He’s on his way, he’s on his way. How did we entice him? I don’t know.
#41
Field, Gallagher, Sawyers, Livermore, Harper, Krov and Peltier as absolute emergency...

Plenty of flex and a couple players for either role... it’s not as strong as we need but it’ll do.

2 strikers need to arrive sharpish, but sadly I can’t see there being more than 1
Reply
#42
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

Yep, I would have classified Lukaku as a high risk and not a good loan. Obviously that was not the case and he proved his worth. But a Lukaku is a one in a blue moon I think and I wouldn't be putting my house on a 20 year old in such a key position needed to retain PL status

(09-17-2020, 04:25 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

I've no objection to Begley being on here, as he is one of the more articulate Villa posters to have found his way to the bored, and his contributions are for the most part well informed, but I wish he would at least acknowledge the fact that he's not Albion when he joins in. 

It'd be more relevant asking him about Tammy Abraham than Romelu Lulaku in this discussion, for instance.

I have never denied I was a Villa supporter and have been very open about it. I just like football and like discussing it, I find it very interesting to get the opinion of other fans. I have posted on here a bit but I have stopped opening with I am a Villa supporter as I very often got dogs abuse. I am not interested in giving or receiving abuse. We are all just people who support our football teams and we are local rivals. The abuse Baggies fans, Blues fans and Villa fans give each other is at times fairly disgusting and that is just not my thing. If you have read my posts, I actually wished Baggies luck last season and said I hoped u get promoted. Nearly all mentions of Villa on here are hoping our players get serious injury and everything about the club fails. I think it is great having a couple of derby games with you guys this season and I would like us both to stay up and I would like Blues to join us in the PL
Reply
#43
(09-18-2020, 12:00 AM)Begley Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

Yep, I would have classified Lukaku as a high risk and not a good loan. Obviously that was not the case and he proved his worth. But a Lukaku is a one in a blue moon I think and I wouldn't be putting my house on a 20 year old in such a key position needed to retain PL status

(09-17-2020, 04:25 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

I've no objection to Begley being on here, as he is one of the more articulate Villa posters to have found his way to the bored, and his contributions are for the most part well informed, but I wish he would at least acknowledge the fact that he's not Albion when he joins in. 

It'd be more relevant asking him about Tammy Abraham than Romelu Lulaku in this discussion, for instance.

I have never denied I was a Villa supporter and have been very open about it. I just like football and like discussing it, I find it very interesting to get the opinion of other fans. I have posted on here a bit but I have stopped opening with I am a Villa supporter as I very often got dogs abuse. I am not interested in giving or receiving abuse. We are all just people who support our football teams and we are local rivals. The abuse Baggies fans, Blues fans and Villa fans give each other is at times fairly disgusting and that is just not my thing. If you have read my posts, I actually wished Baggies luck last season and said I hoped u get promoted. Nearly all mentions of Villa on here are hoping our players get serious injury and everything about the club fails. I think it is great having a couple of derby games with you guys this season and I would like us both to stay up and I would like Blues to join us in the PL
Well said that man!
DK is popular on here, even though a lot appear not to be keen on Stoke, so maybe you've got a chance... but I wouldn't be too optimistic...
The anti Villa stuff does often go too far, but IMO that's cos it's social media and people don't feel constrained etc. Add in the usual macho posturing and you get a board like this.
Or indeed H and V!
Reply
#44
More the merrier.  Adds a different perspective to the discussions, just like the old rivals days.

Begley, who do you hate more, Wolves or Vil...... oh Big Grin
Reply
#45
(09-18-2020, 12:00 AM)Begley Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

Yep, I would have classified Lukaku as a high risk and not a good loan. Obviously that was not the case and he proved his worth. But a Lukaku is a one in a blue moon I think and I wouldn't be putting my house on a 20 year old in such a key position needed to retain PL status

(09-17-2020, 04:25 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

I've no objection to Begley being on here, as he is one of the more articulate Villa posters to have found his way to the bored, and his contributions are for the most part well informed, but I wish he would at least acknowledge the fact that he's not Albion when he joins in. 

It'd be more relevant asking him about Tammy Abraham than Romelu Lulaku in this discussion, for instance.

I have never denied I was a Villa supporter and have been very open about it. I just like football and like discussing it, I find it very interesting to get the opinion of other fans. I have posted on here a bit but I have stopped opening with I am a Villa supporter as I very often got dogs abuse. I am not interested in giving or receiving abuse. We are all just people who support our football teams and we are local rivals. The abuse Baggies fans, Blues fans and Villa fans give each other is at times fairly disgusting and that is just not my thing. If you have read my posts, I actually wished Baggies luck last season and said I hoped u get promoted. Nearly all mentions of Villa on here are hoping our players get serious injury and everything about the club fails. I think it is great having a couple of derby games with you guys this season and I would like us both to stay up and I would like Blues to join us in the PL

Like those comments Begley, completely with you. 
Going back to the “finished article “ point though, you also have to consider the loan fee and wages required for an established player. I seem to recall Stoke paying 8m to loan Zouma from Chelsea, and think of the wages we paid to Sturridge and Krykowiak. We just can’t afford anyone other than an untried prospect.
Reply
#46
(09-17-2020, 03:00 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 02:52 PM)Begley Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 02:04 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 01:58 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 01:51 PM)Peachy Wrote: He was at Charlton first half of the season where he was excellent. Then Chelsea sent him to Swansea second half of the season where he was the driving force to them nicking the last play off place. 

He's a proper box to box number 8 who loves a tackle, will create and score goals and has a huge engine. 

He's one hell of a prospect hence Chelsea keeping him signed up.
I'm also a bit underwhelmed by signing a player not good enough for another team in our league.
Hope he improves us.

Last time I looked at the table the following teams who also wanted Gallagher are in the same league

Villa
Newcastle
Crystal Palace
Leeds

We’ve done well to secure his services (assuming it goes through)

I think you may find that some of those clubs were only interested in Gallagher if he was available on a permanent transfer. He is a great player, lots of potential but takes away from giving home grown players a chance. Chelsea will no doubt do the same as Liverpool and insist on 1st team performances too. It also restricts the ability to buy a player now, improve him and sell him in 12 months time. If Gallagher can deliver what is needed in his very first season of top flight football then it could be worth it but imo getting a loan of an inexperienced 20 year old can only really benefit the parent club

I get what you're saying but do we give home grown players the chance if they're not as good as someone we can get in on loan? Do we play the home grown players even if we think it will make us more likely to go down? It might benefit us long term but it's all about trying to stay up this year.

We have no home grown player anywhere near Gallagher.  Harper could have been but seems to be going backwards.  Another player like Leko who will probably never fulfill his early potential.

(09-17-2020, 04:08 PM)HUGHIE REED31 Wrote: We are putting all our faith and hopes on a 20 year old lad
who i'm not sure has played in the PL

I thought our academy was one of the best in the country
have we not got a 20 year lad already who we could give a go???

No, I don't think we have Hughie. 

And I don't believe we're putting all our faith in a 20 yr old,  but we have no similar player at the club so I would have thought he'll get in the side, where and to replace who I'm not sure.

(09-17-2020, 05:00 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Top player, a real 100% man but with some quality to boot, will score and create as well as put a foot in

Risky we are putting so much faith in a 20 year old but Slav has said he still wants Krov and with Field getting a chance as the "sitter" in the squad if we do get Krov I'd say we're done in midfield, plenty of options wide and at the back - just need to find that goal scorer now

Cuzer

Where has it been said we're putting so much faith in him ( I must have missed it)?  I would think there are far greater expectations on the likes of Pereira and Diangana but Gallagher looks to be a promising player. 

Can I ask Cuzer whose places are Field,  Krov - if we get him and Gallagher taking in the side?  Are you suggesting Livermore's and Sawyers and A N Other?
Reply
#47
(09-18-2020, 06:51 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: More the merrier.  Adds a different perspective to the discussions, just like the old rivals days.

Begley, who do you hate more, Wolves or Vil...... oh Big Grin

Blues obviously  Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#48
(09-18-2020, 09:57 AM)Begley Wrote:
(09-18-2020, 06:51 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: More the merrier.  Adds a different perspective to the discussions, just like the old rivals days.

Begley, who do you hate more, Wolves or Vil...... oh Big Grin

Blues obviously  Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin

Dear Beg, I would hope most Baggies fans would realise the difference between banter and abuse and it's a shame you've had to endure some of the former. 

You're welcome … you can't help being what you are.  Big Grin
Reply
#49
(09-18-2020, 07:17 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(09-18-2020, 12:00 AM)Begley Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

Yep, I would have classified Lukaku as a high risk and not a good loan. Obviously that was not the case and he proved his worth. But a Lukaku is a one in a blue moon I think and I wouldn't be putting my house on a 20 year old in such a key position needed to retain PL status

(09-17-2020, 04:25 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 03:57 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

I've no objection to Begley being on here, as he is one of the more articulate Villa posters to have found his way to the bored, and his contributions are for the most part well informed, but I wish he would at least acknowledge the fact that he's not Albion when he joins in. 

It'd be more relevant asking him about Tammy Abraham than Romelu Lulaku in this discussion, for instance.

I have never denied I was a Villa supporter and have been very open about it. I just like football and like discussing it, I find it very interesting to get the opinion of other fans. I have posted on here a bit but I have stopped opening with I am a Villa supporter as I very often got dogs abuse. I am not interested in giving or receiving abuse. We are all just people who support our football teams and we are local rivals. The abuse Baggies fans, Blues fans and Villa fans give each other is at times fairly disgusting and that is just not my thing. If you have read my posts, I actually wished Baggies luck last season and said I hoped u get promoted. Nearly all mentions of Villa on here are hoping our players get serious injury and everything about the club fails. I think it is great having a couple of derby games with you guys this season and I would like us both to stay up and I would like Blues to join us in the PL

Like those comments Begley, completely with you. 
Going back to the “finished article “ point though, you also have to consider the loan fee and wages required for an established player. I seem to recall Stoke paying 8m to loan Zouma from Chelsea, and think of the wages we paid to Sturridge and Krykowiak. We just can’t afford anyone other than an untried prospect.

First of all thank you!

Re the finished article, it is really tough to get that right and it is high risk. However, I think it gives clubs that have just been promoted their best chance of survival in the PL. The prime example is Henderson at Blades. I am confident that they would have been in a relegation battle without him. I think the loan signing of this window is without question Batshuayi. He will score goals this season. Personally, I think Batshuayi would have been perfect for Baggies or Villa as we are both desperate for a goal scorer. Watkins looks a good player but he has not played in the PL so a big risk. 
I think WBA finds itself in a position a bit like Villa did a year ago. Too many bloody loan players were required to achieve promotion and then transfer budget needs to be spent making these permanent. Although you have done some excellent business in the window it is not improving your team and you need improvement for the PL. The objective must be survival this season and I think getting a top goal scorer is an absolute necessity for WBA, otherwise I fear the worst next May. I don't believe that any of the names linked are the ones to do it hence I said I think u need to go all out for a top class loan for 12 months. Even if this cost 10m+ I think it is worth it. 
Regarding the rumours on Samatta, I doubt many Baggies have actually seen him play. Personally, I hope we keep him. He positions himself well, great header of the ball and will work his socks off. Villa bought him at the end of Jan, he played a few games and then C-19, then was used as a sub a lot. He can't be judged on his time with Villa, particularly considering the fact that the Villa team was very weak, in a relegation fight and had El Ghazi and Trez that could not provide any service to Samatta. WBA has the wide men that could actually provide him with the service he needs.  Maybe look at his Champions League performances for Genk and his game against Liverpool last year where he scored at Anfield in the Champions League or the Carabao final where he scored against Man City. If u can get him to partner with a proven goalscorer then I think u may just have the firepower you need. But hopefully we will keep him and he can develop into a good striker for us  Wink

(09-18-2020, 10:11 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(09-18-2020, 09:57 AM)Begley Wrote:
(09-18-2020, 06:51 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: More the merrier.  Adds a different perspective to the discussions, just like the old rivals days.

Begley, who do you hate more, Wolves or Vil...... oh Big Grin

Blues obviously  Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin

Dear Beg, I would hope most Baggies fans would realise the difference between banter and abuse and it's a shame you've had to endure some of the former. 

You're welcome … you can't help being what you are.  Big Grin
Thank you. I see a forum like going to the pub with my mates to discuss football. It would be seriously boring if we all supported the same team. It is good to have some ribbing and also to get a different perspective on signings and performances  Big Grin
Reply
#50
Dear Beg

Perhaps you should start your posts with 'VFIP' just so we know!

Interesting take on Samatta. Have to admit i wasnt impressed with us being linked. However having read your take on him i've mellowed somewhat. But it does beg the question if he's good enough why would you consider sending him to us?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: