Olé....
#31
I see no evidence Smith would have got us up, bear in mind we would not have had Gayle or Barnes since they were very, very much Moore's influence.

He couldn't buy a win without Grealish, and we had no one similar.

Johnson would have done it though imo, I do rate him as a manager.

If people remember, I was never convinced on Smith, and wasn't keen at any point.
Reply
#32
(09-28-2019, 10:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I see no evidence Smith would have got us up, bear in mind we would not have had Gayle or Barnes since they were very, very much Moore's influence.

He couldn't buy a win without Grealish, and we had no one similar.

Johnson would have done it though imo, I do rate him as a manager.

If people remember, I was never convinced on Smith, and wasn't keen at any point.

Not sure I agree about Johnson getting us up. He’s never mounted a promotion push in his career to date, and regardless of what money he has to spend his sides are consistently inconsistent.

Entertaining football, but to get promotion you need managers who can drag sides to 1-0 wins over the course of a long season, and johnson doesn’t seem to be able to do that.
Reply
#33
Johnson seems to be a streaky manager. Win 5 in a row. Then go 8 without a win. Repeat.
Reply
#34
(09-28-2019, 10:42 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-28-2019, 10:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I see no evidence Smith would have got us up, bear in mind we would not have had Gayle or Barnes since they were very, very much Moore's influence.

He couldn't buy a win without Grealish, and we had no one similar.

Johnson would have done it though imo, I do rate him as a manager.

If people remember, I was never convinced on Smith, and wasn't keen at any point.

Not sure I agree about Johnson getting us up. He’s never mounted a promotion push in his career to date, and regardless of what money he has to spend his sides are consistently inconsistent.

Entertaining football, but to get promotion you need managers who can drag sides to 1-0 wins over the course of a long season, and johnson doesn’t seem to be able to do that.

True, think he may have had the squad to do it with us, but only guess work anyway. 

Just really don't rate Smith, did well at Walsall, but Brentford fans put his success down to Their DoF and lament his ability to grind out results, a lack of a plan B and over reliance on one or two players. That's why I didn't like him, then we saw what he is like as a person too and I really, really am glad we never appointed him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)