Posts: 1,674
Threads: 93
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(09-02-2023, 09:04 AM)Atomic Wrote: I think the biggest feeling overall is one of relief.
Going into this transfer window we knew it was going to be a challenging one and we were aware of the financial restraints. Fans are powerless and we had to place our trust into the hands of people running the operations within the club and that's not easy for fans to do given the recent history.
My biggest fear was us selling the (relative) quality that we had within last seasons squad and the sake of Dara O'Shea early on in this window did nothing to ease those fears. However, Dara is the only one we have sold that I'd put in that "quality" bracket. That's a very good result in terms of our onfield position given the position we are in off the field.
Taylor Gardner-Hickman's departure for Bristol City is not a transfer I'm particularly pleased about but I do appreciate something has to give.
If you look at our squad now for this coming season you can certainly argue that it's better than last seasons squad.
Mowatt, Kipre, Taylor and Fellows have all returned from loans and Josh Maja is a much needed addition to our attack. Added to that Jeremy Sarmiento is a loanee that looks full of promise and Pipa joins as right back competition for Furlong and given that he's played under Corberan twice before, he's obviously got something about him that the head coach likes.
The squad isn't as thin as some people make out. We actually have a squad of 25 players all of whom have Championship experience and we do have two players for each position:
Palmer
Griffiths
Furlong Ajayi Kipre Townsend
Pipa Bartley Pieters Reach
Taylor Kelly
Molumby Yokuslu
Mowatt Chalobah
Wallace Phillips
Fellows Diangana
Swift
Sarmiento
Thomas-Asante
Maja
Dike
That is by no means bad by Championship standards. There's probably one too many centre backs in there and one too few midfielders but it's a well balanced squad. Whether we have enough quality in a couple of areas is open to debate but though it wouldn't be our strongest squad in the last twenty years it's a perfectly respectable one at this level.
I think those running operations deserve credit for compiling this squad under the circumstances.
In terms of finances it's very hard for any fan to offer a strong opinion on the progress made because none of us are privy to the information we'd require to form that opinion. On the face of it I'd say the club would've been extremely keen to offload the likes of Diangana, Grant, Kelly, Bartley had the opportunity arisen and they'll probably be disappointed not to have brought more money into the club. What this means regarding the desperation of our finances I don't know. The club don't appear to be desperate indicated by turning down offers for Thomas-Asante, so hopefully we're getting by which is all we can reasonably expect at the moment and of course there may be stuff going on behind the scenes that none of us fans are currently aware of, in fact I suspect there probably is.
In summary, all in the garden is far from rosy, but I'm happy with the way West Bromwich Albion have handled this transfer window and we can all relax for the time being at least knowing that things could've been far, far worse, certainly on the playing front
Good post my feelings exactly
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(09-02-2023, 08:41 AM)baggie93 Wrote: Im not sure that not selling BTA to Stoke paints a brighter picture of our finances. It seemed that Stoke wanted to pay in instalments which wouldnt have helped our problem much. Isnt this why Dara went a bit cheaper..we had the 7m straight away..rather than instalments.
I’m convinced they think they can see out the season with another cash boost in Jan. Namely Diangana and Josh, with maybe moving on (a newly fit) Kelly and Bartley.
None of us know the true extent but that could boost cash flow by c£10-12m and take £800k off the wage bill.
The issue as I said on another thread is the end of the season, if we aren’t promoted or fail to have investment then it really does go pop.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Glad we kept hold of our big hitters (Dara excepted). Think we look light in midfield, but given finances, can't grumble. Just keeping fingers crossed we don't see Wallace, Swift, Phillips, Molumby and especially Yokoslu injured. It's a squad good enough to stay up and that was my priority for this season, tbh.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-02-2023, 11:10 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Glad we kept hold of our big hitters (Dara excepted). Think we look light in midfield, but given finances, can't grumble. Just keeping fingers crossed we don't see Wallace, Swift, Phillips, Molumby and especially Yokoslu injured. It's a squad good enough to stay up and that was my priority for this season, tbh.
The squad is much better currently than just staying up. It should be competing for a play-off place.
Posts: 7,409
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-02-2023, 07:36 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I forgot about Kelly. Is he fit ?
(09-02-2023, 04:46 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Disappointed we let Malcolm go, what happens if BTA gets injured? CC like previous managers seems
reluctant to give our youngsters a go. With five subs allowed in a game it should be easier.
Pipa does not seem to have played much of late, has he been injured?
Shakpoke could step up? Could be a problem with Shakpoke, pulled up injured before the under 23 defeat to Chelsea last night.
Posts: 588
Threads: 8
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation:
12
09-02-2023, 11:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-02-2023, 11:20 AM by Mr Nimbus.)
(09-02-2023, 11:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-02-2023, 11:10 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Glad we kept hold of our big hitters (Dara excepted). Think we look light in midfield, but given finances, can't grumble. Just keeping fingers crossed we don't see Wallace, Swift, Phillips, Molumby and especially Yokoslu injured. It's a squad good enough to stay up and that was my priority for this season, tbh.
The squad is much better currently than just staying up. It should be competing for a play-off place.
Yep. This squad is more balanced, with the three additions, than the one that challenged for top six last season before key injuries (Dara, Yok and Palmer) scuppered us. Manager is the key, but we need the spine to stay fit (or at least not lose them together/for long periods as last year).
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(09-02-2023, 09:45 AM)Cornflake Wrote: (09-02-2023, 09:04 AM)Atomic Wrote: I think the biggest feeling overall is one of relief.
Going into this transfer window we knew it was going to be a challenging one and we were aware of the financial restraints. Fans are powerless and we had to place our trust into the hands of people running the operations within the club and that's not easy for fans to do given the recent history.
My biggest fear was us selling the (relative) quality that we had within last seasons squad and the sake of Dara O'Shea early on in this window did nothing to ease those fears. However, Dara is the only one we have sold that I'd put in that "quality" bracket. That's a very good result in terms of our onfield position given the position we are in off the field.
Taylor Gardner-Hickman's departure for Bristol City is not a transfer I'm particularly pleased about but I do appreciate something has to give.
If you look at our squad now for this coming season you can certainly argue that it's better than last seasons squad.
Mowatt, Kipre, Taylor and Fellows have all returned from loans and Josh Maja is a much needed addition to our attack. Added to that Jeremy Sarmiento is a loanee that looks full of promise and Pipa joins as right back competition for Furlong and given that he's played under Corberan twice before, he's obviously got something about him that the head coach likes.
The squad isn't as thin as some people make out. We actually have a squad of 25 players all of whom have Championship experience and we do have two players for each position:
Palmer
Griffiths
Furlong Ajayi Kipre Townsend
Pipa Bartley Pieters Reach
Taylor Kelly
Molumby Yokuslu
Mowatt Chalobah
Wallace Phillips
Fellows Diangana
Swift
Sarmiento
Thomas-Asante
Maja
Dike
That is by no means bad by Championship standards. There's probably one too many centre backs in there and one too few midfielders but it's a well balanced squad. Whether we have enough quality in a couple of areas is open to debate but though it wouldn't be our strongest squad in the last twenty years it's a perfectly respectable one at this level.
I think those running operations deserve credit for compiling this squad under the circumstances.
In terms of finances it's very hard for any fan to offer a strong opinion on the progress made because none of us are privy to the information we'd require to form that opinion. On the face of it I'd say the club would've been extremely keen to offload the likes of Diangana, Grant, Kelly, Bartley had the opportunity arisen and they'll probably be disappointed not to have brought more money into the club. What this means regarding the desperation of our finances I don't know. The club don't appear to be desperate indicated by turning down offers for Thomas-Asante, so hopefully we're getting by which is all we can reasonably expect at the moment and of course there may be stuff going on behind the scenes that none of us fans are currently aware of, in fact I suspect there probably is.
In summary, all in the garden is far from rosy, but I'm happy with the way West Bromwich Albion have handled this transfer window and we can all relax for the time being at least knowing that things could've been far, far worse, certainly on the playing front
Good post my feelings exactly
Excellent post , although 3 of the 25 (Reach, Kelly and Dike) are long term injuries
I wonder if any of the (remaining) kids e.g. Cleary might get a go.
Posts: 7,409
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-02-2023, 11:17 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (09-02-2023, 09:45 AM)Cornflake Wrote: (09-02-2023, 09:04 AM)Atomic Wrote: I think the biggest feeling overall is one of relief.
Going into this transfer window we knew it was going to be a challenging one and we were aware of the financial restraints. Fans are powerless and we had to place our trust into the hands of people running the operations within the club and that's not easy for fans to do given the recent history.
My biggest fear was us selling the (relative) quality that we had within last seasons squad and the sake of Dara O'Shea early on in this window did nothing to ease those fears. However, Dara is the only one we have sold that I'd put in that "quality" bracket. That's a very good result in terms of our onfield position given the position we are in off the field.
Taylor Gardner-Hickman's departure for Bristol City is not a transfer I'm particularly pleased about but I do appreciate something has to give.
If you look at our squad now for this coming season you can certainly argue that it's better than last seasons squad.
Mowatt, Kipre, Taylor and Fellows have all returned from loans and Josh Maja is a much needed addition to our attack. Added to that Jeremy Sarmiento is a loanee that looks full of promise and Pipa joins as right back competition for Furlong and given that he's played under Corberan twice before, he's obviously got something about him that the head coach likes.
The squad isn't as thin as some people make out. We actually have a squad of 25 players all of whom have Championship experience and we do have two players for each position:
Palmer
Griffiths
Furlong Ajayi Kipre Townsend
Pipa Bartley Pieters Reach
Taylor Kelly
Molumby Yokuslu
Mowatt Chalobah
Wallace Phillips
Fellows Diangana
Swift
Sarmiento
Thomas-Asante
Maja
Dike
That is by no means bad by Championship standards. There's probably one too many centre backs in there and one too few midfielders but it's a well balanced squad. Whether we have enough quality in a couple of areas is open to debate but though it wouldn't be our strongest squad in the last twenty years it's a perfectly respectable one at this level.
I think those running operations deserve credit for compiling this squad under the circumstances.
In terms of finances it's very hard for any fan to offer a strong opinion on the progress made because none of us are privy to the information we'd require to form that opinion. On the face of it I'd say the club would've been extremely keen to offload the likes of Diangana, Grant, Kelly, Bartley had the opportunity arisen and they'll probably be disappointed not to have brought more money into the club. What this means regarding the desperation of our finances I don't know. The club don't appear to be desperate indicated by turning down offers for Thomas-Asante, so hopefully we're getting by which is all we can reasonably expect at the moment and of course there may be stuff going on behind the scenes that none of us fans are currently aware of, in fact I suspect there probably is.
In summary, all in the garden is far from rosy, but I'm happy with the way West Bromwich Albion have handled this transfer window and we can all relax for the time being at least knowing that things could've been far, far worse, certainly on the playing front
Good post my feelings exactly
Excellent post , although 3 of the 25 (Reach, Kelly and Dike) are long term injuries
I wonder if any of the (remaining) kids e.g. Cleary might get a go.
Good post Atomic. I’m totally on board with this squad at present. Hopefully a sale is in the pipeline and we can become all as one again.
Posts: 588
Threads: 8
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation:
12
Cleary still on the comeback from a recurring hamstring injury (no, i wasnt aware until this morning iether). I'm guessing this is the reason he's not gone on loan rather than his proximity to a first team place.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(09-02-2023, 11:24 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Cleary still on the comeback from a recurring hamstring injury (no, i wasnt aware until this morning iether). I'm guessing this is the reason he's not gone on loan rather than his proximity to a first team place.
I think there must be a reason Cleary hasn't featured over the last 18 months? For some reason or other he just hasn't been 1st choice reserve despite looking the most able of our yoot.
|