Posts: 8,084
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
09-16-2022, 04:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2022, 04:17 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(09-16-2022, 02:54 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-16-2022, 10:58 AM)MancBaggie Wrote: I never ever want us to lose. if we go on a run of wins, everyone's laughing
Peachy and Cuzer have nailed it. The lack of preparation and conditioning is like when Pisscan was here - just a bunch of players told to give it their best. That was outdated in 2006 - let alone now.
He actually has good coaches - but this merit is totally undermined by him shoehorning his son. Ridiculous we allowed this
SB's big attribute historically has been his good transfer business - but the CH fiasco and bizarre decision not to replace Carroll or CR from last season(who like or hate him went for peanuts) means we dont even benefit from that
If we sack Bruce, we will be appointing a 5th manager in under 2.5 seasons.
I agree about the conditioning of the players, but it is definitely something that pre existed Bruce.
I think back to the Bilic season at Xmas, which was the last time I was confident about the trajectory of the club. How many players have improved since then, including arrivals after that.
What is wrong with a club that its players stagnate or get worse after joining them.
It’s easy to point to when the rot set in. And who set it there.
Prior to that we had a system and reporting structure we wouldn’t break for anyone; even Hodgson. It had its bad parts but largely served us well. when Pulis joined, the team were a shitshow but the club wasn’t. Since Pulis left, it’s all largely been a shitshow.
Interestingly enough; when we did the Top 5 Worst, Pulis wasn’t in mine on statistics. But for damage done to a club since leaving, I’d say he’s comfortably going home with a medal.
Had JRP been around to mop-up the damage, we’d likely be OK. He wasn’t and this lot were. The rest is history.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
My take on this 'situation' is that it probably is time for him to go, but the underlying 'rottenness' of the club is seriously problematic. However, with the players we have , I think a better manager would have us in he top 6 now.
Bruce isn't wholly to blame, but I am concerned with the issue of starting games slowly. Birmingham's opening goal was on the cards and we could have been a gola behind before they scored. We rallied well and equalised, and at that point, Bruce needed to alter things. Sometimes, Bruce does not really change the approach enough in order to get a breakthrough or to dominate the middle of the park and getting the majority of the second balls. But he cannot get past the sluggish way we start matches and this has cost us 5 or 6 points already. This is the difference between 20th and 6th.
It isn't al bad, but rarely is and we need an inventive manager and coaching staff. We need more, but this is the requirement now, I feel.
Posts: 1,308
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(09-16-2022, 04:15 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (09-16-2022, 02:54 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-16-2022, 10:58 AM)MancBaggie Wrote: I never ever want us to lose. if we go on a run of wins, everyone's laughing
Peachy and Cuzer have nailed it. The lack of preparation and conditioning is like when Pisscan was here - just a bunch of players told to give it their best. That was outdated in 2006 - let alone now.
He actually has good coaches - but this merit is totally undermined by him shoehorning his son. Ridiculous we allowed this
SB's big attribute historically has been his good transfer business - but the CH fiasco and bizarre decision not to replace Carroll or CR from last season(who like or hate him went for peanuts) means we dont even benefit from that
If we sack Bruce, we will be appointing a 5th manager in under 2.5 seasons.
I agree about the conditioning of the players, but it is definitely something that pre existed Bruce.
I think back to the Bilic season at Xmas, which was the last time I was confident about the trajectory of the club. How many players have improved since then, including arrivals after that.
What is wrong with a club that its players stagnate or get worse after joining them.
It’s easy to point to when the rot set in. And who set it there.
Prior to that we had a system and reporting structure we wouldn’t break for anyone; even Hodgson. It had its bad parts but largely served us well. when Pulis joined, the team were a shitshow but the club wasn’t. Since Pulis left, it’s all largely been a shitshow.
Interestingly enough; when we did the Top 5 Worst, Pulis wasn’t in mine on statistics. But for damage done to a club since leaving, I’d say he’s comfortably going home with a medal.
Had JRP been around to mop-up the damage, we’d likely be OK. He wasn’t and this lot were. The rest is history.
all valid points, although it would be madness even if we could afford to, to sack him now. Has to be given until Christmas and then lets see where we are, three wins on the bounce in this league would see us in the play offs, starting tomorrow. although conceeding three at home to the blues is worrying.
Posts: 516
Threads: 23
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
My worry is that Bruce seems incapable of putting a winning run together,which any team hopeful of promotion needs to do ,just can’t see him putting a run of win’s together
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(09-16-2022, 05:05 PM)igorbalis Wrote: it would be madness even if we could afford to, to sack him now. Has to be given until Christmas and then lets see where we are, three wins on the bounce in this league would see us in the play offs, starting tomorrow. although conceeding three at home to the blues is worrying.
Why would it be madness? He's been failing since his arrival and the hopes some had of him somehow doing better this season have been dashed. Having won only once this season, and just 7 times altogether during his tenure, winning 3 in a row looks pretty unlikely.
Bruce's 9 points from the first 9 games of this season is worse than Ismael's 11 points from his final 9 games.
Posts: 1,308
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(09-16-2022, 05:28 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:05 PM)igorbalis Wrote: it would be madness even if we could afford to, to sack him now. Has to be given until Christmas and then lets see where we are, three wins on the bounce in this league would see us in the play offs, starting tomorrow. although conceeding three at home to the blues is worrying.
Why would it be madness? He's been failing since his arrival and the hopes some had of him somehow doing better this season have been dashed. Having won only once this season, and just 7 times altogether during his tenure, winning 3 in a row looks pretty unlikely.
Bruce's 9 points from the first 9 games of this season is worse than Ismael's 11 points from his final 9 games.
simply because we need some continuity, we cant just keep sacking managers - the problem lies with the owners, and whoever they are, they arent going to invest in the club, so we need to get behing the team more than ever, and those who want us to loose tomorrow can f*ck right off (sorry junior baggies!)
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-16-2022, 05:35 PM)igorbalis Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:28 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:05 PM)igorbalis Wrote: it would be madness even if we could afford to, to sack him now. Has to be given until Christmas and then lets see where we are, three wins on the bounce in this league would see us in the play offs, starting tomorrow. although conceeding three at home to the blues is worrying.
Why would it be madness? He's been failing since his arrival and the hopes some had of him somehow doing better this season have been dashed. Having won only once this season, and just 7 times altogether during his tenure, winning 3 in a row looks pretty unlikely.
Bruce's 9 points from the first 9 games of this season is worse than Ismael's 11 points from his final 9 games.
simply because we need some continuity, we cant just keep sacking managers - the problem lies with the owners, and whoever they are, they arent going to invest in the club, so we need to get behing the team more than ever, and those who want us to loose tomorrow can f*ck right off (sorry junior baggies!)
If we carry on as we are under Bruce, we'll end up in League One.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(09-16-2022, 05:35 PM)igorbalis Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:28 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:05 PM)igorbalis Wrote: it would be madness even if we could afford to, to sack him now. Has to be given until Christmas and then lets see where we are, three wins on the bounce in this league would see us in the play offs, starting tomorrow. although conceeding three at home to the blues is worrying.
Why would it be madness? He's been failing since his arrival and the hopes some had of him somehow doing better this season have been dashed. Having won only once this season, and just 7 times altogether during his tenure, winning 3 in a row looks pretty unlikely.
Bruce's 9 points from the first 9 games of this season is worse than Ismael's 11 points from his final 9 games.
simply because we need some continuity, we cant just keep sacking managers - the problem lies with the owners, and whoever they are, they arent going to invest in the club, so we need to get behing the team more than ever, and those who want us to loose tomorrow can f*ck right off (sorry junior baggies!)
Call me radical, but perhaps we should appoint a hungry, young manager with modern ideas and some clearly recognisable tactics (plus some in-game adaptability), who will stand a better chance of keeping the fans on his side through using a style of play that is more to their liking whilst making the most of our players' strengths. Then we wouldn't need to keep sacking managers would we?
What you're suggesting is continuity for continuity's sake, basically, and not because Bruce is deserving of the fans' or the club's loyalty.
Posts: 1,308
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(09-16-2022, 05:45 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:35 PM)igorbalis Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:28 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-16-2022, 05:05 PM)igorbalis Wrote: it would be madness even if we could afford to, to sack him now. Has to be given until Christmas and then lets see where we are, three wins on the bounce in this league would see us in the play offs, starting tomorrow. although conceeding three at home to the blues is worrying.
Why would it be madness? He's been failing since his arrival and the hopes some had of him somehow doing better this season have been dashed. Having won only once this season, and just 7 times altogether during his tenure, winning 3 in a row looks pretty unlikely.
Bruce's 9 points from the first 9 games of this season is worse than Ismael's 11 points from his final 9 games.
simply because we need some continuity, we cant just keep sacking managers - the problem lies with the owners, and whoever they are, they arent going to invest in the club, so we need to get behing the team more than ever, and those who want us to loose tomorrow can f*ck right off (sorry junior baggies!)
Call me radical, but perhaps we should appoint a hungry, young manager with modern ideas and some clearly recognisable tactics (plus some in-game adaptability), who will stand a better chance of keeping the fans on his side through using a style of play that is more to their liking whilst making the most of our players' strengths. Then we wouldn't need to keep sacking managers would we?
What you're suggesting is continuity for continuity's sake, basically, and not because Bruce is deserving of the fans' or the club's loyalty.
But you could argue that Bruce has the experience and knows what it takes to get teams promoted from this league. I bad result does not a season make, and hopefully we will show some sort of reaction tomorrow. I think he deserves until Christmas and then lets see where we are, I thought Bruce was the wrong appointment from the start, but we cant keep sacking managers every twelve months.
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
Bruce did nothing to get the job in the first place.
Bruce did nothing last season to warrant an extension.
Bruce has done nothing to improve our record of conceding the first goal inside 20 mins each week.
Bruce has done nothing in terms of trying a different formation considering we are missing a target man.
Bruce has done nothing to improve set pieces both defensively and offensively.
Bruce has done nothing this season to expect more time.
There is absolutely nothing to suggest that keeping Bruce will suddenly turn us into a potent force in this division. Unless Dike comes back and plays like a world beater but even then he would need to score a couple each week considering the way we defend. The only time we try a new formation is when it is all going wrong and we chuck players on from the bench and nobody seems to have a clue where they are supposed to be playing.
If Bruce keeps on doing nothing then he will finally achieve something - relegation.
|