Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(11-06-2025, 08:20 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Bloke is a fucking first rate coach. He’d have this fairly average bunch of chancers in the top 4. Best coach we’ve had since Hodgson
First sentence is absolutely correct, last sentence possibly correct.
The bit in the middle is fanciful. He couldn't get better squads than this one into the top 4 . The blokes a really good coach not a miracle worker.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(11-07-2025, 10:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (11-06-2025, 08:20 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Bloke is a fucking first rate coach. He’d have this fairly average bunch of chancers in the top 4. Best coach we’ve had since Hodgson
First sentence is absolutely correct, last sentence possibly correct.
The bit in the middle is fanciful. He couldn't get better squads than this one into the top 4 . The blokes a really good coach not a miracle worker.
Tbf, look at the clubs which are around the top at the moment. A lot of them are clubs that nobody fancied this season. All 3 of the relegated teams have had terrible starts relative to what their expectations would be. It really does seem to be the most open Championship for years. I think it's fair to say that our squad (which isn't great but is definitely top half level) could be in those top few places with proper coaching, organisation and leadership.
Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-07-2025, 01:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-07-2025, 01:09 PM by Josh1873.)
I absolutely rate CC, he's a phenomenal manager. However he struggled a little last season with a better squad than we have now, I believe we'd have gotten into the play-offs if he'd have stayed. But it would have been 6th placed, and we'd have scraped in. It wouldn't have been the comfortable 5th we saw the previous campaign.
I honestly doubt very much he'd get this team anywhere near 4th. We may have an outside chance of the play-offs with CC, but it wouldn't have been guaranteed or as likely as it would have been last season.
I don't want to keep sounding like I'm some sort of Mason fan boy, he's copping some rightful stick and deserves the criticism he's getting, and it has been dog shit the last few weeks, it really has. But the more I think about this season, the unbalanced squad, and the fact this is his first gig, the more I realise how much of a mammoth job he has taken on. Maybe it's too much for him, but maybe he'll figure it out with time. I really don't know. I just think the job is much bigger and tougher than most are realising.
I'll end by reiterating that no matter how difficult his task is, I do expect better performances than what we've been served up with.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(11-07-2025, 01:07 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I absolutely rate CC, he's a phenomenal manager. However he struggled a little last season with a better squad than we have now, I believe we'd have gotten into the play-offs if he'd have stayed. But it would have been 6th placed, and we'd have scraped in. It wouldn't have been the comfortable 5th we saw the previous campaign.
I honestly doubt very much he'd get this team anywhere near 4th. We may have an outside chance of the play-offs with CC, but it wouldn't have been guaranteed or as likely as it would have been last season.
I don't want to keep sounding like I'm some sort of Mason fan boy, he's copping some rightful stick and deserves the criticism he's getting, and it has been dog shit the last few weeks, it really has. But the more I think about this season, the unbalanced squad, and the fact this is his first gig, the more I realise how much of a mammoth job he has taken on. Maybe it's too much for him, but maybe he'll figure it out with time. I really don't know. I just think the job is much bigger and tougher than most are realising.
I'll end by reiterating that no matter how difficult his task is, I do expect better performances than what we've been served up with.
I’m not sure I agree he had a stronger squad during his time here - had CC been given the financial backing and reinforcements Mowbray blew last season we’d have been comfortably in the playoffs.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(11-07-2025, 10:57 AM)1952 Wrote: (11-07-2025, 10:13 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The two main concerns from those mentioned were that we had actually been on a fairly sustained (of slow) dip in ppg and, as was mentioned many times before his inevitable departure, he was being aggressively touted widely to other clubs for a fair while before he left. Others on here will know that to be correct.
Re the views on him as a coach
Is he better than Mason? Cleary
Was the football like 3 Valium and a Xanax? Yes
Would I want to watch it again? No
Is he as bad or as good or some claim on here? No. He’s a good coach, but with limitations in personality and adaptability (so far) that will prevent him going to the top. For me, he’s like an Emery light. A formula that works but is limited as much as it is successful by it’s inflexibility
Good post Or total bollix, mebbees? I'd have liked to see what Carlos would have done with what we spent in the following January. As for 3 valium and a xanax, I never saw a Corberan side that didn't pro actively go out to win. It's all a bit of pointless fantasy though, he won't be coming back.
Posts: 3,622
Threads: 253
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation:
1
(11-07-2025, 10:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (11-06-2025, 08:20 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Bloke is a fucking first rate coach. He’d have this fairly average bunch of chancers in the top 4. Best coach we’ve had since Hodgson
First sentence is absolutely correct, last sentence possibly correct.
The bit in the middle is fanciful. He couldn't get better squads than this one into the top 4 . The blokes a really good coach not a miracle worker.
Much tougher league then though. Some very average sides, bar Coventry, in this seasons the top 6.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(11-07-2025, 01:07 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I absolutely rate CC, he's a phenomenal manager. However he struggled a little last season with a better squad than we have now, I believe we'd have gotten into the play-offs if he'd have stayed. But it would have been 6th placed, and we'd have scraped in. It wouldn't have been the comfortable 5th we saw the previous campaign.
I honestly doubt very much he'd get this team anywhere near 4th. We may have an outside chance of the play-offs with CC, but it wouldn't have been guaranteed or as likely as it would have been last season.
I don't want to keep sounding like I'm some sort of Mason fan boy, he's copping some rightful stick and deserves the criticism he's getting, and it has been dog shit the last few weeks, it really has. But the more I think about this season, the unbalanced squad, and the fact this is his first gig, the more I realise how much of a mammoth job he has taken on. Maybe it's too much for him, but maybe he'll figure it out with time. I really don't know. I just think the job is much bigger and tougher than most are realising.
I'll end by reiterating that no matter how difficult his task is, I do expect better performances than what we've been served up with.
I think this is right.
Generally speaking we seem to have an unrealistic view of how we were doing last season when Corberan was in charge.
At this time last season we were in a spell of drawing matches, many of which were against very mediocre opposition. We were not playing football that was good enough to get into the play offs.
On the whole Corberan was not getting criticism, which was right. An understanding of where we were as a club, plus Corberans record with us up to that point, meant he deserved support and time. If he stayed maybe he would have been able to get us back on track, hard to think who would be better qualified for the job.
But he didn't stay, so we'll never know.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
11-07-2025, 01:55 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-07-2025, 02:07 PM by MrBater.)
(11-07-2025, 01:35 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (11-07-2025, 01:07 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I absolutely rate CC, he's a phenomenal manager. However he struggled a little last season with a better squad than we have now, I believe we'd have gotten into the play-offs if he'd have stayed. But it would have been 6th placed, and we'd have scraped in. It wouldn't have been the comfortable 5th we saw the previous campaign.
I honestly doubt very much he'd get this team anywhere near 4th. We may have an outside chance of the play-offs with CC, but it wouldn't have been guaranteed or as likely as it would have been last season.
I don't want to keep sounding like I'm some sort of Mason fan boy, he's copping some rightful stick and deserves the criticism he's getting, and it has been dog shit the last few weeks, it really has. But the more I think about this season, the unbalanced squad, and the fact this is his first gig, the more I realise how much of a mammoth job he has taken on. Maybe it's too much for him, but maybe he'll figure it out with time. I really don't know. I just think the job is much bigger and tougher than most are realising.
I'll end by reiterating that no matter how difficult his task is, I do expect better performances than what we've been served up with.
I think this is right.
Generally speaking we seem to have an unrealistic view of how we were doing last season when Corberan was in charge.
At this time last season we were in a spell of drawing matches, many of which were against very mediocre opposition. We were not playing football that was good enough to get into the play offs.
On the whole Corberan was not getting criticism, which was right. An understanding of where we were as a club, plus Corberans record with us up to that point, meant he deserved support and time. If he stayed maybe he would have been able to get us back on track, hard to think who would be better qualified for the job.
But he didn't stay, so we'll never know.
I posted the other day, first 13 games, Mason is only 3 points behind Corberan... CC wasn't losing though, just drawing.
After 14, CC gained yet another draw giving us 22 points (5th position), taking him 4 ahead of mason after 14 games... Millwall in 5th this season have 24 points, this season CC would be in 7th after 14 games with those points.
CC had 8 more games with us... taking 13 points from the possible 24... Leaving us on 35 from 22 games (1.59pts per game), in 7th.
Mason is running at 1.29pts per game. So if mason can get 17 points from the next 8 games he'll match CC, and we'd all probably be reasonably happy.
had we maintained the 1.59 pts per game then we'd have got 73(ish) points... we got 64. 73 would have been 5th.
random pointlessness, last season we scored 57 goals, 18 more than Coventry have already got this! We'd scored 26 goals in 22 games when CC left... We'd scored 14 at the 14 game stage, so Mason's 12 isn't massively dissimilar!
Posts: 7,717
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
We'll be lucky to have 35 points by Easter if Mason stays in post.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(11-07-2025, 01:55 PM)MrBater Wrote: (11-07-2025, 01:35 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (11-07-2025, 01:07 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I absolutely rate CC, he's a phenomenal manager. However he struggled a little last season with a better squad than we have now, I believe we'd have gotten into the play-offs if he'd have stayed. But it would have been 6th placed, and we'd have scraped in. It wouldn't have been the comfortable 5th we saw the previous campaign.
I honestly doubt very much he'd get this team anywhere near 4th. We may have an outside chance of the play-offs with CC, but it wouldn't have been guaranteed or as likely as it would have been last season.
I don't want to keep sounding like I'm some sort of Mason fan boy, he's copping some rightful stick and deserves the criticism he's getting, and it has been dog shit the last few weeks, it really has. But the more I think about this season, the unbalanced squad, and the fact this is his first gig, the more I realise how much of a mammoth job he has taken on. Maybe it's too much for him, but maybe he'll figure it out with time. I really don't know. I just think the job is much bigger and tougher than most are realising.
I'll end by reiterating that no matter how difficult his task is, I do expect better performances than what we've been served up with.
I think this is right.
Generally speaking we seem to have an unrealistic view of how we were doing last season when Corberan was in charge.
At this time last season we were in a spell of drawing matches, many of which were against very mediocre opposition. We were not playing football that was good enough to get into the play offs.
On the whole Corberan was not getting criticism, which was right. An understanding of where we were as a club, plus Corberans record with us up to that point, meant he deserved support and time. If he stayed maybe he would have been able to get us back on track, hard to think who would be better qualified for the job.
But he didn't stay, so we'll never know.
I posted the other day, first 13 games, Mason is only 3 points behind Corberan... CC wasn't losing though, just drawing.
After 14, CC gained yet another draw giving us 22 points (5th position), taking him 4 ahead of mason after 14 games... Millwall in 5th this season have 24 points, this season CC would be in 7th after 14 games with those points.
CC had 8 more games with us... taking 13 points from the possible 24... Leaving us on 35 from 22 games (1.59pts per game), in 7th.
Mason is running at 1.29pts per game. So if mason can get 17 points from the next 8 games he'll match CC, and we'd all probably be reasonably happy.
had we maintained the 1.59 pts per game then we'd have got 73(ish) points... we got 64. 73 would have been 5th.
Who here thinks Mason will take over 2 points a game from our next 8?
|