So...possibly us and Leeds promoted
#41
(03-14-2020, 04:46 PM)Ampadu\s Left Boot Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 04:12 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 12:36 PM)hudds Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 11:28 AM)wba13 Wrote: For me you cannot play behind closed doors , football is a spectator sport played by well paid players for the viewing public to watch . I for one would be most aggrieved if we get promotion, that I was not there to cheer them on. Yes I do agree with the postponement and I will admit I do not think the fixtures will be finished. But there has to be a better way than behind closed doors, that’s a total cop out. The only people this would suit are the people in power who would get there fixtures played. Think of the cost to the league 1 and 2 clubs that rely on match revenue, they would still have the cost of fulfilling the fixture with little if any revenue coming in. UEFA,THE PREMIER LEAGUE and the EFL have to come up with a better solution than that.

It's a better solution than anything else availble.  But it presupposes fit and well footballers and officials etc to particiipate, which itself may not be possible.

So what's your solution in extremis?

For me I don’t know the solution, but thinking of it I agree with the Brighton chairman who says how can you continue the season beyond June, player, it’s impossible contracts finish, loan players return to there parent clubs, players due for there breaks it cannot happen. I like it when he says Leeds and West Brom should be promoted and for one season a 20 side premier league. I don’t have a solution but I cannot see why it should be played behind closed doors .

Can't see a reason to play it behind closed doors? To complete the season of course!

None of the other mentioned reasons should stop the season being completed, even if this is achieved during August and the start of next season (which would be played on a tighter schedule with League Cup and EFL trophy cancelled for the year) put back 1 month.

If players contracts finish or their loans end, then bad luck, that is a mere inconvenience compared to voiding a whole season. The transfer window will be open by June and extended loans can be agreed between the clubs if the season is played at a later date.

Whatever happens, nothing should be decided for several months regardless to see how the situation worldwide develops - how do we know there will even be a next season yet?

Sorry but I respect your opinion, but for me as I’ve previously said It’s totally unfair on the paying public to play behind closed doors it’s a spectator sport. You say to finish the season, but without the fans the games are mean less training ground exercises.So it’s bad luck that we lose Krovinovic, Robinson because there loans run out, that is unfair because it’s players like these that have helped get us where we are. Yes I do want the season to finish but for me not behind closed doors.
Reply
#42
Speedway has an approach to this. Due to the impact of weather, league positions are decided by a cut off date, regardless of number of games completed.

Football could have something similar going forward as an emergency backstop, i.e. league table at 6th May regardless.
Reply
#43
(03-14-2020, 09:26 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 04:46 PM)Ampadu\s Left Boot Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 04:12 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 12:36 PM)hudds Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 11:28 AM)wba13 Wrote: For me you cannot play behind closed doors , football is a spectator sport played by well paid players for the viewing public to watch . I for one would be most aggrieved if we get promotion, that I was not there to cheer them on. Yes I do agree with the postponement and I will admit I do not think the fixtures will be finished. But there has to be a better way than behind closed doors, that’s a total cop out. The only people this would suit are the people in power who would get there fixtures played. Think of the cost to the league 1 and 2 clubs that rely on match revenue, they would still have the cost of fulfilling the fixture with little if any revenue coming in. UEFA,THE PREMIER LEAGUE and the EFL have to come up with a better solution than that.

It's a better solution than anything else availble.  But it presupposes fit and well footballers and officials etc to particiipate, which itself may not be possible.

So what's your solution in extremis?

For me I don’t know the solution, but thinking of it I agree with the Brighton chairman who says how can you continue the season beyond June, player, it’s impossible contracts finish, loan players return to there parent clubs, players due for there breaks it cannot happen. I like it when he says Leeds and West Brom should be promoted and for one season a 20 side premier league. I don’t have a solution but I cannot see why it should be played behind closed doors .

Can't see a reason to play it behind closed doors? To complete the season of course!

None of the other mentioned reasons should stop the season being completed, even if this is achieved during August and the start of next season (which would be played on a tighter schedule with League Cup and EFL trophy cancelled for the year) put back 1 month.

If players contracts finish or their loans end, then bad luck, that is a mere inconvenience compared to voiding a whole season. The transfer window will be open by June and extended loans can be agreed between the clubs if the season is played at a later date.

Whatever happens, nothing should be decided for several months regardless to see how the situation worldwide develops - how do we know there will even be a next season yet?

Sorry but I respect your opinion, but for me as I’ve previously said It’s totally unfair on the paying public to play behind closed doors it’s a spectator sport. You say to finish the season, but without the fans the games are mean less training ground exercises.So it’s bad luck that we lose Krovinovic, Robinson because there loans run out, that is unfair because it’s players like these that have helped get us where we are. Yes I do want the season to finish but for me not behind closed doors.

That's just your selfish way of looking at it no offence to you but you just want to watch us no matter what I might be wrong  but the fans are secondary in football mate when it comes down to it
Reply
#44
What did they do in 1939??
Reply
#45
(03-15-2020, 12:47 AM)baggpuss Wrote: What did they do in 1939??

Wave a piece of paper in the air.
Flag shagging,misogynistic,covidiot,anitvax gammon.
Or just a normal white bloke.
Reply
#46
(03-14-2020, 06:28 PM)Mickyfudge Wrote:
(03-14-2020, 04:27 PM)Three Degrees Wrote: This proves theres to much football today , back when i were a lad you get matches postponed for weeks and they still finished the season , still before its pointed out to me money
talks.

I think it was 1978 loads of games were postponed because of the ice and snow ,the season was still completed

Yeah and it cost us the title......  Angry
Reply
#47
It should all be decided by the pools panel
Reply
#48
The more I read, the more I sense there is little chance of the season ever being finished. So now it's time to mitigate the fallout and it looks like the most sensible approach to take will be to reward potential winners but not penalise potential losers. In other words, award the title to Liverpool, promote those currently in the automatic positions across the leagues but don't relegate anyone and cancel the play-offs. Next season, this would leave 22 in the Prem, 24 in the Champ and League One and 22 in League Two. No games in hand in the football league would see a team jump from the play-off positions into automatic. It's not as straightforward in non-league but I'm sure arrangements can be made.

The point is that this approach removes the prospect of legal challenges from all those in automatic promotion and relegation places and leaves only the chance of court challenges from play-off contenders who feel they could have made it automatically or at Wembley. But I imagine the authorities would be much happier to defend a case in which, for example, Forest claim they could have made up a ten point deficit over 9 games (yeah, right - no prediction model in existence would bear that out...) rather than one from the likes of Leeds or us with a much more convincing argument that voiding the season would result in the loss of millions in revenue.

So the leagues would be slightly out of kilter next season but all leagues can introduce rules to even it up again before a ball is kicked, making it fair for everyone. We'd obviously benefit from this outcome but I can't see another way. Voiding it and starting again, like mad Piers Morgan and his mates want to do, would send shares in law firms soaring.

If the season can't be played out (and I genuinely hope it is), then with only around 20% of it left to be played, the fairest and most ethical outcome will be the one I've outlined above albeit it will be a disappointing decision for play-off teams who feel they could make it either automatically or in the knock-outs (and this includes both teams local to me, Pompey and Havant and Waterlooville - I have a season ticket at Havant and yesterday's fifth successive win moved us within three points of Wealdstone who occupy the only automatic promotion spot...)
Reply
#49
(03-15-2020, 12:47 AM)baggpuss Wrote: What did they do in 1939??

War was declared in September. They had only played 3 games before fixtures was cancelled. Bit different this season  when we are 80% through the season.
Reply
#50
(03-15-2020, 12:57 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-15-2020, 11:10 AM)steviedm Wrote: The more I read, the more I sense there is little chance of the season ever being finished. So now it's time to mitigate the fallout and it looks like the most sensible approach to take will be to reward potential winners but not penalise potential losers. In other words, award the title to Liverpool, promote those currently in the automatic positions across the leagues but don't relegate anyone and cancel the play-offs. Next season, this would leave 22 in the Prem, 24 in the Champ and League One and 22 in League Two. No games in hand in the football league would see a team jump from the play-off positions into automatic. It's not as straightforward in non-league but I'm sure arrangements can be made.

The point is that this approach removes the prospect of legal challenges from all those in automatic promotion and relegation places and leaves only the chance of court challenges from play-off contenders who feel they could have made it automatically or at Wembley. But I imagine the authorities would be much happier to defend a case in which, for example, Forest claim they could have made up a ten point deficit over 9 games (yeah, right - no prediction model in existence would bear that out...) rather than one from the likes of Leeds or us with a much more convincing argument that voiding the season would result in the loss of millions in revenue.

So the leagues would be slightly out of kilter next season but all leagues can introduce rules to even it up again before a ball is kicked, making it fair for everyone. We'd obviously benefit from this outcome but I can't see another way. Voiding it and starting again, like mad Piers Morgan and his mates want to do, would send shares in law firms soaring.

If the season can't be played out (and I genuinely hope it is), then with only around 20% of it left to be played, the fairest and most ethical outcome will be the one I've outlined above albeit it will be a disappointing decision for play-off teams who feel they could make it either automatically or in the knock-outs (and this includes both teams local to me, Pompey and Havant and Waterlooville - I have a season ticket at Havant and yesterday's fifth successive win moved us within three points of Wealdstone who occupy the only automatic promotion spot...)

With so much of the season gone and the extreme circumstances, I don't think the legal challenge possibilities should stop the EFL/Prem making a call - to have no relegation but have promotion seems too problematic. They may go on average points per game and adding them on for remaining fixtures to determine final position, as some teams have less games played than others - which still relegates Villa I believe which is a plus in its favour.

It's not really problematic and actually probably the line of most agreement of the Prem clubs to have no relegation from the Premier League and promote the top 2 in the Chump for a single 22 club season.  If you start "what ifs", that's when the legal rows brew.  Also limited kerfuffle from the Championship clubs and less legal costs.   Not the best but given we and Leeds are pretty clear at this stage, it's more palatable and we get promoted, which is the main thing....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)