Everton, Villa, Chelsea and Forest
#41
(06-25-2024, 07:46 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 05:19 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: At the point you sell a player, surely the full carrying value has to be written off? I can’t be arsed reading that article.

That would be the accounting treatment, but it appears the PSR allow the purchase price to the written off over the contract length (max 5 years to stop Chelsea’s 8 year scam) on the initial deal.

It’s almost as if the rules were written to be broken by those that could truly afford to do so.

Really? Fuck me
Reply
#42
(06-25-2024, 08:02 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 07:46 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 05:19 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: At the point you sell a player, surely the full carrying value has to be written off? I can’t be arsed reading that article.

That would be the accounting treatment, but it appears the PSR allow the purchase price to the written off over the contract length (max 5 years to stop Chelsea’s 8 year scam) on the initial deal.

It’s almost as if the rules were written to be broken by those that could truly afford to do so.

Really? Fuck me

Yeah, but that's also why we won't need to sell Grant for £15m this summer to record a "profit"
Reply
#43
I don't remotely blame the 4 clubs involved in this. They're always going to find loopholes to get around it, and this is the latest one. Yes it's more frustrating because it involves the fishy cunts, but we're in a not too dissimilar position. Would you really be annoyed if we were involved in some similar dealings?

The upside is it shows what a mockery the PSR/FFP rules are. The big downside is that academy players are now traded like commodities, which can't be good for them. They might get a decent financial compensation though.
Reply
#44
They may as well create a seniors club, and just use them to trade for enough millions to cover the losses.

It'd be easy enough for the prem to say deals between two clubs in a season are treated as one deal, so total the sell value, total the buy value and whatever is left is either profit or loss.... So the Seals to Everton to Seal thing would net each club ZERO.

none of this £10m profit for you, £10m profit for you.... £2m per year loss for each of you over the next 5 years....which is bloody stupid.
Reply
#45
(06-25-2024, 09:44 AM)NewWanker Wrote: They may as well create a seniors club, and just use them to trade for enough millions to cover the losses.

It'd be easy enough for the prem to say deals between two clubs in a season are treated as one deal, so total the sell value, total the buy value and whatever is left is either profit or loss.... So the Seals to Everton to Seal thing would net each club ZERO.

none of this £10m profit for you, £10m profit for you.... £2m per year loss for each of you over the next 5 years....which is bloody stupid.

Or give the academy they nicked the players from 50% of the sale price.  So overvaluing players would become harder because you'd be generating a huge liability.

Granted it doesn't work for players not nicked from other clubs.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#46
(06-25-2024, 11:16 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:44 AM)NewWanker Wrote: They may as well create a seniors club, and just use them to trade for enough millions to cover the losses.

It'd be easy enough for the prem to say deals between two clubs in a season are treated as one deal, so total the sell value, total the buy value and whatever is left is either profit or loss.... So the Seals to Everton to Seal thing would net each club ZERO.

none of this £10m profit for you, £10m profit for you.... £2m per year loss for each of you over the next 5 years....which is bloody stupid.

Or give the academy they nicked the players from 50% of the sale price.  So overvaluing players would become harder because you'd be generating a huge liability.

Granted it doesn't work for players not nicked from other clubs.

then do both
Reply
#47
(06-25-2024, 11:16 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:44 AM)NewWanker Wrote: They may as well create a seniors club, and just use them to trade for enough millions to cover the losses.

It'd be easy enough for the prem to say deals between two clubs in a season are treated as one deal, so total the sell value, total the buy value and whatever is left is either profit or loss.... So the Seals to Everton to Seal thing would net each club ZERO.

none of this £10m profit for you, £10m profit for you.... £2m per year loss for each of you over the next 5 years....which is bloody stupid.

Or give the academy they nicked the players from 50% of the sale price.  So overvaluing players would become harder because you'd be generating a huge liability.

Granted it doesn't work for players not nicked from other clubs.
This should be mandatory.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)