06-13-2022, 11:06 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-14-2022, 08:23 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(06-13-2022, 07:36 PM)Squid Wrote:(06-13-2022, 05:59 PM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote:(06-13-2022, 03:13 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-13-2022, 02:58 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:It's a good explanation.(06-13-2022, 01:44 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: To my mind if you've got a penis, you're a male, if you've got a vagina you're female. It's that simple. (I know scientifically, in extreme and rare circumstances there's a gray area, when you have both male and female genitalia).
BUT if someone wants to identify as one or the other (or non-binary) then if that makes them happy, and they aren't hurting anyone, whats the issue? I don't claim to fully understand the mentality of people who claim to be born in the wrong body, but it must be torture if you truly believe that.
I may get hate for the following, and the above, but here goes.
If you have female tendencies, when you're male, or male tendencies, when you're female, you're made to feel it's wrong, so you start to feel you're in the wrong body. If society didn't judge and you weren't picked on, discriminated or bullied, you'd live your life as you wanted and wouldn't need to change sex. So the issue is how society acts, not with the individual.
Really interesting take... I guess only those who've gone through it ay be able to explain.
Good post.
The stereotypes of gender probably push a lot of people into uncomfortable areas.
Maybe many aren't in the wrong body, but just uncomfortable with society's definition of what it is to be a man or a woman.
At one end you get grunting muscular macho men who like football and chopping wood and enjoy building a shed. Equally you get women caked in make -up wearing pink and painting their nails at the other extreme. All of us sit somewhere in the whole spectrum.
For instance I have a soft spoken mate who many people think is gay, when he is married with 2 kids, and likes football.
A medical friend of mine when we discussing transgender some time ago said the problem is a mental health issue and society's role in reinforcing stereotypes.
[font="Frutiger W01", Arial, sans-serif]Gender dysphoria is not a mental illness. Your “medical friend” (whatever that means) chatting shit.[/font]
It's in the DSM-5.
If it isn't a mental illness and there is no physiological cause for gender dysphoria, then it shouldn't require any medical treatment whatsoever and NHS service provision can be withdrawn.
People need to take care of the arguments they make as it may lead to somewhere they didn't intend.
BaggieBaggieBromBrom it may be you talking out your bum bum. I think my medical friend, a psychiatrist if you’re pressing, his opinion is possibly worthy of debate as it clearly isn’t a disease like motor neurone, cancer, Parkinsons etc. It’s not something that is tangible as it is currently no more than an opinion in the mind of the person wanting to undergo the surgery so keep your mind open. It’s clearly a complex matter as to why people want to change gender.

