, that life is a risk and in our efforts to eliminate all risk, we can lose sight of what life is about.
I do agree with that entirely 74 but, using your example, if someone said to you we have had 60 thousand road deaths in the 1st half of the year do you think that they should do something about it until they can work out how to stop it. The steps taken about Covid were entirely necessary, but in the current situation, I believe that the emphasis on Covid is now out of proportion.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(08-21-2020, 01:45 PM)74bus Wrote: (08-21-2020, 12:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:46 AM)74bus Wrote: I take your points, but just a thought. There are, on average, 5 road deaths every day on UK roads and countless more seriously injured. However, I still want to have the convenience of using my car despite the small chance that I might kill myself or someone else. And so do millions of others.
My point is, that life is a risk and in our efforts to eliminate all risk, we can lose sight of what life is about.
I do agree with that entirely 74 but, using your example, if someone said to you we have had 60 thousand road deaths in the 1st half of the year do you think that they should do something about it until they can work out how to stop it. The steps taken about Covid were entirely necessary, but in the current situation, I believe that the emphasis on Covid is now out of proportion.
+1
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(08-21-2020, 12:19 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
I’m pretty sure teachers, catering, administrative staff have to work in schools. I’m sure they are touched by your consideration for others.
I was fully supportive of lockdowns to save the NHS and as the virus took it's grip. We are past that now, we have the data, we can see the real evidence of what happened and what is continuing to happen. Why are we not looking at other places and learning? One hospital alone has a backlog of 11,000 radiology scans (with 1,000 new ones every week). With the extra measures they can't even process the normal amount they would before COVID, why are COVID deaths more important to save than cancer deaths? (Which statistically can happen to a younger % of the population).
Simple question - at what point in your view is it safe for children to go back to school in an unrestricted manner? What's the measure or test that has to be reached or satisfied for you to say "okay it's now time for schools to be as they were in February"?
They are going back to school but your point was I thought you wanted them to return to complete normality and that simply isn’t possible. There will have to be social distancing in place because frankly kids are germ factories and the bug hasn’t gone away.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
08-21-2020, 02:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-21-2020, 02:04 PM by baggy1.)
(08-21-2020, 01:17 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
Birmingham is now on lockdown warning for guess how many hospital admissions? 7 day average across ALL East and West Midlands hospitals for COVID is 13. 13 people a day = lockdown. You guys might be okay with that I'm not.
Cancer screening should be back up at 100%, they aren't anywhere near that. My wife has had an appointment at a specialist unit (not cancer fortunately) in London pushed back 3 times since lockdown. The hospitals are empty. The NHS is set up to run at 80% bed occupancy, I'd be surprised if it was half of that at the moment.
On the testing yes as you test more you get more positive results but as a % of tests that are positive this is still way past it's peak. You aren't going to get to a COVID zero position, just as we haven't with Flu. Flu is currently killing 4x more people than COVID, why didn't you wear a mask for that last winter? Also the flu death rate in 1999 was pretty horrific (20K deaths), I don't remember one call for the Y2K celebrations to not go ahead do you?
I'm not forcing you to holiday in Spain, I'm not forcing you to go to a pub, I'm not forcing you to go to a sports event or concert. But why do you think that I shouldn't now we are down to the tail end of a virus.
So your argument is (in paragraph order)
Birmingham is now on lockdown - it isn't. I can't say it any simpler than that at this moment. This might change but currently it is on a watchlist not on lockdown. You can still go to the pub, the gym, shopping, you can even go to BHX and get a flight to almost anywhere you want, the kids will be back in school once the summer holidays are over. That is not lockdown.
Cancer screening has been underfunded for years and has had a backlog for years, there is a further backlog due to the virus and the lockdown that was in place. Using your own quote - I don't remember you shouting for extra funding when a serious incident was called this time last year for these treatments. Don't let the government cover up years of underfunding by accepting their version that the current situation has caused the backlogs.
Those 19k deaths in the 1999 winter were the total without measures in place i.e. it died out naturally, we are at 60k excess deaths this year already with measures in place. Without measures that figure would have been much higher because hospitalisation was spiralling until lockdown was introduced, that is why we locked down, but I repeat we are not in lockdown now.
You can holiday in Spain, you can go to the pub, you can watch a sports event - if you are concerned about not being able to go to a match then you are in a very blessed situation if that is your main concern.
BTW, I agree with you that we should keep relaxing measures, but we have to do it with a balanced approach and if that means that we have to make small sacrifices for a short period then so be it.
(08-21-2020, 01:45 PM)74bus Wrote: (08-21-2020, 12:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:46 AM)74bus Wrote: I take your points, but just a thought. There are, on average, 5 road deaths every day on UK roads and countless more seriously injured. However, I still want to have the convenience of using my car despite the small chance that I might kill myself or someone else. And so do millions of others.
My point is, that life is a risk and in our efforts to eliminate all risk, we can lose sight of what life is about.
I do agree with that entirely 74 but, using your example, if someone said to you we have had 60 thousand road deaths in the 1st half of the year do you think that they should do something about it until they can work out how to stop it. The steps taken about Covid were entirely necessary, but in the current situation, I believe that the emphasis on Covid is now out of proportion.
And what is that emphasis - what is it that you want to be happening that isn't allowed already?
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(08-21-2020, 02:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 12:19 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
I’m pretty sure teachers, catering, administrative staff have to work in schools. I’m sure they are touched by your consideration for others.
I was fully supportive of lockdowns to save the NHS and as the virus took it's grip. We are past that now, we have the data, we can see the real evidence of what happened and what is continuing to happen. Why are we not looking at other places and learning? One hospital alone has a backlog of 11,000 radiology scans (with 1,000 new ones every week). With the extra measures they can't even process the normal amount they would before COVID, why are COVID deaths more important to save than cancer deaths? (Which statistically can happen to a younger % of the population).
Simple question - at what point in your view is it safe for children to go back to school in an unrestricted manner? What's the measure or test that has to be reached or satisfied for you to say "okay it's now time for schools to be as they were in February"?
They are going back to school but your point was I thought you wanted them to return to complete normality and that simply isn’t possible. There will have to be social distancing in place because frankly kids are germ factories and the bug hasn’t gone away.
So when will they return to normal?
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(08-21-2020, 02:11 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: (08-21-2020, 02:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 12:19 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-21-2020, 11:37 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I was talking about children / young adults and schools being closed.
20 people under the age of 19 have died with COVID noted on the papers, this is against a population of 15.62m in that age group in the UK. So the death rate is actually 0.00013% for these people.
Schools need to reopen completely unrestricted now, it's insane.
"It's also basic logic that the reasons that the figures have dropped is that a proportion of the population have been and still are being sensible - social-distancing, good hygiene etc." - positive case numbers rose consistently from 6th July yet there was no uptick in hospital admittance, ICU bed occupancy or deaths. So either people testing positive now are not getting the strain as hard and therefore aren't at risk of death or the people being tested are younger and therefore aren't at risk of death.
Either way it's done by the actual definition of a pandemic this is over, we are no long in a pandemic in this country. We need to realise this and get back to further version of "normality" - that includes sports events, schools open fully without restrictions, ridiculous lockdown threats in specific towns, pubs / restaurants back to full capacity. This is all fun and games sat on the pavement in the summer, once the dark nights drawn in the places will go under.
I’m pretty sure teachers, catering, administrative staff have to work in schools. I’m sure they are touched by your consideration for others.
I was fully supportive of lockdowns to save the NHS and as the virus took it's grip. We are past that now, we have the data, we can see the real evidence of what happened and what is continuing to happen. Why are we not looking at other places and learning? One hospital alone has a backlog of 11,000 radiology scans (with 1,000 new ones every week). With the extra measures they can't even process the normal amount they would before COVID, why are COVID deaths more important to save than cancer deaths? (Which statistically can happen to a younger % of the population).
Simple question - at what point in your view is it safe for children to go back to school in an unrestricted manner? What's the measure or test that has to be reached or satisfied for you to say "okay it's now time for schools to be as they were in February"?
They are going back to school but your point was I thought you wanted them to return to complete normality and that simply isn’t possible. There will have to be social distancing in place because frankly kids are germ factories and the bug hasn’t gone away.
So when will they return to normal?
When there is a vaccine I'd imagine, much like the rest of the world
|