100, 000 daily tests
#41
You're going to get that JOK with so many different set ups, private, state, specialist - although there are operating guidelines each business will operate them differently and different managers / owners will be more / less proactive / professional. Too many variables I'm afraid.
Reply
#42
I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.
Reply
#43
That's the bit that gets me as well JOK -there will be so much to learn from this eventually. My only guess is that there must be some sort of genetic reason for examples like you say there. It could open up a Pandora's box
Reply
#44
(05-13-2020, 09:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: That's the bit that gets me as well JOK -there will be so much to learn from this eventually. My only guess is that there must be some sort of genetic reason for examples like you say there. It could open up a Pandora's box

There must be something genetic in it. Why, for instance, are the BAME community by far the worse, proportionately, affected? 

If I owned a tin foil hat I would be very suspicious!
Reply
#45
(05-13-2020, 09:35 AM)JOK Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 09:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: That's the bit that gets me as well JOK -there will be so much to learn from this eventually. My only guess is that there must be some sort of genetic reason for examples like you say there. It could open up a Pandora's box

There must be something genetic in it. Why, for instance, are the BAME community by far the worse, proportionately, affected? 

If I owned a tin foil hat I would be very suspicious!

I've read that BAME are particularly affected because they disproportionately live in the city, commute via public transport, work in the NHS, live in more crowded accomodation and are poorer. All these contribute to higher likelihood of catching the virus and also mean they are less likely to be healthy and so more likely to succumb. 

There maybe something genetic, but that would imply that there's something unique in being white, as BAME covers every other race on the planet! Possible, but unlikely. The most likely way that would happen would be if the virus originated in a 'white' Europe so an inbuilt herd immunity had developed. Therefore, it's more likely the socio-economic reasons.


*** It's anecdotal that BAME suffer most. Like in a lot of headlines to do with Corona, no proper research has been done. So this could be irrelevant, anyway!
Reply
#46
(05-13-2020, 10:02 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 09:35 AM)JOK Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 09:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: That's the bit that gets me as well JOK -there will be so much to learn from this eventually. My only guess is that there must be some sort of genetic reason for examples like you say there. It could open up a Pandora's box

There must be something genetic in it. Why, for instance, are the BAME community by far the worse, proportionately, affected? 

If I owned a tin foil hat I would be very suspicious!

I've read that BAME are particularly affected because they disproportionately live in the city, commute via public transport, work in the NHS, live in more crowded accomodation and are poorer. All these contribute to higher likelihood of catching the virus and also mean they are less likely to be healthy and so more likely to succumb. 

There maybe something genetic, but that would imply that there's something unique in being white, as BAME covers every other race on the planet!  Possible, but unlikely. The most likely way that would happen would be if the virus originated in a 'white' Europe so an inbuilt herd immunity had developed. Therefore, it's more likely the socio-economic reasons.


*** It's anecdotal that BAME suffer most. Like in a lot of headlines to do with Corona, no proper research has been done. So this could be irrelevant, anyway!

Lower Vitamin D is something that is being explored.
Reply
#47
(05-13-2020, 08:53 AM)JOK Wrote: I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.

Under 45yrs only a few hundred people have died. Mainly due to underlying health conditions. So perfectly healthy people in 99.99% of cases haven't died. It is almost exclusively a killer of those who are already weakened in some way. For example, overweight, smokers, drinkers, diabetics with circulatory issues.
Reply
#48
(05-13-2020, 11:29 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 08:53 AM)JOK Wrote: I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.

Under 45yrs only a few hundred people have died. Mainly due to underlying health conditions. So perfectly healthy people in 99.99% of cases haven't died. It is almost exclusively a killer of those who are already weakened in some way. For example, overweight, smokers, drinkers, diabetics with circulatory issues.

So Americans then?
Reply
#49
(05-13-2020, 10:02 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 09:35 AM)JOK Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 09:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: That's the bit that gets me as well JOK -there will be so much to learn from this eventually. My only guess is that there must be some sort of genetic reason for examples like you say there. It could open up a Pandora's box

There must be something genetic in it. Why, for instance, are the BAME community by far the worse, proportionately, affected? 

If I owned a tin foil hat I would be very suspicious!

I've read that BAME are particularly affected because they disproportionately live in the city, commute via public transport, work in the NHS, live in more crowded accomodation and are poorer. All these contribute to higher likelihood of catching the virus and also mean they are less likely to be healthy and so more likely to succumb. 

There maybe something genetic, but that would imply that there's something unique in being white, as BAME covers every other race on the planet!  Possible, but unlikely. The most likely way that would happen would be if the virus originated in a 'white' Europe so an inbuilt herd immunity had developed. Therefore, it's more likely the socio-economic reasons.


*** It's anecdotal that BAME suffer most. Like in a lot of headlines to do with Corona, no proper research has been done. So this could be irrelevant, anyway!

I fear advocates of eugenics and white supremacism are going to dine out on this hypothesis.

(05-13-2020, 11:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 11:29 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 08:53 AM)JOK Wrote: I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.

Under 45yrs only a few hundred people have died. Mainly due to underlying health conditions. So perfectly healthy people in 99.99% of cases haven't died. It is almost exclusively a killer of those who are already weakened in some way. For example, overweight, smokers, drinkers, diabetics with circulatory issues.

So Americans then?

I'd omit the drinkers bit.  Of the many cultural stereotypes used to castigate Yanks, i found "shit drinkers" to be fairly accurate.
Reply
#50
(05-13-2020, 08:30 AM)JOK Wrote: Three weeks ago, in my mother home, a gentleman showed symptoms on Monday evening. The whole home, residents and staff, were tested on the Thursday and given the results on the following Sunday. Nine confirmed cases. No deaths!
I find it hard to believe the wildly varying outcomes. In testing and virus.

My friend has second result today and is positive.

Whether JOK believes me or not isn't the issue on my mind right now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)