Rwanda lite
#41
(05-18-2025, 11:03 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So your solution is simply to keep costs down by recruiting cheap labour.

Care costs are what they are, they’re paid for by a selection of means, government funding, insurance and personal payments. PIP is a government payment to those most in need of it, assessment is being changed to reflect the ability to continue funding where needed.

If you think we live in a country where the state can afford to pay for everything and not make sure it’s appropriate then you are deluded. WFA wasn’t needed by many, PIP is being abused in places and needs to be tightened up. Care needs to be appropriately funded.

Where is the evidence for PIP fraud/being abused? Please provide evidence for context. 
PIP cuts are being made to save Reeves budget blushes and the criteria is being changed to save money. 
Most care is paid for by the state and given that around 31% of people have less than was it £1k of savings then that problem doesn’t go away. 

It’s easy for the comfortably well off to feel it’s ok to take money and support away from others, it’s very Tory but hey there isn’t any difference these days between Labour and Tory policies.

Even Reeves constituency don’t agree with her!
Reply
#42
(05-18-2025, 11:03 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So your solution is simply to keep costs down by recruiting cheap labour.

Care costs are what they are, they’re paid for by a selection of means, government funding, insurance and personal payments. PIP is a government payment to those most in need of it, assessment is being changed to reflect the ability to continue funding where needed.

If you think we live in a country where the state can afford to pay for everything and not make sure it’s appropriate then you are deluded. WFA wasn’t needed by many, PIP is being abused in places and needs to be tightened up. Care needs to be appropriately funded.

PIP as an instrument is already refused to people who need it hence why the successful appeal rate is so high, primarily due to the issues with the structure of the paperwork. All this will do is cut an allowance to more people who need it ending up with higher legal fees to defend cases they will lose and also strain unpaid carers - already saving the Exchequer over £10bn a year - further resulting in worse care and more state funding. 

This approach is the epitome of Treasury Brain thinking that this current government have let themselves get suckered into on issues they weren't prepared to deal with once getting into government, much as Blair's government did.

If they keep this up expect hardening in the opinions of 2024 Labour voters wanting to go Green, Lib Dem and Reform which I do not want as with FPTP that will likely lead to Farage being PM
Reply
#43
(05-18-2025, 12:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-18-2025, 11:03 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So your solution is simply to keep costs down by recruiting cheap labour.

Care costs are what they are, they’re paid for by a selection of means, government funding, insurance and personal payments. PIP is a government payment to those most in need of it, assessment is being changed to reflect the ability to continue funding where needed.

If you think we live in a country where the state can afford to pay for everything and not make sure it’s appropriate then you are deluded. WFA wasn’t needed by many, PIP is being abused in places and needs to be tightened up. Care needs to be appropriately funded.

PIP as an instrument is already refused to people who need it hence why the successful appeal rate is so high, primarily due to the issues with the structure of the paperwork. All this will do is cut an allowance to more people who need it ending up with higher legal fees to defend cases they will lose and also strain unpaid carers - already saving the Exchequer over £10bn a year - further resulting in worse care and more state funding. 

This approach is the epitome of Treasury Brain thinking that this current government have let themselves get suckered into on issues they weren't prepared to deal with once getting into government, much as Blair's government did.

If they keep this up expect hardening in the opinions of 2024 Labour voters wanting to go Green, Lib Dem and Reform which I do not want as with FPTP that will likely lead to Farage being PM

I’m happy to say Labour can get to pluck… they have permanently lost my vote to the Greens or Lib Dem’s. Good post by the way BB.  I really don’t want Reform in office but I can’t vote for a party that is going after some of the poorest in society. 

If Starmer, Reeves and Kendall etc get removed and Labour return to the actual centre left I might change my mind but those three particularly make it impossible to do so currently.
Reply
#44
Interesting article on Times Online about the impact of the proposed £1bn Employment Support scheme.

Labour's findng just how difficult government is. Particularly when the realisation dawns that the welfare state and health spending is wholly unaffordable.

The next 4 years could be a slow motion car crash of epic proportions.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)