For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives
#41
(04-11-2019, 09:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 08:57 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Firstly Derek, the underwhelming factor is, I would like the club to show some fucking ambition!

The current news is like we are about to appoint a fucking roasted Parsnip for the rest of the season.

That’s not answering the question Saus. Who would you have preferred? Just a few names of realistic targets. I imagine some will say Jankovic and Wagner (spelling) but there CVs are patchy with relegation and resignations. 

If he was a foreign manager with a similar CV I suspect the link would be more warmly / excitedly recurved.

I would of preferred Jokanovic, and unfortunately, Fat Sam is probably more appealing, someone like Bilic could probably have been tempted, Rowett would not have been a bad option. 

Of the johnny foreigners I can think of that we could have possibly enquired to, you'd probably want someone German considering the football is very similar, Stoger - ex Dortmund, Herrlich - ex LeverKusen, and if you wanted tippy tappy we could have enquired with a Spaniard like Garcia ex - Villareal or Ziganda ex - Bilbao...

But no..... The club smattering with very little ambition, go for bland and underwhelming:

[Image: 214111ebdef55ccd421bf8fda4087c67.jpg]
Reply
#42
I think if we are willing to pay £650k compo means he’s not the cheap option, and possibly the number 1 target all along. I can see why and have warmed to the idea so much that I’d like an approach made prior to the weekend so he can watch the game as a relative neutral
Reply
#43
His one mistake was that summer recruitment at Norwich. He admits that himself, otherwise his record is surprisingly impressive. Doesn't have some stupid philosophy about the game and adapts to what he has at his disposal.

Young and determined with ambition, I was too hasty to write him off I think, I reckon he'll prove to be a very good choice.
Reply
#44
Welcome Alix Neel!

Sold me when I read this bit:

“‘Before you go, Seb,’ ‘Yes boss?’ ‘If you fuck around I’ll break your balls.’
Reply
#45
I would be more than happy with Neil. The Premier League has really changed the attitude and expectations of our fans.

I don't like it.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#46
(04-11-2019, 09:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.

However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.

The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.

Why would Alex Neil want the poison chalice that's the Albion job?  In fact he's already distanced himself from it.   Wink
Reply
#47
(04-11-2019, 04:57 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 09:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.

However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.

The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.

Why would Alex Neil want the poison chalice that's the Albion job?  In fact he's already distanced himself from it.   Wink
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#48
(04-11-2019, 09:15 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Seems an ok choice to me - others touted earlier don't seem to want to come, or the stories were misleading,  so we may have little choice. But any new appointment is a risk and at this stage a big one. I would have stuck with Moore - he was on a bad run but had got out of one before - Smith had a bad run at Villa and they weren't daft enough to sack him for it. The reason seemed to be so we would make the top two but that has backfired after an initial bounce and we look more at sea now.
That alternative has gone though, so if we have targeted Neil, I hope at least we get him and he doesn't turn us down based on some part of the deal - he hasn't signed yet and this is the Albion...

What has Dean Smith ever achieved as a manager?  

Neil has won promotion twice via the play-offs and has a year's premier league experience and is 14 years younger. He also just missed out on the play-offs last season by 2 points with Preston.
Reply
#49
(04-11-2019, 04:57 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 09:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.

However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.

The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.

Why would Alex Neil want the poison chalice that's the Albion job?  In fact he's already distanced himself from it.   Wink

I don't buy that the managerial job at the Albion is a poisoned chalice.

Yes, we're tight. But at least that means we're a financially stable club, that doesn't need to flash sale our assets just to keep the club alive.

We have enough playing staff with sellable value to allow any manager to be appointed, and mould a squad in his own image.

I know with each season at this level, promotion gets more and more difficult, but going into next season we have a good enough chance to go up, to be attractive to a new manager. 

We have a promising academy which is starting to produce some excellent talent.

We have top training facilities, a good stadium, which produces a loud atmosphere, and we generally have a patient and understanding fan base.

Is the job 'that' bad? There are worse clubs to manage, out there.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#50
(04-11-2019, 05:19 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 04:57 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 09:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.

However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.

The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.

Why would Alex Neil want the poison chalice that's the Albion job?  In fact he's already distanced himself from it.   Wink

I don't buy that the managerial job at the Albion is a poisoned chalice.

Yes, we're tight. But at least that means we're a financially stable club, that doesn't need to flash sale our assets just to keep the club alive.

We have enough playing staff with sellable value to allow any manager to be appointed, and mould a squad in his own image.

I know with each season at this level, promotion gets more and more difficult, but going into next season we have a good enough chance to go up, to be attractive to a new manager. 

We have a promising academy which is starting to produce some excellent talent.

We have top training facilities, a good stadium, which produces a loud atmosphere, and we generally have a patient and understanding fan base.

Is the job 'that' bad? There are worse clubs to manage, out there.
All this is true. But our problem is our owners.
Would you trust them, in Neil's position?

I also wouldn't warm to a bloke who walks out on his club before the end of the season.

I will be surprised if he comes (but this is football, so anything can happen I guess)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: