Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(07-18-2021, 10:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (07-18-2021, 09:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh indeed, 35 million at least should be the rate we go for.
However, as a club, what do we do if towards the end of the window he demands to leave, to the point of sulking, not doing what the manager says but the best offer is 25 million.....
Not our fault if nobody meets the valuation, he will have to get on with it. And by all accounts he has been. You just know we’re going to get this horribly wrong though, we’ve practically publicly declared we want to sell him to fund signings. Even if that is the plan, we should be shouting from the rooftops that he’s going nowhere unless a silly offer comes in. I’ve seen some suggest we loan him out ffs. To fund signings that are almost certainly going to be inferior players. Insane
Yeah that loaning idea was the dumbest thing I've read.
What if he doesn't 'get on with it' once the window closes?
This is the issue, and I'm sure the club have had this conversation with him and his agent, we will never know what was said in those discussions.
Remember Saido? I'd hope Pereira is better than that, and I imagine he is.
This is the conundrum the club will have, and they have more of the facts than us.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
It's disgusting the board are trotting out the "sell to buy" mantra through the media via back door press leaks and it seems as Albion fans it's being accepted
We do not have to sell to buy, we have money to spend on transfers, not a great deal, but some. I raised concerns when Clarke was only a loan deal, with no option to buy, we were categorically trying to buy the player but then somehow couldn't afford £5m
I tried to cut Ken some slack when he put his eggs in the Val basket, £2m compo, although we tried to batter Barnsley down over that which proved a waste of time, yet from a competitive budget to the pot is empty is just taking the piss
When have we ever been relegated from the Prem and needed to "sell to buy?" Never! Even through the pandemic and lost revenue we don't need to know either and we frankly shouldn't stomach it
Look at the released list of players too, HRK on his wages for example, could make a case for him still offering something at chump level but we let him go, for what? To then not be in a position to reinvest that saving? Yes we are in a fortunate position to pay slightly better salaries than most in this division but now we should be looking to kick on and give Val a squad which has a chance to get back promoted and on Friday night we had Matty Phillips playing as a number 9 FFS!
Squad clearly needs work, we sent a terrible message out re Pereira and SJ when we basically hung a "For Sale" sign around their neck at Val's first presser, what's wrong with the Naarge approach? Difference is they have owners who try to do right by the club, we have people teling lies from the top down and taking the fans for a ride so it seems
I fear if we don't get back up in the next 2 years we're on a very slippery slope, given that in mind the current actions from the board and how we're approaching things beggars belief
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(07-19-2021, 07:56 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-18-2021, 10:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (07-18-2021, 09:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh indeed, 35 million at least should be the rate we go for.
However, as a club, what do we do if towards the end of the window he demands to leave, to the point of sulking, not doing what the manager says but the best offer is 25 million.....
Not our fault if nobody meets the valuation, he will have to get on with it. And by all accounts he has been. You just know we’re going to get this horribly wrong though, we’ve practically publicly declared we want to sell him to fund signings. Even if that is the plan, we should be shouting from the rooftops that he’s going nowhere unless a silly offer comes in. I’ve seen some suggest we loan him out ffs. To fund signings that are almost certainly going to be inferior players. Insane
Yeah that loaning idea was the dumbest thing I've read.
What if he doesn't 'get on with it' once the window closes?
This is the issue, and I'm sure the club have had this conversation with him and his agent, we will never know what was said in those discussions.
Remember Saido? I'd hope Pereira is better than that, and I imagine he is.
This is the conundrum the club will have, and they have more of the facts than us.
I guess the main difference is Spurs were the side interested in Saido which was head turning for him. So far, to our knowledge at least nobody of note wants Pereira. Everyone now knows our position and that they’ll likely get a bargain at the end of the window. Act like a small club and you’ll get treated like one
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
The Spurs thing wasn’t even our fault, Levy tried to take the piss on the fee and how it was paid. Had he just stumped up the agreed asking price Saido would have gone and everyone would have been happy (except Spurs about six months later).
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
07-19-2021, 09:30 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-19-2021, 09:37 AM by Shabby Russian.)
(07-18-2021, 09:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh indeed, 35 million at least should be the rate we go for.
However, as a club, what do we do if towards the end of the window he demands to leave, to the point of sulking, not doing what the manager says but the best offer is 25 million.....
The unemotional correct response would be to sell him. That would represent a good profit and as long as the money is put back into the club everyone is a winner.
We need to show to younger players with potential, that coming to our club would be a good move for their career. Playing hardball when it is their time to move on isn't the way to do it.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(07-19-2021, 08:51 AM)Cuzer Wrote: It's disgusting the board are trotting out the "sell to buy" mantra through the media via back door press leaks and it seems as Albion fans it's being accepted
We do not have to sell to buy, we have money to spend on transfers, not a great deal, but some. I raised concerns when Clarke was only a loan deal, with no option to buy, we were categorically trying to buy the player but then somehow couldn't afford £5m
I tried to cut Ken some slack when he put his eggs in the Val basket, £2m compo, although we tried to batter Barnsley down over that which proved a waste of time, yet from a competitive budget to the pot is empty is just taking the piss
When have we ever been relegated from the Prem and needed to "sell to buy?" Never! Even through the pandemic and lost revenue we don't need to know either and we frankly shouldn't stomach it
Look at the released list of players too, HRK on his wages for example, could make a case for him still offering something at chump level but we let him go, for what? To then not be in a position to reinvest that saving? Yes we are in a fortunate position to pay slightly better salaries than most in this division but now we should be looking to kick on and give Val a squad which has a chance to get back promoted and on Friday night we had Matty Phillips playing as a number 9 FFS!
Squad clearly needs work, we sent a terrible message out re Pereira and SJ when we basically hung a "For Sale" sign around their neck at Val's first presser, what's wrong with the Naarge approach? Difference is they have owners who try to do right by the club, we have people teling lies from the top down and taking the fans for a ride so it seems
I fear if we don't get back up in the next 2 years we're on a very slippery slope, given that in mind the current actions from the board and how we're approaching things beggars belief
Cuzer
Fulham and Sheff Utd making the same noise too.
I think there is money for transfers tbh, but we don't want us knowing that right now, but it will be less than previous relegations.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(07-19-2021, 09:30 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (07-18-2021, 09:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh indeed, 35 million at least should be the rate we go for.
However, as a club, what do we do if towards the end of the window he demands to leave, to the point of sulking, not doing what the manager says but the best offer is 25 million.....
The unemotional correct response would be to sell him. That would represent a good profit and as long as the money is put back into the club everyone is a winner.
We need to show to younger players with potential, that coming to our club would be a good move for their career. Playing hardball when it is their time to move on isn't the way to do it.
That's the key thing. Do you have faith in Lai doing this?
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(07-19-2021, 09:36 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-19-2021, 08:51 AM)Cuzer Wrote: It's disgusting the board are trotting out the "sell to buy" mantra through the media via back door press leaks and it seems as Albion fans it's being accepted
We do not have to sell to buy, we have money to spend on transfers, not a great deal, but some. I raised concerns when Clarke was only a loan deal, with no option to buy, we were categorically trying to buy the player but then somehow couldn't afford £5m
I tried to cut Ken some slack when he put his eggs in the Val basket, £2m compo, although we tried to batter Barnsley down over that which proved a waste of time, yet from a competitive budget to the pot is empty is just taking the piss
When have we ever been relegated from the Prem and needed to "sell to buy?" Never! Even through the pandemic and lost revenue we don't need to know either and we frankly shouldn't stomach it
Look at the released list of players too, HRK on his wages for example, could make a case for him still offering something at chump level but we let him go, for what? To then not be in a position to reinvest that saving? Yes we are in a fortunate position to pay slightly better salaries than most in this division but now we should be looking to kick on and give Val a squad which has a chance to get back promoted and on Friday night we had Matty Phillips playing as a number 9 FFS!
Squad clearly needs work, we sent a terrible message out re Pereira and SJ when we basically hung a "For Sale" sign around their neck at Val's first presser, what's wrong with the Naarge approach? Difference is they have owners who try to do right by the club, we have people teling lies from the top down and taking the fans for a ride so it seems
I fear if we don't get back up in the next 2 years we're on a very slippery slope, given that in mind the current actions from the board and how we're approaching things beggars belief
Cuzer
Fulham and Sheff Utd making the same noise too.
I think there is money for transfers tbh, but we don't want us knowing that right now, but it will be less than previous relegations.
Maybe we'd be better off telling everybody we've got £40 million to spend, and then try to negotiate cheaper transfer fees.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Just over 2 weeks and we kick off.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
07-19-2021, 10:37 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-19-2021, 10:40 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(07-19-2021, 09:36 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-19-2021, 08:51 AM)Cuzer Wrote: It's disgusting the board are trotting out the "sell to buy" mantra through the media via back door press leaks and it seems as Albion fans it's being accepted
We do not have to sell to buy, we have money to spend on transfers, not a great deal, but some. I raised concerns when Clarke was only a loan deal, with no option to buy, we were categorically trying to buy the player but then somehow couldn't afford £5m
I tried to cut Ken some slack when he put his eggs in the Val basket, £2m compo, although we tried to batter Barnsley down over that which proved a waste of time, yet from a competitive budget to the pot is empty is just taking the piss
When have we ever been relegated from the Prem and needed to "sell to buy?" Never! Even through the pandemic and lost revenue we don't need to know either and we frankly shouldn't stomach it
Look at the released list of players too, HRK on his wages for example, could make a case for him still offering something at chump level but we let him go, for what? To then not be in a position to reinvest that saving? Yes we are in a fortunate position to pay slightly better salaries than most in this division but now we should be looking to kick on and give Val a squad which has a chance to get back promoted and on Friday night we had Matty Phillips playing as a number 9 FFS!
Squad clearly needs work, we sent a terrible message out re Pereira and SJ when we basically hung a "For Sale" sign around their neck at Val's first presser, what's wrong with the Naarge approach? Difference is they have owners who try to do right by the club, we have people teling lies from the top down and taking the fans for a ride so it seems
I fear if we don't get back up in the next 2 years we're on a very slippery slope, given that in mind the current actions from the board and how we're approaching things beggars belief
Cuzer
Fulham and Sheff Utd making the same noise too.
I think there is money for transfers tbh, but we don't want us knowing that right now, but it will be less than previous relegations.
The reduced income last season alongside the 2 year instead of 3 year parachute payment has made it more difficult for the relegated clubs than previously in terms of funding rebuilds. Comparatively our budget remains as strong relative to the rest of the division as it ever has done, but there’s less room for long term transfer commitments - especially given how risk adverse we as a club are.
As Cuzer says, since last season we have taken Maitland-Niles, Gallagher, Diagne, Austin, Ivanovic, Gibbs, Grosicki, Yokuslu, HRK and Hegazi’s substantial wages off the wage bill, alongside releasing Peltier, Edwards, Lonergan and we have further sold Field and Harper. Add that to the fact the remaining players have seen their wages cut by up to 50% and it is hard to believe our budget is even remotely stretched.
We have some legacy transfer payments from last season to cover, but taking into account the last 3 seasons’ transfers we are still in a net profit from sales to buys - or break even at best - not including the Ferguson tribunal fee, so it’s not like we can claim all our money is going on Grant still!
I don’t expect us to splash stupid amounts of cash around, and with so many league clubs being financially stretched there will be bargains to be had negating the need to, but I can’t accept there isn’t money in the budget to get 2-3 decent Championship additions in without having to undersell Pereira to the first bidder.
You have to remember too, Sheff United have the best part of £120m of transfer fees from the last 2 seasons to amortise with zero raised in sales!
|