PSR breach reported by John Percy
(04-17-2026, 11:03 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Quick football q how has Max O'Leary done for yourselves?

Steady but with an error in him or?

We had John Pelling too in the past..pretty competent financially.

While I'm at it, even if say a 1 point or 2 point deduction the final outcome I suspect WBA have enough, you look solid enough.

An improvement on Griffiths, whom I rate, by the way. An unexpectedly good signing. He was a big miss for us when he was out for a few games. The defence definitely appears more confident and assured when he’s behind them.- whether that’s because of MOL, improved coaching now Ramsay has departed, suddenly having Campbell playing at centre half, or a combination of all three, I don’t know.
Reply
(04-17-2026, 11:03 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Quick football q how has Max O'Leary done for yourselves?

Steady but with an error in him or?

We had John Pelling too in the past..pretty competent financially.

While I'm at it, even if say a 1 point or 2 point deduction the final outcome I suspect WBA have enough, you look solid enough.

Unlike others I don't particularly rate him and our other keeper is clearly a better all round goalkeeper, for me O'Leary is poor on crosses and hardly seems to save anything difficult, his distribution is iffy too. That said, he's picked up a few clean sheets and seems to have the trust of the (now settled) backline. Not a major issue though unless teams start bombarding us with crosses last 4 games, one of the games he missed (Wrexham) we'd have definitely lost if he had played imo.
Reply
(04-17-2026, 11:44 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(04-17-2026, 11:03 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Quick football q how has Max O'Leary done for yourselves?

Steady but with an error in him or?

We had John Pelling too in the past..pretty competent financially.

While I'm at it, even if say a 1 point or 2 point deduction the final outcome I suspect WBA have enough, you look solid enough.

Unlike others I don't particularly rate him and our other keeper is clearly a better all round goalkeeper, for me O'Leary is poor on crosses and hardly seems to save anything difficult, his distribution is iffy too. That said, he's picked up a few clean sheets and seems to have the trust of the (now settled) backline. Not a major issue though unless teams start bombarding us with crosses last 4 games, one of the games he missed (Wrexham) we'd have definitely lost if he had played imo.

Which of our other keepers is better than O’Leary? Wildshit who is the worst statistical goalkeeper in the league this year, or Griffiths who isn’t far behind in terms of errors and save %?

Josh has potential, and may improve with a better defence in front of him, but O’Leary has been better since coming in, though based on this year, neither have been good enough for where we want to be.
Reply
(04-17-2026, 11:03 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Quick football q how has Max O'Leary done for yourselves?

Steady but with an error in him or?

We had John Pelling too in the past..pretty competent financially.

While I'm at it, even if say a 1 point or 2 point deduction the final outcome I suspect WBA have enough, you look solid enough.

In my opinion - Max has reassured our back line and is the keeper we needed for the situation we are in (With lack of better options out there). 

Do i believe he is a better keeper than Josh, no. I think they both have their strengths and they both have their weaknesses and they are "on par" with each other given the ones strength is the others weakness. However MOL uses his voice much more than Josh, which in turn along with a bit of a shake up and GC back as CB has made us look more comfortable.
Reply
(04-17-2026, 11:03 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Quick football q how has Max O'Leary done for yourselves?

Steady but with an error in him or?

We had John Pelling too in the past..pretty competent financially.

While I'm at it, even if say a 1 point or 2 point deduction the final outcome I suspect WBA have enough, you look solid enough.

He's been a good signing for us in that he's been competent and means Griffiths has been allowed to rebuild his confidence after a pretty horrible season with a defence doing it's best to destroy him. O'Leary is more vocal, organises the defence better and though probably isn't a particularly great keeper, has given some leadership and motivation to a team that was struggling, he's also benefitted from us actually setting the defence up properly for games.

I'd sign him for next year and keep him and Griffiths in rotation, hoping by end of next season, Griffiths establishes himself as solid number one, I know I'd never feel worried if O'Leary suddenly had to come in, whereas with Wildshit I knew we were fucked as soon as I saw his name.
Reply
(04-17-2026, 11:03 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Quick football q how has Max O'Leary done for yourselves?

Steady but with an error in him or?

We had John Pelling too in the past..pretty competent financially.

While I'm at it, even if say a 1 point or 2 point deduction the final outcome I suspect WBA have enough, you look solid enough.

I thank him for his efforts but look forward to the club finding some magic beans stuck behind a sofa somewhere in the hope of signing better in the summer.
Reply
MOL is a decent back-up keeper at Champo levek and can get by at a bottom end Champ team, which is currently where our previous coaches have got us to.

Longer term he's not good enough, not sure whether Josh is either, but I expect Josh has the potential to improve over time whereas MOL has peaked.

I'd keep MOL for the remaniing 4 games, if goes wrong and we're in L1 next season he's be ok, not great, but ok. I'd like to think that if we do stay up and the owners are serious about our future then we could attract better for a full Champ season. I do accept why he was needed for now, Wildshit was so bad, he even managed to make Josh a worse keeper, although Mason had a fair part to play in destroying his confidence too.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
I think we've been spoilt over the decades with our legendary keepers.

As have England.
Reply
He’s bang average as is Griffiths neither are good enough to be the clubs no1 if we stay in the Championship. Neither is going to save us 10pts or so a season and at best they will be neutral at worst they will cost us points.

I’d hope for better but I very much doubt given the last twelve months of enforced reduction in quality the squad we will get better. Whether we are in the Championship or ffs League One.
Reply
(04-17-2026, 02:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He’s bang average as is Griffiths neither are good enough to be the clubs no1 if we stay in the Championship. Neither is going to save us 10pts or so a season and at best they will be neutral at worst they will cost us points.

I’d hope for better but I very much doubt given the last twelve months of enforced reduction in quality the squad we will get better. Whether we are in the Championship or ffs League One.

Would probably agree. Griffiths will have more slack coming up through the ranks but you'd probably want to look to be getting an upgrade on either.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: