Sanity prevails
#41
(04-17-2025, 12:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The law should reflect and protect the majority of the population. And this law directly protects the interests of Women (old fashioned ones) who for all of time have been the victim of abuse and often lacked basic human rights. As a brother and husband to 2 young women, son to an older, frailer women, and uncle to 2 young (toddler) nieces. I am glad they will have the confidence that their biological sex is recognised and protected in a masculine dominated world.

On the other side. Now the law has closed some of the conversation. The primary role of society is to hammer home kindness, compassion and warmth to those experiencing gender dysphoria. It's down to legislators to ensure there is ample protection for the trans community against hate crimes, and there is a societal push for inclusion where possible. Safe, gender neutral bathroom/changing facilities for example, and the more gyms, bars, restaurants etc that offer genderless facilities will increase the consumer choices Trans people will have to live their lives freely without having to face gendered issues.
That’s pretty much spot on.
Reply
#42
(04-17-2025, 01:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-17-2025, 12:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The law should reflect and protect the majority of the population. And this law directly protects the interests of Women (old fashioned ones) who for all of time have been the victim of abuse and often lacked basic human rights. As a brother and husband to 2 young women, son to an older, frailer women, and uncle to 2 young (toddler) nieces. I am glad they will have the confidence that their biological sex is recognised and protected in a masculine dominated world.

On the other side. Now the law has closed some of the conversation. The primary role of society is to hammer home kindness, compassion and warmth to those experiencing gender dysphoria. It's down to legislators to ensure there is ample protection for the trans community against hate crimes, and there is a societal push for inclusion where possible. Safe, gender neutral bathroom/changing facilities for example, and the more gyms, bars, restaurants etc that offer genderless facilities will increase the consumer choices Trans people will have to live their lives freely without having to face gendered issues.

The law should protect everyone’s human right’s not just the majority, that’s why we have human rights law in the first place to ensure the likes of Trump and in this county Tufton Street loons can’t pick and choose whose rights we can ignore, cuz they ay loik us!

Whilst I completely agree with the sentiment of what you're saying Dekka. There will always be somebody, especially in today's self ID world, that will fall outside of the legislative framework. 

Technically trans women are protected by the same laws we all are, but in the eyes of said law are Male, as per their biology. 

The most important part of this is my second paragraph. For those not fortunate enough to feel comfortable to live as the gender assigned according their biological sex, they should have the right to present how they wish, and will hopefully have enough choice in life that they won't be subject to difficult gendered decisions.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#43
Be good to see who the next minority group cracko, Proth etc are directed to be angry with next are now this has been dealt with.

I suppose when they’ve seen their other politically preferred spheres go so badly wrong this is a soothing diversion
Reply
#44
Really? Oh do fuck off you sanctamonius tit.
Reply
#45
This ruling is about women's rights. Those trying to paint it as some kind of attack on a minority group are wrong and insulting.

Lurker's post summed it up pretty well. It allows the necessary clarity in law, without undermining the Equality Act 2010, under which both sex and gender reassignment are protected categories
Reply
#46
(04-17-2025, 01:23 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Be good to see who the next minority group cracko, Proth etc are directed to be angry with next are now this has been dealt with.

I suppose when they’ve seen their other politically preferred spheres go so badly wrong this is a soothing diversion

A minority of men that think they're women, and as a result think they should be treated like, yano, actual women, at the expense of actual women. As stated this is about women's rights.

The next step in the trans debate you seem to want to make it into, now that them impinging on every aspect of women's life has been put to bed, is protecting children from being mutilated at the behest of said minority of men and their 'allies'.
Reply
#47
This is the problem with political debate more generally. A lot of people want to drag people's opinions into a corner and make them very black and white. .

I personally struggle with 'Trans' as topic, as do many of my queer friends. Much of the literature is spurious surrounding the benefits of gender reassignment surgery, especially for younger people so most of the debate ends up being emotionally driven and closed off as people are scared of being labelled "right wing" or "transphobic".

One of said queer friends had been living as non-binary for a while now but for most of their childhood as a biological female suffering from body dysmorphia was offered all manner of reassignment options, but really no other interventions. She now, at 41, accepted she is a women. But it turns out she had drew the short straw reproductively and her body, hormonally was doing horrific things to her.

She recently had her womb and fallopian tubes removed in some major surgery is on HRT and she said for the first time she's started to feel feminine.

She always says how much she's glad she didn't get led down the trans path, that many in her community were advocating at the time based on their own almost obsession with identity choice. She now is glad she has the chance to be a woman now she's had the right medical intervention.

Just goes to show difficult balancing politics and personal identity can be.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#48
(04-17-2025, 03:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: This is the problem with political debate more generally. A lot of people want to drag people's opinions into a corner and make them very black and white. .

I personally struggle with 'Trans' as topic, as do many of my queer friends. Much of the literature is spurious surrounding the benefits of gender reassignment surgery, especially for younger people so most of the debate ends up being emotionally driven and closed off as people are scared of being labelled "right wing" or "transphobic".

One of said queer friends had been living as non-binary for a while now but for most of their childhood as a biological female suffering from body dysmorphia was offered all manner of reassignment options, but really no other interventions. She now, at 41, accepted she is a women. But it turns out she had drew the short straw reproductively and her body, hormonally was doing horrific things to her.

She recently had her womb and fallopian tubes removed in some major surgery is on HRT and she said for the first time she's started to feel feminine.

She always says how much she's glad she didn't get led down the trans path, that many in her community were advocating at the time based on their own almost obsession with identity choice. She now is glad she has the chance to be a woman now she's had the right medical intervention.

Just goes to show difficult balancing politics and personal identity can be.

Yet in some of the posts on here would be lumped in with the ridiculous notion that because some with gender identity challenges have committed crimes (shock) the whole community should be portrayed as a risk and treated accordingly. It’s the comfort with that mentality on parts of this thread that is truly disturbing
Reply
#49
(04-17-2025, 03:58 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(04-17-2025, 03:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: This is the problem with political debate more generally. A lot of people want to drag people's opinions into a corner and make them very black and white. .

I personally struggle with 'Trans' as topic, as do many of my queer friends. Much of the literature is spurious surrounding the benefits of gender reassignment surgery, especially for younger people so most of the debate ends up being emotionally driven and closed off as people are scared of being labelled "right wing" or "transphobic".

One of said queer friends had been living as non-binary for a while now but for most of their childhood as a biological female suffering from body dysmorphia was offered all manner of reassignment options, but really no other interventions. She now, at 41, accepted she is a women. But it turns out she had drew the short straw reproductively and her body, hormonally was doing horrific things to her.

She recently had her womb and fallopian tubes removed in some major surgery is on HRT and she said for the first time she's started to feel feminine.

She always says how much she's glad she didn't get led down the trans path, that many in her community were advocating at the time based on their own almost obsession with identity choice. She now is glad she has the chance to be a woman now she's had the right medical intervention.

Just goes to show difficult balancing politics and personal identity can be.

Yet in some of the posts on here would be lumped in with the ridiculous notion that because some with gender identity challenges have committed crimes (shock) the whole community should be portrayed as a risk and treated accordingly. It’s the comfort with that mentality on parts of this thread that is truly disturbing

Ok. Let me clarify something for you.

Not all men are criminals. We know it is a minority of men who are violent or sexually abusive.

Yet we still have single sex spaces to protect women from the men who are abusive.

We also have separate sporting categories because there men have a clear physical advantage over women in some sporting categories.

All the above is pretty uncontentious and few claim that women are discriminating against men for this.

Then we had people saying, my gender identity is that of a woman therefore, I should be allowed into women's single sex spaces. 

And increasing numbers of women said...we understand you want to live your lives in the way you see fit, but you are still male. 

This means:

You commit male crimes (at the same level of offending as non-trans males)

I (and many women) physically read you as male and you have been raised as a male with male anatomy, which means that I wouldn't feel comfortable with you in women only refuges or hospital wards

You still retain advantages in sports, due to male puberty, so competing against you is unfair.

Also,  de-facto self id, where any many can declare he is a women and access single sex spaces is green light to be abused by predatory males, whether trans or not. While self-ID was never officially the law in the UK, it was widely adopted in the NHS and the prison system.

Can you see? It is not about "discriminating against a small number of people", it is about ensuing that women have male free spaces when we need them. The law has spoken and males remain male whichever gender they identify with.
Reply
#50
This.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: