Not a very sure start to life
#41
(02-07-2024, 11:01 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Austerity for the masses whilst giving tax breaks to the richest absolutely feels like a choice to me.

Which tax breaks are these? Specifically?

I hear this claptrap all the time.

And you're another one avoiding the issue. Debt.
Reply
#42
(02-07-2024, 07:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There’s the inescapable root of the issue.

The inescapable root of the issue is a failure to invest capital into infrastructure projects to improve connectivity, productivity and capacity which would enable economic growth (and therefore more money to cover operational day-to-day spending), and then attacking proposals to invest into infrastructure projects despite interest rates being at an extremely low level for ages.

You do not get out of a doom loop of stagnation by ignoring the actual root cause of the problem, the state needs to support infrastructure investment both in terms of public capital and regulatory support for private capital. Push has come to shove.

The State can’t “invest” without making the situation worse. QE has led to the intolerable situation that The Treasury has to underwrite the BoEs losses on bond sales. This could be to tune of tens of £billions each year.

We went through the looking glass in 2008, and smashed it to pieces during Covid & the energy price crisis. There is no prospect of a return to the “normality” essential to your plan.

I am quite used to being the lone voice of dissent on here, but it’s becoming clearer by the day that we’re reaping what we have sown.

The underwriting of BoE losses was caused by Osbourne's stupid insistence to rely on inflation-linked bonds instead of working with interest rates. That's a Tory failure, not a BoE failure.

The state gets a return on capital investment, that's the point. You need to get out of your pigheaded and fiscally reckless position of all government spending is bad, spending on infrastructure is not the same as operational spending and the former can be done through borrowing and has to be done otherwise the economy will not grow and we will be overtaken by the Czechs, Slovenes and Poles as they're currently on track to overtake us by the end of the decade.

And I don't really give a shit about your contrarian doomerism, we need to invest in our infrastructure. We do not have a choice if we want to get out of the doom spiral of economic stagnation. It could have been done over the last 14 years but it wasn't so it'll have to be done now. There is a solution - an explicit one - and tough shit if you don't like it because the medicine isn't always nice. We are well into a second lost decade, your attitude would consign us to a third and fourth lost decade.

(02-07-2024, 12:41 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Interest post BB.

With all the optimism in the world, do you think humanity has at least one more bounce era in it? I.e. that whatever logic is followed we can create another period of relative optimism and tangible progress?


 I don’t. But I’m willing to hear the case in favour.

So long as we don't blow ourselves up and manage to mitigate and prevent the worst of climate change I don't see why we can't, AI will bring massive productivity gains as it matures over the next century and we're moving towards renewables for energy production which is operationally dirt cheap so should provide us with lots of capacity to do stuff, so long as we bother to invest into it and not get scared by people infatuated with permanent austerity that will keep us in the doom loop.
Reply
#43
(02-07-2024, 12:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The underwriting of BoE losses was caused by Osbourne's stupid insistence to rely on inflation-linked bonds instead of working with interest rates. That's a Tory failure, not a BoE failure.

The state gets a return on capital investment, that's the point. You need to get out of your pigheaded and fiscally reckless position of all government spending is bad, spending on infrastructure is not the same as operational spending and the former can be done through borrowing and has to be done otherwise the economy will not grow and we will be overtaken by the Czechs, Slovenes and Poles as they're currently on track to overtake us by the end of the decade.

And I don't really give a shit about your contrarian doomerism, we need to invest in our infrastructure. We do not have a choice if we want to get out of the doom spiral of economic stagnation. It could have been done over the last 14 years but it wasn't so it'll have to be done now. There is a solution - an explicit one - and tough shit if you don't like it because the medicine isn't always nice. We are well into a second lost decade, your attitude would consign us to a third and fourth lost decade.

Have I ever argued in favour of the indexation of debt? No.

Have I ever argued that ALL government spending is bad? No.

Or that the State should not borrow to invest? No, on the contrary I have argued in favour of specific bonds for housing and other infrastructure.

All I've said is how difficult it will be to do so because of the actions of previous governments commencing in 2008. It is a juvenile solution to simply contend that "we need to do it anyway" even if the bond market collapses as it did under Truss. That's not doomerism, it's realism.

Circumstances and novel(!) government / BoE actions have conspired to get us into this unique mess, and you will not get out of it using traditional methods. 

Over the years I've already offered up solutions in some areas, such as housing bonds, working pensioners paying NI, and the state having a first charge on homes if you choose to rely on the state for social care / residential care in your dotage. Inevitably the cost of what has transpired over the last 16 years will fall on us one way or the other - and rightly so as, largely, we've been complicit in the confidence trick we were first offered in 2008, and during every crisis since.
Reply
#44
But campaigned for a party with all the innovative nouse of a goldfish
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#45
(02-07-2024, 01:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-07-2024, 12:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The underwriting of BoE losses was caused by Osbourne's stupid insistence to rely on inflation-linked bonds instead of working with interest rates. That's a Tory failure, not a BoE failure.

The state gets a return on capital investment, that's the point. You need to get out of your pigheaded and fiscally reckless position of all government spending is bad, spending on infrastructure is not the same as operational spending and the former can be done through borrowing and has to be done otherwise the economy will not grow and we will be overtaken by the Czechs, Slovenes and Poles as they're currently on track to overtake us by the end of the decade.

And I don't really give a shit about your contrarian doomerism, we need to invest in our infrastructure. We do not have a choice if we want to get out of the doom spiral of economic stagnation. It could have been done over the last 14 years but it wasn't so it'll have to be done now. There is a solution - an explicit one - and tough shit if you don't like it because the medicine isn't always nice. We are well into a second lost decade, your attitude would consign us to a third and fourth lost decade.

Have I ever argued in favour of the indexation of debt? No.

Have I ever argued that ALL government spending is bad? No.

Or that the State should not borrow to invest? No, on the contrary I have argued in favour of specific bonds for housing and other infrastructure.

All I've said is how difficult it will be to do so because of the actions of previous governments commencing in 2008. It is a juvenile solution to simply contend that "we need to do it anyway" even if the bond market collapses as it did under Truss. That's not doomerism, it's realism.

Circumstances and novel(!) government / BoE actions have conspired to get us into this unique mess, and you will not get out of it using traditional methods. 

Over the years I've already offered up solutions in some areas, such as housing bonds, working pensioners paying NI, and the state having a first charge on homes if you choose to rely on the state for social care / residential care in your dotage. Inevitably the cost of what has transpired over the last 16 years will fall on us one way or the other - and rightly so as, largely, we've been complicit in the confidence trick we were first offered in 2008, and during every crisis since.

It's doomerism. You're staring at a doom spiral of economic stagnation and don't want to do the one thing that will get us out of it, which is to grow the economy. And you grow the economy by investing into infrastructure that boosts productivity and capacity.

No shit it's difficult, there's no other way out of it though. That's the consequence of putting off infrastructure development for decades. 

Truss fucked up because her and the people surrounding her wanted to borrow for operational spending. This is completely different and infrastructure investment has millennia of precedent that it works. It's working right now in the US, it's working right now in the eastern EU states.

And it's telling that you're talking about social and residential care, that is not capital investment. Stop moving the goalposts, it's obvious what will cover that. Also stop whining about 2008, in 2015 there was only one major UK political party that was opposed to investment into infrastructure - you campaigned for them. That's years before COVID, it's years after the financial crisis and it's years we lost with low interest rates to invest in infrastructure because the Tories have not and never have known what fiscal responsibility is.
Reply
#46
(02-07-2024, 01:37 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: But campaigned for a party with all the innovative nouse of a goldfish

I campaigned for the #LeastWorst outcome on several occasions. I might have mentioned it before. 

As it turns out the period since I last voted Tory has seen the greatest waste of public money in our history on untargeted Covid relief and even less targeted energy price relief. I apologise profusely for not warning you all about Covid and Putin's impending invasion of Ukraine in December 2019. My bad.

None of which changes the fact that whoever is in government next is going to find things rather difficult - unless they engage in even more financial repression, which I guess won't be popular.
Reply
#47
Now that Starmer & Co. have finally jettisoned their commitment to borrowing £28bn extra per year we’re left with altering non-dom status which will create a warm feeling for the left but very little actual money, and VAT on private school fees which will hit the middle classes hardest and lead to a host of unintended consequences.

Aside from that, its more of the same but delivered with Princess Di’s empathetic face.

In terms of outcomes, once again you can’t get a Rizla between them. It’s now just about optics. Again.
Reply
#48
I suspect that at the very least we won’t see some key positions occupied by around 15 different ministers under his leadership. Fag paper ideologically or not, that’s a seismic difference. As you will see if you read the comments from the military leadership today.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#49
Quite. The scale of resignations and sackings by the Tories in the last few years is only matched by Labour in their brief flirtation with Socialism under Corbyn.
Reply
#50
The difference being that wasn’t destroying the country as it occurred.
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)