Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
From the Bilic promotion season we have lost Pereria, Sawyers, Krovonovic, HRK, Austen, Ferguson and Edwards.
And replaced with Hugil, Reach, Mowatt, Clarke, Snodgrass, Grant and Molumby.
Think I would prefer the players in the first list than the second.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(10-21-2021, 12:04 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: From the Bilic promotion season we have lost Pereria, Sawyers, Krovonovic, HRK, Austen, Ferguson and Edwards.
And replaced with Hugil, Reach, Mowatt, Clarke, Snodgrass, Grant and Molumby.
Think I would prefer the players in the first list than the second.
Sawyers/Krov for Molumby/Mowatt is pretty balanced.
Hugill for Austen - again much as a muchness but yes Austin scored (but we all have Grant & Robinson)
Edwards/Ferguson - not that concerned about
HRK - perfect for our system now
Pereira is the loss
However the point of my post is that 'th ere aren't many teams that would call themselves weak with Johnstone, Townsend, Clarke, Ajayi, Mowatt, Robinson, Grady, Phillips and Grant in their first XI - but the way we play negates their strengths because we don't have all the players needed to play this system.' Its a coaching, tactical point.
We have enough for to 6, top 3, it is that we are less than the sum of our parts rather than being devoid of actual quality.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(10-20-2021, 08:56 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Considering we know Grant, Robinson and Philips aren’t bad players it is quite shocking how bad we look.
We looked word-class for the first 54 seconds  .
What I find really annoying is the media mantra that 'Albion press opponents to make mistakes to then capitalise'. Isn't that what Man City do, just that they have better players.
Robinson is overrated. Needs too many touches and fluffs far too many chances and good situations. I was saying this towards the end of this first loan period and got slaughtered.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(10-21-2021, 12:17 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: (10-21-2021, 12:04 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: From the Bilic promotion season we have lost Pereria, Sawyers, Krovonovic, HRK, Austen, Ferguson and Edwards.
And replaced with Hugil, Reach, Mowatt, Clarke, Snodgrass, Grant and Molumby.
Think I would prefer the players in the first list than the second.
Sawyers/Krov for Molumby/Mowatt is pretty balanced.
Hugill for Austen - again much as a muchness but yes Austin scored (but we all have Grant & Robinson)
Edwards/Ferguson - not that concerned about
HRK - perfect for our system now
Pereira is the loss
However the point of my post is that 'there aren't many teams that would call themselves weak with Johnstone, Townsend, Clarke, Ajayi, Mowatt, Robinson, Grady, Phillips and Grant in their first XI - but the way we play negates their strengths because we don't have all the players needed to play this system.' Its a coaching, tactical point.
We have enough for to 6, top 3, it is that we are less than the sum of our parts rather than being devoid of actual quality.
I find it odd not concerned by Ferguson, really.
I think there has been a bit of a re write of history, but he was very important to how we played in the first half of the Bilic promotion season, you know the bit of the season where we were really good
On paper our squad sounds good, but when you do a deeper dive into their careers there has been a lot of football played at a level below championship promotion standard.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(10-21-2021, 12:30 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (10-21-2021, 12:17 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: (10-21-2021, 12:04 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: From the Bilic promotion season we have lost Pereria, Sawyers, Krovonovic, HRK, Austen, Ferguson and Edwards.
And replaced with Hugil, Reach, Mowatt, Clarke, Snodgrass, Grant and Molumby.
Think I would prefer the players in the first list than the second.
Sawyers/Krov for Molumby/Mowatt is pretty balanced.
Hugill for Austen - again much as a muchness but yes Austin scored (but we all have Grant & Robinson)
Edwards/Ferguson - not that concerned about
HRK - perfect for our system now
Pereira is the loss
However the point of my post is that 'there aren't many teams that would call themselves weak with Johnstone, Townsend, Clarke, Ajayi, Mowatt, Robinson, Grady, Phillips and Grant in their first XI - but the way we play negates their strengths because we don't have all the players needed to play this system.' Its a coaching, tactical point.
We have enough for to 6, top 3, it is that we are less than the sum of our parts rather than being devoid of actual quality.
I find it odd not concerned by Ferguson, really.
I think there has been a bit of a re write of history, but he was very important to how we played in the first half of the Bilic promotion season, you know the bit of the season where we were really good
On paper our squad sounds good, but when you do a deeper dive into their careers there has been a lot of football played at a level below championship promotion standard.
I like Ferguson and how he plays - but it'd also be rewriting history to say he'd be making an impact now as he got injured for us and is still out for Palace. I also think he started the majority of his games at left back, scored a tremendous goal v QPR from there, but would you play him before Townsend? If he switched to right back he'd probably get a game but not hugely different to Furlong (admittedly he looks in drastic form right now).
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
10-21-2021, 01:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-21-2021, 01:38 PM by Hopalong.)
(10-20-2021, 08:59 PM)Fido Wrote: (10-20-2021, 08:55 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Cannot believe by a long way our most effective wide player, Philips is played through the middle. Especially when Furlong is so off the pace and giving us absolutely nothing offensively on the right
Manager getting lots wrong
I agree. It's one thing he offers us, getting wide, taking players on and whipping the ball in. Grant doesn't do it down the left so we at least need one fuggin wing where we get a shot at it!
In fairness to Grant, think he has a couple of assists which have earned us wins?
(10-21-2021, 07:00 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (10-21-2021, 06:49 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Agree.
Without Val we’d be 16th IMO
I’m not even going to ask where you’ve pulled that gem from.
We have one of the top 3-4 squads In the league. It’s just not being managed well enough.
Unless I'm mistaken, we've been top/2nd all season til last night? So that argument doesn't hold water.
We are still very early into Val's tenure, there will be hiccups but we'll get better as the season progresses and necessary tweaks are made.
(10-21-2021, 07:43 AM)clem4england Wrote: (10-21-2021, 07:32 AM)Mickyfudge Wrote: In my opinion this is the worst squad we have had for years ,we have fallen so far behind teams like wolves and Leeds it’s criminal,a combination of poor signings and a lack of anyone bar o shay coming from the academy Yep - a poor, unbalanced squad with no striker and no creative midfielder. Appalling recruitment in Summer 2020 has led to this.
It really hit home when we played Blues for me. Two years ago only Bellingham would have got anywhere near our team and that was because he was a bit special. This time, I'd take Jutkiewicz, Sunjic, Chong, Bela. And the same applies most weeks - Swansea seem to be screwed financially and are letting all of their big earners go but Laird, Piroe, Paterson (on last night), Grimes would all walk into our team and Downes, Cabango, Bennett are no worse than what we start each week.
Clem, Swansea got to the PO final, they're a good side.
(10-21-2021, 07:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-21-2021, 07:32 AM)Mickyfudge Wrote: In my opinion this is the worst squad we have had for years ,we have fallen so far behind teams like wolves and Leeds it’s criminal,a combination of poor signings and a lack of anyone bar o shay coming from the academy
This.
Covid hit a very large nail into a coffin already being sealed.
We've been awful at recruitment ever since these owners came in, and not great before that once McDonut uninstall all of Ashworths stuff.
Only time any recruitment has been done well, is managers themselves doing it. Bilic with Pereira and Grady. Moore with Gayle, Barnes and Townsend. Arguably only summer signing that was what we needed was Mowatt, Vals signing.
A million miles away from what we used to be.
Mid table Champ guys, get used to it, I think it's here as of this season.
Think you're being overly-pessimistic Birdy.
Mowatt, Clarke and Molumby are very good signings at this level and Reach has done OK. Bryan yet to be given an opportunity and I still think Hugill will prove to be a decent signing if he gets some service!
The signings we've made have been made to fit Val's system so we need to see how it pans out over the season, still very early days. Incredulous that some are calling for him to go. We've had a couple of hiccups against good sides and have slipped to 3rd but things change quickly in this league. It's not as if we've lost to Peterborough.
There's no doubt our recruitment has gone tits up largely since Sly old Roy seduced Ashworth away with the odd exception like Pereira but he wanted out once the Saudis came in and I fail to see where he would have fitted into Val's 3-4-3. We more than doubled our money so not a disaster. Would gladly accept £24m for Grady! Maybe Newcastle will come in for him.
Posts: 10,526
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(10-21-2021, 11:41 AM)Squid Wrote: (10-21-2021, 10:11 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: The problem is I think we have become less than the sum of our parts, which is concerning and a coaching / pattern of play issue.
I see your point Birdie regarding what our style of play should be, but this team has shown it can retain the ball - under Bilic in the Champ is an example (while we have lost Pereira, Mowatt can be good in possession).
The squad lacks a proper forward for this system, I can't see how we can play this type of football and not have (dare I say it) a HRK, Long, MAF or similar. This system relies on have ball retention in the second phase and a lot of that comes from the number 9 being able to hold the ball or knock downs. That enables the wide forwards space and you retain possesion in the final third.
We have no one capable of that role - and therefore lose possession and look dreadful.
There aren't many teams that would call themselves weak with Johnstone, Townsend, Clarke, Ajayi, Mowatt, Robinson, Grady, Phillips and Grant in their first XI - but the way we play negates their strengths because we don't have all the players needed to play this system.
The ball retention of that season was largely due to the much-maligned Sawyers in addition to Pereira and when he played, Krovinovic, who was very good at getting the ball to Pereira.
Two of the three players you mention were not in Vals plans.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
10-21-2021, 01:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-21-2021, 01:44 PM by Hopalong.)
(10-21-2021, 08:21 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I still think we’re only one playing missing from a top starting XI
Johnstone
Furlong. Bartley. Clarke. Townsend
Livermore. Mowatt
Phillips. Robinson. Dinagana
And someone to hold the fucking ball up.
You could move Phillips central and put one of the others wide right or play Grant instead of Grady, O’Shea to come back etc but for me our strength is the tricky wide players coming from deep who aren’t natural forwards. Just someone to hold the ball up and bring them in to play and we signed fucking Hugil.
We signed Hugill because we needed someone to lead the line a No.9. Clearly Val gave up on Big Ken early on and Dike wasn't available.
(10-21-2021, 09:41 AM)Peachy Wrote: (10-21-2021, 09:06 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-21-2021, 09:01 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (10-21-2021, 08:12 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think I've said before, I am not a fan of 4-4-2 unless you have a decent target man up top and a do it all midfielder.
I'd like to see us push the wing backs back a bit, push a defender further forward and have a DM, move the two wider strikers to wide players, and see if that gets us playing more.
Yup, we absolutely do not have the central midfield for a 442… quite why we are persevering with a 343 baffles me similarly.
Our strikers arent very good, and so need better service from open play. They won’t get that from Livermore, Mowatt is too busy doing Jakes running to always deliver a quality final ball, and Furlong is better with his hands than his feet… that means our only progressive ball of quality comes throughTownsend, but opposition managers are shutting off his supply route and it leaves us without a lot of creativity.
If Grady isn’t fit, I’d line up against Bristol with;
…………Grant .Robinson
………………….Snodgrass
Townsend Mowatt Molumby Phillips
………..Clark Bartley Ajayi
..………………Johnstone
Button, Kipre, Bryan, Reach, Hugill, Garner-Hickman and probably Castro?
Not against that at all.
Snodgrass should have had more chances imo. He's capable of passing the ball, he's experienced, a leader amd more technical than people realise.
I'm not against it either but I know one man that will be. And he's our manager.
As long as I have a hole in my arse he won't change our formation or approach. Not a chance.
Why should he change his approach/principles? He's what it says on the tin. Does Pep change his principles when they have a defeat and they've had some pretty critical defeats in finals!
Posts: 10,862
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
10-21-2021, 01:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-21-2021, 01:49 PM by Peachy.)
(10-21-2021, 01:41 PM)Hopalong Wrote: (10-21-2021, 08:21 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I still think we’re only one playing missing from a top starting XI
Johnstone
Furlong. Bartley. Clarke. Townsend
Livermore. Mowatt
Phillips. Robinson. Dinagana
And someone to hold the fucking ball up.
You could move Phillips central and put one of the others wide right or play Grant instead of Grady, O’Shea to come back etc but for me our strength is the tricky wide players coming from deep who aren’t natural forwards. Just someone to hold the ball up and bring them in to play and we signed fucking Hugil.
We signed Hugill because we needed someone to lead the line a No.9. Clearly Val gave up on Big Ken early on and Dike wasn't available.
Having seen Hugils contributions so far I think we might need to bring Big Ken in from the cold.......
Its so annoying his work rate and desire doesn't match his physical attributes as he's just what we need in that respect. Val said pre Cardiff game
“He has been injured in the last few weeks,” Ismael explained. “He is a West Brom player so it doesn’t change anything with our thoughts on Ken.
“He was injured so for a few weeks he was out. He needs to get back his fitness now and he needs to get the confidence of having his fitness back, but when Ken is 100 per cent fit we know we have another possibility in our front three with him.”
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(10-21-2021, 10:11 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: The problem is I think we have become less than the sum of our parts, which is concerning and a coaching / pattern of play issue.
I see your point Birdie regarding what our style of play should be, but this team has shown it can retain the ball - under Bilic in the Champ is an example (while we have lost Pereira, Mowatt can be good in possession).
The squad lacks a proper forward for this system, I can't see how we can play this type of football and not have (dare I say it) a HRK, Long, MAF or similar. This system relies on have ball retention in the second phase and a lot of that comes from the number 9 being able to hold the ball or knock downs. That enables the wide forwards space and you retain possesion in the final third.
We have no one capable of that role - and therefore lose possession and look dreadful.
There aren't many teams that would call themselves weak with Johnstone, Townsend, Clarke, Ajayi, Mowatt, Robinson, Grady, Phillips and Grant in their first XI - but the way we play negates their strengths because we don't have all the players needed to play this system.
It took Man City and Liverpool - with hundreds of millions - four/five years to build a side to challenge for the title but you expect Val to do it in one window?
So if my analysis is correct, we need a replacement for Furlong and Livermore and we'll be the finished article? Or is it Bartley too? What about a centre-forward?
Let's see what happens in Jan and who comes in. We are where we are at the moment.
|