Boris says go back to work
#41
(05-11-2020, 02:15 PM)Sliced Wrote: If the message is 'basically, the onus is on you, the people, to take some responsibility for yourselves', which I don't necessarily disagree with, why then did he also say that fines were going to be stricter for those who break the rules?

It's a bit like the "taking the piss test". No one's ever been pulled over by the coppers for doing 78mph on a motorway. Do 85 and you've had it.

(05-11-2020, 02:04 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: So you don't want any laws then?

Rolleyes
Reply
#42
(05-11-2020, 02:44 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-11-2020, 02:15 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-11-2020, 12:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-11-2020, 12:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Apologist alert

Nope, not at all. I happen to think Lockdown has been overdone and will cause far more issues for lives than it will solve.

I disagree with Boris completely, but the prevailing narrative seems pretty straightforward; Take some responsibility for your own actions and don't be a twat.

When you try to order human life by design, down to the level at which one might picnic, you invariably end up in mess.

An authentically conservative approach would be to explain the risks and objectives clearly, and let us take responsibility given our circumstances.


It's not straightforward at all. If the message is 'basically, the onus is on you, the people, to take some responsibility for yourselves', which I don't necessarily disagree with, why then did he also say that fines were going to be stricter for those who break the rules? The rules are no longer clearly defined. Also there's no consistency in his message. If I can't do X then how come I'm allowed to do Y when the impact is the same etc.

I hope for some clarification on the details of this today, but I don't expect any

This is a valid criticism. I do think the govt are on a very sticky wicket in the worst of all worlds: a hugely polarising issue about about which very little is ultimately known. As an example, CPAP being a better form of treatment than ventilation is something that has only been ascertained in the past few weeks.

I also think that outside of social media, the average citizen generally realises the govt have limited options.

But to move towards relaxing lockdown, while also increasing fines is odd.

While Proth is advocating relaxing lockdown from a conservative angle, there is a social democrat argument for it too, as lockdown is having a disproportionate impact on the poor, particularly those with mental health conditions. People not accessing healthcare is also a problem.

Some people are having a very pleasant lockdown indeed and it's uncomfortable watching them decry people who live in tower blocks for daring to visit their local park.

Spot on. Its the poor who will suffer healthwise, jobwise the longer lockdown goes on.

Too many people are labelling the whole thing "money vs deaths", which is ridiculous.

Its more like "corona deaths vs deaths/jobs/health from the impact of lockdown", if we have to label it in a few words (which of course we can't anyway).

In addition, we're also in a situation whereby the total number of coronavirus deaths is being looked at in isolation, due to the over simplification in the mainstream media. This isn't how respiratory viral infections work. They exacerbate other health issues in the majority of cases. As such, the death rate amongst healthy under 45s is very small. And I mean tiny. We're into road traffic accident type of percentages for the chance of dying if you're a healthy under 45. Even under 65 the figures are low. For example... Older people often have internal organs that only work at, say, 70% efficiency of a young person. That's what age does to us. This is fine for older people to still live and their bodies function under normal circumstances. Reduce the supply of oxygen by a further 20% though (as in when corona gets hold of the lungs), and then the organs are in massive trouble (why many are dying of corona induced kidney failure). A healthy under 45 however can take that 20% reduction in oxygen, feel like shit for a couple of weeks, then the body gets over it. This is only one example, but its the same for an older person's cardiovascular system (their arteries are a bit thinner etc), which all means that the death rate in older people is enormously higher. I firmly believe the mainstream media should be educating the public on this, explaining how respiratory viral infections such as covid kill people, what co-morbidity is, the difference in risk by age etc. This is essential to make balanced informed decisions, but unfortunately we are just bombarded with the total number of deaths every day "with" coronavirus, and little further detail in the MSM.

This is why my personal opinion is that moving forward, the plan should be centred around healthy working people getting back to work to limit the socio economic damage which will affect the poor disproportionately, while the over 65s and vulnerable should be shielded as much as physically possible. I realise the practicalities are difficult and far more complicated, and I certainly don't have the answer to how this should precisely work, but I believe this should be the basis of a plan going forward.

Unfortunately, as with many things these days, there's far too many people simply shut the debate down and label it as "deaths vs money".

I would urge everyone to research these things I've mentioned, and far more, in order to get a balanced view of this disease, how it works, co-morbidity, the risk to age groups etc. This is essential to make informed decisions on how we move forward.
Reply
#43
The statements made by the govt aren't confusing in themselves. The problem is i doubt the majority of the population agree with this approach. England the 2nd most densely populated country in the world in countries over 50 million people with a bad covid-19 issue - why ease the lockdown now? Just watch the infection spike come next Monday.
Reply
#44
(05-11-2020, 03:08 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Spot on. Its the poor who will suffer healthwise, jobwise the longer lockdown goes on.

Too many people are labelling the whole thing "money vs deaths", which is ridiculous.

Its more like "corona deaths vs deaths/jobs/health from the impact of lockdown", if we have to label it in a few words (which of course we can't anyway).

In addition, we're also in a situation whereby the total number of coronavirus deaths is being looked at in isolation, due to the over simplification in the mainstream media. This isn't how respiratory viral infections work. They exacerbate other health issues in the majority of cases. As such, the death rate amongst healthy under 45s is very small. And I mean tiny. We're into road traffic accident type of percentages for the chance of dying if you're a healthy under 45. Even under 65 the figures are low. For example... Older people often have internal organs that only work at, say, 70% efficiency of a young person. That's what age does to us. This is fine for older people to still live and their bodies function under normal circumstances. Reduce the supply of oxygen by a further 20% though (as in when corona gets hold of the lungs), and then the organs are in massive trouble (why many are dying of corona induced kidney failure). A healthy under 45 however can take that 20% reduction in oxygen, feel like shit for a couple of weeks, then the body gets over it. This is only one example, but its the same for an older person's cardiovascular system (their arteries are a bit thinner etc), which all means that the death rate in older people is enormously higher. I firmly believe the mainstream media should be educating the public on this, explaining how respiratory viral infections such as covid kill people, what co-morbidity is, the difference in risk by age etc. This is essential to make balanced informed decisions, but unfortunately we are just bombarded with the total number of deaths every day "with" coronavirus, and little further detail in the MSM.

This is why my personal opinion is that moving forward, the plan should be centred around healthy working people getting back to work to limit the socio economic damage which will affect the poor disproportionately, while the over 65s and vulnerable should be shielded as much as physically possible. I realise the practicalities are difficult and far more complicated, and I certainly don't have the answer to how this should precisely work, but I believe this should be the basis of a plan going forward.

Unfortunately, as with many things these days, there's far too many people simply shut the debate down and label it as "deaths vs money".

I would urge everyone to research these things I've mentioned, and far more, in order to get a balanced view of this disease, how it works, co-morbidity, the risk to age groups etc. This is essential to make informed decisions on how we move forward.

I don't think this is deaths vs money at all but even with research it doesn't mean the understanding of the disease is at a stage where we, as a nation, can effectively be making guesses as to what to do next, which is what happened yesterday.

You say do the research and I have looked at the figures, not thorough research obviously, but I didn't stop at the under 45s (a strange number to stop at as we have a working age in the uk of nearly 70 these days btw). But let's use your figures and then add some.

Deaths in under 45s up to week 17 in 2019 was 6,068 compared to 6,279 in 2020 - like you say, no real worry there.
Deaths in under 65s for the same periods was 28,210 vs 32,052 - nearly an extra 4k deaths, again not massive until you look in a bit more detail and realise that virtually all of those 4k came in the 4 weeks to week 17, that's a thousand extra people of working age dying every week year on year. Is that an acceptable figure?
And then look at the deaths as a whole for the year to week 17 and then you have 229,300 against 185,519, that's an extra 44,000 people that have died up until 24th April including 40,000 in the last 4 weeks of that period - that's 10,000 extra deaths a week. And apart from the fact that these are all old and will die anyway at some point, Is that figure acceptable to you?

The government fucked up the start of this unbelievably badly and because of that we should be locking down for longer until we have it under control, but instead of accepting they fucked up and apologising for the extra pain that they will cause by locking down for longer they have decided to release the lockdown. And this is at a point where there rolling average death figure is higher than when the initial decision to lock down was made - what has changed?

(05-11-2020, 03:50 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: The statements made by the govt aren't confusing in themselves. The problem is i doubt the majority of the population agree with this approach. England the 2nd most densely populated country in the world in countries over 50 million people with a bad covid-19 issue - why ease the lockdown now? Just watch the infection spike come next Monday.

Exactly FB - I would be saying that it will come in a couple of weeks due to incubation periods etc but it will come and then there will be the delay in cases spread whilst not on lockdown. 

So in the meantime, all the businesses that have to restart their order looks will be asked to close down again and watch the pipeline dry up.

Fuck it, it's only the old ones that are at risk though.
Reply
#45
(05-11-2020, 04:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-11-2020, 03:08 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Spot on. Its the poor who will suffer healthwise, jobwise the longer lockdown goes on.

Too many people are labelling the whole thing "money vs deaths", which is ridiculous.

Its more like "corona deaths vs deaths/jobs/health from the impact of lockdown", if we have to label it in a few words (which of course we can't anyway).

In addition, we're also in a situation whereby the total number of coronavirus deaths is being looked at in isolation, due to the over simplification in the mainstream media. This isn't how respiratory viral infections work. They exacerbate other health issues in the majority of cases. As such, the death rate amongst healthy under 45s is very small. And I mean tiny. We're into road traffic accident type of percentages for the chance of dying if you're a healthy under 45. Even under 65 the figures are low. For example... Older people often have internal organs that only work at, say, 70% efficiency of a young person. That's what age does to us. This is fine for older people to still live and their bodies function under normal circumstances. Reduce the supply of oxygen by a further 20% though (as in when corona gets hold of the lungs), and then the organs are in massive trouble (why many are dying of corona induced kidney failure). A healthy under 45 however can take that 20% reduction in oxygen, feel like shit for a couple of weeks, then the body gets over it. This is only one example, but its the same for an older person's cardiovascular system (their arteries are a bit thinner etc), which all means that the death rate in older people is enormously higher. I firmly believe the mainstream media should be educating the public on this, explaining how respiratory viral infections such as covid kill people, what co-morbidity is, the difference in risk by age etc. This is essential to make balanced informed decisions, but unfortunately we are just bombarded with the total number of deaths every day "with" coronavirus, and little further detail in the MSM.

This is why my personal opinion is that moving forward, the plan should be centred around healthy working people getting back to work to limit the socio economic damage which will affect the poor disproportionately, while the over 65s and vulnerable should be shielded as much as physically possible. I realise the practicalities are difficult and far more complicated, and I certainly don't have the answer to how this should precisely work, but I believe this should be the basis of a plan going forward.

Unfortunately, as with many things these days, there's far too many people simply shut the debate down and label it as "deaths vs money".

I would urge everyone to research these things I've mentioned, and far more, in order to get a balanced view of this disease, how it works, co-morbidity, the risk to age groups etc. This is essential to make informed decisions on how we move forward.

I don't think this is deaths vs money at all but even with research it doesn't mean the understanding of the disease is at a stage where we, as a nation, can effectively be making guesses as to what to do next, which is what happened yesterday.

You say do the research and I have looked at the figures, not thorough research obviously, but I didn't stop at the under 45s (a strange number to stop at as we have a working age in the uk of nearly 70 these days btw). But let's use your figures and then add some.

Deaths in under 45s up to week 17 in 2019 was 6,068 compared to 6,279 in 2020 - like you say, no real worry there.
Deaths in under 65s for the same periods was 28,210 vs 32,052 - nearly an extra 4k deaths, again not massive until you look in a bit more detail and realise that virtually all of those 4k came in the 4 weeks to week 17, that's a thousand extra people of working age dying every week year on year. Is that an acceptable figure?
And then look at the deaths as a whole for the year to week 17 and then you have 229,300 against 185,519, that's an extra 44,000 people that have died up until 24th April including 40,000 in the last 4 weeks of that period - that's 10,000 extra deaths a week. And apart from the fact that these are all old and will die anyway at some point, Is that figure acceptable to you?

The government fucked up the start of this unbelievably badly and because of that we should be locking down for longer until we have it under control, but instead of accepting they fucked up and apologising for the extra pain that they will cause by locking down for longer they have decided to release the lockdown. And this is at a point where there rolling average death figure is higher than when the initial decision to lock down was made - what has changed?

(05-11-2020, 03:50 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: The statements made by the govt aren't confusing in themselves. The problem is i doubt the majority of the population agree with this approach. England the 2nd most densely populated country in the world in countries over 50 million people with a bad covid-19 issue - why ease the lockdown now? Just watch the infection spike come next Monday.

Exactly FB - I would be saying that it will come in a couple of weeks due to incubation periods etc but it will come and then there will be the delay in cases spread whilst not on lockdown. 

So in the meantime, all the businesses that have to restart their order looks will be asked to close down again and watch the pipeline dry up.

Fuck it, it's only the old ones that are at risk though.

The 2nd wave of infections will be around Bank hol time imo and may well be (according to what experts you believe) a lot worse than the 1st, unfortunately trying to get people to adopt another lockdown could well prove problematic, do you begin to suspect that the govt are now trying to reintroduce their herd immunity by stealth or am I just being a bit cynical.
Reply
#46
(05-11-2020, 05:30 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: The 2nd wave of infections will be around Bank hol time imo and may well be (according to what experts you believe) a lot worse than the 1st, unfortunately trying to get people to adopt another lockdown could well prove problematic, do you begin to suspect that the govt are now trying to reintroduce their herd immunity by stealth or am I just being a bit cynical.

I don't think they are that intelligent to be honest tetley, they've fucked up all along, I really can't see it all being part of a master plan with that candy floss haired muppet as the dancing ape at the front.

They're guessing at what to do, gambling with lives that ironically were their core support as well
Reply
#47
(05-11-2020, 03:08 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Spot on. Its the poor who will suffer healthwise, jobwise the longer lockdown goes on.

Too many people are labelling the whole thing "money vs deaths", which is ridiculous.

Absolutely right. We don't ban cars from the road despite 1,800 deaths and 160,000 casualties 2018 - but we put appropriate and considered laws in place.
Reply
#48
(05-11-2020, 04:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-11-2020, 03:08 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Spot on. Its the poor who will suffer healthwise, jobwise the longer lockdown goes on.

Too many people are labelling the whole thing "money vs deaths", which is ridiculous.

Its more like "corona deaths vs deaths/jobs/health from the impact of lockdown", if we have to label it in a few words (which of course we can't anyway).

In addition, we're also in a situation whereby the total number of coronavirus deaths is being looked at in isolation, due to the over simplification in the mainstream media. This isn't how respiratory viral infections work. They exacerbate other health issues in the majority of cases. As such, the death rate amongst healthy under 45s is very small. And I mean tiny. We're into road traffic accident type of percentages for the chance of dying if you're a healthy under 45. Even under 65 the figures are low. For example... Older people often have internal organs that only work at, say, 70% efficiency of a young person. That's what age does to us. This is fine for older people to still live and their bodies function under normal circumstances. Reduce the supply of oxygen by a further 20% though (as in when corona gets hold of the lungs), and then the organs are in massive trouble (why many are dying of corona induced kidney failure). A healthy under 45 however can take that 20% reduction in oxygen, feel like shit for a couple of weeks, then the body gets over it. This is only one example, but its the same for an older person's cardiovascular system (their arteries are a bit thinner etc), which all means that the death rate in older people is enormously higher. I firmly believe the mainstream media should be educating the public on this, explaining how respiratory viral infections such as covid kill people, what co-morbidity is, the difference in risk by age etc. This is essential to make balanced informed decisions, but unfortunately we are just bombarded with the total number of deaths every day "with" coronavirus, and little further detail in the MSM.

This is why my personal opinion is that moving forward, the plan should be centred around healthy working people getting back to work to limit the socio economic damage which will affect the poor disproportionately, while the over 65s and vulnerable should be shielded as much as physically possible. I realise the practicalities are difficult and far more complicated, and I certainly don't have the answer to how this should precisely work, but I believe this should be the basis of a plan going forward.

Unfortunately, as with many things these days, there's far too many people simply shut the debate down and label it as "deaths vs money".

I would urge everyone to research these things I've mentioned, and far more, in order to get a balanced view of this disease, how it works, co-morbidity, the risk to age groups etc. This is essential to make informed decisions on how we move forward.

I don't think this is deaths vs money at all but even with research it doesn't mean the understanding of the disease is at a stage where we, as a nation, can effectively be making guesses as to what to do next, which is what happened yesterday.

You say do the research and I have looked at the figures, not thorough research obviously, but I didn't stop at the under 45s (a strange number to stop at as we have a working age in the uk of nearly 70 these days btw). But let's use your figures and then add some.

Deaths in under 45s up to week 17 in 2019 was 6,068 compared to 6,279 in 2020 - like you say, no real worry there.
Deaths in under 65s for the same periods was 28,210 vs 32,052 - nearly an extra 4k deaths, again not massive until you look in a bit more detail and realise that virtually all of those 4k came in the 4 weeks to week 17, that's a thousand extra people of working age dying every week year on year. Is that an acceptable figure?
And then look at the deaths as a whole for the year to week 17 and then you have 229,300 against 185,519, that's an extra 44,000 people that have died up until 24th April including 40,000 in the last 4 weeks of that period - that's 10,000 extra deaths a week. And apart from the fact that these are all old and will die anyway at some point, Is that figure acceptable to you?

The government fucked up the start of this unbelievably badly and because of that we should be locking down for longer until we have it under control, but instead of accepting they fucked up and apologising for the extra pain that they will cause by locking down for longer they have decided to release the lockdown. And this is at a point where there rolling average death figure is higher than when the initial decision to lock down was made - what has changed?

(05-11-2020, 03:50 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: The statements made by the govt aren't confusing in themselves. The problem is i doubt the majority of the population agree with this approach. England the 2nd most densely populated country in the world in countries over 50 million people with a bad covid-19 issue - why ease the lockdown now? Just watch the infection spike come next Monday.

Exactly FB - I would be saying that it will come in a couple of weeks due to incubation periods etc but it will come and then there will be the delay in cases spread whilst not on lockdown. 

So in the meantime, all the businesses that have to restart their order looks will be asked to close down again and watch the pipeline dry up.

Fuck it, it's only the old ones that are at risk though.

Of course deaths aren't acceptable, but unfortunately they're unavoidable. Its surely about limiting numbers. You've based the entire argument on covid deaths and not balanced it against the deaths/poverty from lockdown. My point is that the debate cannot be only on covid deaths. All I'm saying is a sensible balanced debate includes factoring in the deaths that lockdown will cause through socio economic hardship. The sad fact is the longer lockdown goes on, there will be less covid deaths, but more future deaths and poverty due to economic damage. To ignore the latter and only base it on the covid deaths is frankly bizarre. I do not pretend to know where the "tipping point" is at all.

I've not said anywhere in my post that lockdown should stop, or shouldn't stop right now. I actually said i believe the elderly should be the focus of shielding as they are the most at risk (my words were shielded as much as pysically possible!), and I made the point that the focus moving forward should be based on risks of age groups (gven the figures, I can't believe anyone would disagree with that).

I'm not saying "fuck it its only the old ones at risk", any more than you're saying "fuck the socio economic damage and deaths/poverty/misery that will cause”. I actually said the elderly should be the focus of shielding to protect them.
Reply
#49
But how do you expect to run an economy with just the under 45s? Because you either have to risk the rest of society or shield them, this isn’t about % chance, this is about definitive numbers of deaths.
Reply
#50
(05-11-2020, 09:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: But how do you expect to run an economy with just the under 45s? Because you either have to risk the rest of society or shield them, this isn’t about % chance, this is about definitive numbers of deaths.

I don't expect to run an economy on under 45s. I said I think this should be the focus of how we move forward. Not literally under 45s go out, everyone else stay in! That would be barmy. I don't pretend to have the answer to every practicality, but I think it has to be based around these statistics by age group.

I'm more worried about how you run an economy if the lockdown goes on and on, and I'm very worried how the poor will be disproportionately affected in the medium to long term. But again, I'm not even giving an opinion on when lockdown should be lifted, I'm saying the debate should include all these factors I'm talking about, not just covid deaths.

% chance is based on a definitive number of deaths in each age group, that's the point of detailed statistical analysis.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)