Suspended Parliament
#31
(08-29-2019, 10:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:26 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:08 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: Boris Johnson takes a course of action which leads to 3 fewer sitting days. John Major prorogued in 1997 for way longer, it's not unprecedented. Remainers: "OH MY GOD!! IT'S A COUP!!!".

This would be the longest proroguing of parliament in 40 years (planned to be 5 weeks by Boris, was previously 3 weeks with the usual being less than a week), longer than Major's (15 days, 24th March to 7th April). That is a bare faced lie, the rest of your post is opinionated rubbish.

Well done BB, I read it and couldn't be arsed to even respond - it's just more bullshit from the leave at all costs camp. It would help if Boris just said what everyone knows is the reasoning and ballsed it out, instead he hides like a cheeky schoolboy.

https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/...fullreport

https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansa...parliament

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmse9697.htm

Sources are here for it are in the last two links (note, it is 15 days as Parliament doesn't sit on weekends, hence it is from the 24th and not the 22nd of March in the second list), the 6 week bullshit that some people are using to justify what Boris is doing includes the dissolution of parliament on the 8th of April for a general election, the prorogation was designed to evade government scrutiny and allow for an election to be called, trying to skirt around the cash for questions scandal. 

That entire list of bullshit stinks of someone who gets all their news from Paul Staines' glorified blog
Reply
#32
(08-29-2019, 10:35 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:26 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:08 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: Boris Johnson takes a course of action which leads to 3 fewer sitting days. John Major prorogued in 1997 for way longer, it's not unprecedented. Remainers: "OH MY GOD!! IT'S A COUP!!!".

This would be the longest proroguing of parliament in 40 years (planned to be 5 weeks by Boris, was previously 3 weeks with the usual being less than a week), longer than Major's (15 days, 24th March to 7th April). That is a bare faced lie, the rest of your post is opinionated rubbish.

Well done BB, I read it and couldn't be arsed to even respond - it's just more bullshit from the leave at all costs camp. It would help if Boris just said what everyone knows is the reasoning and ballsed it out, instead he hides like a cheeky schoolboy.

https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/...fullreport

https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansa...parliament

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmse9697.htm

Sources are here for it are in the last two links (note, it is 15 days as Parliament doesn't sit on weekends, hence it is from the 24th and not the 22nd of March in the second list), the 6 week bullshit that some people are using to justify what Boris is doing includes the dissolution of parliament on the 8th of April for a general election, the prorogation was designed to evade government scrutiny and allow for an election to be called, trying to skirt around the cash for questions scandal. 

That entire list of bullshit stinks of someone who gets all their news from Paul Staines' glorified blog

Your desperation in dismissing facts as lies, as well as your language, merely demonstrate your lack of intelligence. I can evidence all of it. You've embarrassed yourself.

AC Grayling and others tell EU to make negotiations difficult https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8uSFSGR94iE

Bercow allows amendment of Government business motion https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-p...s-46810616

Grieve et al trying to control the UK's exit https://www.theguardian.com/politics/201...-amendment

Consider sending the Queen to an EU summit as Head of State https://metro.co.uk/2019/07/19/plot-use-...-10425033/

Caroline Lucas's all-female Cabinet idea https://www.theguardian.com/politics/201...eal-brexit

Ken Clarke as caretaker PM https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-49372525

Jo Swinson says she would not accept a leave win in a second referendum https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/201...exit-even/
nor would Caroline Lucas (ignore the source, the clip is of her speaking on the BBC's Politics Live) https://www.express.co.uk/videos/6063492...econd-vote

MPs pledge to form alternative Parliament https://www.theguardian.com/politics/201...ion-brexit

That's checkmate to me. You're welcome. Apology accepted.
Reply
#33
Supposed grown men ranting at each other on a non descript football message board, somehow imagining it makes a scrap of difference, how far we have come.
Reply
#34
(08-29-2019, 10:40 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:35 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:26 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:08 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: Boris Johnson takes a course of action which leads to 3 fewer sitting days. John Major prorogued in 1997 for way longer, it's not unprecedented. Remainers: "OH MY GOD!! IT'S A COUP!!!".

This would be the longest proroguing of parliament in 40 years (planned to be 5 weeks by Boris, was previously 3 weeks with the usual being less than a week), longer than Major's (15 days, 24th March to 7th April). That is a bare faced lie, the rest of your post is opinionated rubbish.

Well done BB, I read it and couldn't be arsed to even respond - it's just more bullshit from the leave at all costs camp. It would help if Boris just said what everyone knows is the reasoning and ballsed it out, instead he hides like a cheeky schoolboy.

https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/...fullreport

https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansa...parliament

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmse9697.htm

Sources are here for it are in the last two links (note, it is 15 days as Parliament doesn't sit on weekends, hence it is from the 24th and not the 22nd of March in the second list), the 6 week bullshit that some people are using to justify what Boris is doing includes the dissolution of parliament on the 8th of April for a general election, the prorogation was designed to evade government scrutiny and allow for an election to be called, trying to skirt around the cash for questions scandal. 

That entire list of bullshit stinks of someone who gets all their news from Paul Staines' glorified blog

Your desperation in dismissing facts as lies shows your lack of intelligence. I can evidence all of it. You've embarrassed yourself.

They aren't facts, they are bullshit opinions on events that happened hence me completely ignoring them. You could spin any interpretation what happened and you're never going to agree with me and I'll never agree with you so there was no point in addressing them.

Save for the last one, which was a bare faced lie which I have corrected.
Reply
#35
(08-29-2019, 10:20 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 09:57 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:20 AM)igorbalis Wrote: I'm still not convinced that it would be such a disaster if we were to leave with no deal - I guess only time will tell. My only concern re a no deal is what happens in Northern Ireland, and the implications it will no doubt have for the peace process and the good friday agreement - In all honesty most people just want closure of the whole business and as much as I dislike Boris he is doing what should have been done following the referendum, planning for a no deal exit whilst trying to negotiate the best deal possible from the eu.

There’s no such thing as a no deal Brexit at some point unless we are going to trade with our BIGGEST trading partner on WTO rules for decades we will have to negotiate a deal. The idea we hold the best hand if this happens is nonsense. What are the benefits of leaving without a deal?

1. We are not tied into a backstop that we cannot exit unilaterally - which is arguably illegal on the basis of the decision of the ECJ in Wightman, where the ECJ was at pains to point-out that unilateral withdrawal from Treaty mechanisms is a right of a sovereign state

2. We are not subject to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK (albeit vicariously)

3. We are mot subject to EU laws that we have had no role in shaping

4. It evades the restrictions May agreed in our our future trade deals

5. It doesn't violate the GFA which the backstop arguable does as it alters the constitutional status of Northern Ireland in relation to the rest of the UK without consent of the NI people. (Incidentally, while no-one wants to see a border any more than currently exists across Ireland, there is no commitment in the GFA on any border type.)

1. The backstop is an insurance policy designed to skirt around the delicate situation of the Irish border, and if a viable proposal on how to manage the border is put forward and implemented then the backstop is redundant

2. Canada is subject to ECJ jurisdiction through the CETA court

3. Do you understand how trade deals work? We will be subject to EU legislation through any trade deal and won't be able to shape it without being in the EU. This is the same with literally every trade deal

4. The political declaration in the withdrawal agreement is not a guarantee, it is a plan and subject to change as it is a separate document

5. We will need to put security forces to manage a customs border between NI and Ireland if we were trading with the EU on WTO rules unless we decide to do no customs checks at all with anyone (bad idea) and that violates the GFA.

You can't have your cake and eat it.

2. The difference is that Canada can unilaterally exit CETA, the UK cannot the backstop. It's also a Tribunal rather than a court. The ECJ has no jurisdiction over the Tribunal, which is limited to rulings on CETA itself. EU law will only be admissable as evidence of fact, not as rules of law. https://www.twobirds.com/en/news/article...ith-eu-law That is a huge difference to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK

3. Sure. But that is still not EU lawmaking power within the UK. There's a difference

4. I am aware, but what relevance has that to your argument?

(08-29-2019, 10:50 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:40 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:35 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:26 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: This would be the longest proroguing of parliament in 40 years (planned to be 5 weeks by Boris, was previously 3 weeks with the usual being less than a week), longer than Major's (15 days, 24th March to 7th April). That is a bare faced lie, the rest of your post is opinionated rubbish.

Well done BB, I read it and couldn't be arsed to even respond - it's just more bullshit from the leave at all costs camp. It would help if Boris just said what everyone knows is the reasoning and ballsed it out, instead he hides like a cheeky schoolboy.

https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/...fullreport

https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansa...parliament

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmse9697.htm

Sources are here for it are in the last two links (note, it is 15 days as Parliament doesn't sit on weekends, hence it is from the 24th and not the 22nd of March in the second list), the 6 week bullshit that some people are using to justify what Boris is doing includes the dissolution of parliament on the 8th of April for a general election, the prorogation was designed to evade government scrutiny and allow for an election to be called, trying to skirt around the cash for questions scandal. 

That entire list of bullshit stinks of someone who gets all their news from Paul Staines' glorified blog

Your desperation in dismissing facts as lies shows your lack of intelligence. I can evidence all of it. You've embarrassed yourself.

They aren't facts, they are bullshit opinions on events that happened hence me completely ignoring them. You could spin any interpretation what happened and you're never going to agree with me and I'll never agree with you so there was no point in addressing them.

Save for the last one, which was a bare faced lie which I have corrected.

Everything I claimed was correct, as the above evidence shows. I can see that there is no point in engaging with anyone with such a poor understanding of matters, nor anyone who is unable to admit when they have been proven wrong.

You said my list of remain disrespect for democracy was, I quote, 'bullshit'. I have showed that it was not. I am sure the forum can weigh-up the evidence and conclude accordingly.

Glad this place has an ignore function.
Reply
#36
(08-29-2019, 10:59 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:20 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 09:57 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 08:20 AM)igorbalis Wrote: I'm still not convinced that it would be such a disaster if we were to leave with no deal - I guess only time will tell. My only concern re a no deal is what happens in Northern Ireland, and the implications it will no doubt have for the peace process and the good friday agreement - In all honesty most people just want closure of the whole business and as much as I dislike Boris he is doing what should have been done following the referendum, planning for a no deal exit whilst trying to negotiate the best deal possible from the eu.

There’s no such thing as a no deal Brexit at some point unless we are going to trade with our BIGGEST trading partner on WTO rules for decades we will have to negotiate a deal. The idea we hold the best hand if this happens is nonsense. What are the benefits of leaving without a deal?

1. We are not tied into a backstop that we cannot exit unilaterally - which is arguably illegal on the basis of the decision of the ECJ in Wightman, where the ECJ was at pains to point-out that unilateral withdrawal from Treaty mechanisms is a right of a sovereign state

2. We are not subject to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK (albeit vicariously)

3. We are mot subject to EU laws that we have had no role in shaping

4. It evades the restrictions May agreed in our our future trade deals

5. It doesn't violate the GFA which the backstop arguable does as it alters the constitutional status of Northern Ireland in relation to the rest of the UK without consent of the NI people. (Incidentally, while no-one wants to see a border any more than currently exists across Ireland, there is no commitment in the GFA on any border type.)

1. The backstop is an insurance policy designed to skirt around the delicate situation of the Irish border, and if a viable proposal on how to manage the border is put forward and implemented then the backstop is redundant

2. Canada is subject to ECJ jurisdiction through the CETA court

3. Do you understand how trade deals work? We will be subject to EU legislation through any trade deal and won't be able to shape it without being in the EU. This is the same with literally every trade deal

4. The political declaration in the withdrawal agreement is not a guarantee, it is a plan and subject to change as it is a separate document

5. We will need to put security forces to manage a customs border between NI and Ireland if we were trading with the EU on WTO rules unless we decide to do no customs checks at all with anyone (bad idea) and that violates the GFA.

You can't have your cake and eat it.

2. The difference is that Canada can unilaterally exit CETA, the UK cannot the backstop. It's also a Tribunal rather than a court. The ECJ has no jurisdiction over the Tribunal, which is limited to rulings on CETA itself. EU law will only be admissable as evidence of fact, not as rules of law. https://www.twobirds.com/en/news/article...ith-eu-law That is a huge difference to ECJ jurisdiction within the UK

3. Sure. But that is still not EU lawmaking power within the UK. There's a difference

4. I am aware, but what relevance has that to your argument?

(08-29-2019, 10:50 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:40 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:35 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Well done BB, I read it and couldn't be arsed to even respond - it's just more bullshit from the leave at all costs camp. It would help if Boris just said what everyone knows is the reasoning and ballsed it out, instead he hides like a cheeky schoolboy.

https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/...fullreport

https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansa...parliament

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmse9697.htm

Sources are here for it are in the last two links (note, it is 15 days as Parliament doesn't sit on weekends, hence it is from the 24th and not the 22nd of March in the second list), the 6 week bullshit that some people are using to justify what Boris is doing includes the dissolution of parliament on the 8th of April for a general election, the prorogation was designed to evade government scrutiny and allow for an election to be called, trying to skirt around the cash for questions scandal. 

That entire list of bullshit stinks of someone who gets all their news from Paul Staines' glorified blog

Your desperation in dismissing facts as lies shows your lack of intelligence. I can evidence all of it. You've embarrassed yourself.

They aren't facts, they are bullshit opinions on events that happened hence me completely ignoring them. You could spin any interpretation what happened and you're never going to agree with me and I'll never agree with you so there was no point in addressing them.

Save for the last one, which was a bare faced lie which I have corrected.

Everything I claimed was correct, as the above evidence shows. I can see that there is no point in engaging with anyone with such a poor understanding of matters, nor anyone who is unable to admit when they have been proven wrong.

You said my list of remain disrespect for democracy was, I quote, 'bullshit'. I have showed that it was not. I am sure the forum can weigh-up the evidence and conclude accordingly.

Glad this place has an ignore function.

2. As per the withdrawal agreement, your interpretation of the scope of the ECJ over UK law would only last for the duration of the transitional period after which it would need to be replaced by a CETA-like tribunal panel as per the future trade arrangements. And the UK can't unilaterally exit the backstop as it is a backstop, it is a fallback if nothing is agreed. That is the point of it, and to avoid it all that needs to happen is viable plan for managing the Irish border to be implemented.

3. That part of the withdrawal agreement lasts only until the end of the transition, after which the EU holds no lawmaking power over the UK outside the scope of a trade agreement which would be the case with every other trade agreement we make.

4. The restrictions on May's arrangement are a piece of paper that are not signed into law, they can be changed.

As for your list of "evidence", it is a bunch of bullshit opinions based on spin from one side of the argument, anyone could look at those events and spin accordingly (hint, it would still be bullshit opinions) and I cannot be arsed to put up a list of my opinions on those events that would come to a completely different conclusion. It is a waste of fucking time for both of us, and it doesn't prove anything one way or another.

As for not being able to admit when you're wrong, I literally provided the link from Hansard to prove to you that you were lying about the length of Major's proroguing. I corrected you because that was an objective fact that you were wrong about. You have instead doubled down and decided to ignore the actual evidence I posted. I will admit I am wrong when you provide evidence to support that as I have done before.
Reply
#37
(08-29-2019, 10:59 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: I am sure the forum can weigh-up the evidence and conclude accordingly

Glad this place has an ignore function.

I agree, on both counts and particularly the latter

Anybody ending a post with "That's checkmate to me. You're welcome. Apology accepted" is proof enough of its usefulness.
Reply
#38
DerekHardballs - I can't find your post about which ECJ judgments I don't like.

It is an irrelevant issue to the one I raised. My objection is about the ECJ having jurisdiction within the UK when we have left, as I made clear. To be subject to a Court of an organisation you are not a member of at the international law level is bad enough. But it's downright perverse for a court of an organisation you are not a member of to have intra-jurisdictional authority.

Your argument is similar to the risible argument that remainers use on social media 'Tell me one EU you don't like'. Even if every law emanating from the EU was magnificent, the problem would still be with the process.

The same is true of the ECJ. It makes no bones about the fact that it makes new law to 'Further the aims of the Treaties'. I am sorry, but courts are there to interpret and apply law. Not make it.

Anyway, here's a the list of ECJ judgments I don't like, off the top of my head:

Costa v ENEL - establishing the supremacy of EEC law (as it was) over national law even though there was nothing in the Treaty about it

Ratti, and Marshall v Southampton AHA, where the court invented the doctrine of vertical direct effect of Directives - again, something noit found in the Treaty at the time

The expansive definition of 'the state' to include any public body, for the purposes of direct effect, in Foster v British Gas

Indirect effect as outlined in Van Colson - meaning that domestic law has to be interpreted in-accordance with unimplemented Directives. The ECJ's remit is to interpret and apply EU law, NOT to tell member states what to do with their own domestic law. Yet another ECJ power grab (becoming a theme, isn't it?)

The broad definition of 'undertaking' (business) in various antitrust cases to allow interventionism

United Brands, where different pricing in different member states was an abuse of a dominant position (it wasn't)

Lastly, the case where the ECJ decided that MEPs allowances can't be published even in redacted form. So much for EU transparency https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/s...urt-ruling

(08-29-2019, 11:24 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:59 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: I am sure the forum can weigh-up the evidence and conclude accordingly

Glad this place has an ignore function.

I agree, on both counts and particularly the latter

Anybody ending a post with "That's checkmate to me. You're welcome. Apology accepted" is proof enough of its usefulness.

Aw, upset are you because your mate's argument was totally defeated? I'll ignore you as well.
Reply
#39
(08-29-2019, 11:26 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: DerekHardballs - I can't find your post about which ECJ judgments I don't like.

It is an irrelevant issue to the one I raised. My objection is about the ECJ having  jurisdiction within the UK when we have left, as I made clear. To be subject to a Court of an organisation you are not a member of at the international law level is bad enough. But it's downright perverse for a court of an organisation you are not a member of to have intra-jurisdictional authority.

Your argument is similar to the risible argument that remainers use on social media 'Tell me one EU you don't like'. Even if every law emanating from the EU was magnificent, the problem would still be with the process.

The same is true of the ECJ. It makes no bones about the fact that it makes new law to 'Further the aims of the Treaties'. I am sorry, but courts are there to interpret and apply law. Not make it.

Anyway, here's a the list of ECJ judgments I don't like, off the top of my head:

Costa v ENEL - establishing the supremacy of EEC law (as it was) over national law even though there was nothing in the Treaty about it

Ratti, and Marshall v Southampton AHA, where the court invented the doctrine of vertical direct effect of Directives - again, something noit found in the Treaty at the time

The expansive definition of 'the state' to include any public body, for the purposes of direct effect, in Foster v British Gas

Indirect effect as outlined in Van Colson - meaning that domestic law has to be interpreted in-accordance with unimplemented Directives. The ECJ's remit is to interpret and apply EU law, NOT to tell member states what to do with their own domestic law. Yet another ECJ power grab (becoming a theme, isn't it?)

The broad definition of 'undertaking' (business) in various antitrust cases to allow interventionism

United Brands, where different pricing in different member states was an abuse of a dominant position (it wasn't)

Lastly, the case where the ECJ decided that MEPs allowances can't be published even in redacted form. So much for EU transparency https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/s...urt-ruling

(08-29-2019, 11:24 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(08-29-2019, 10:59 AM)Neil Parsley Wrote: I am sure the forum can weigh-up the evidence and conclude accordingly

Glad this place has an ignore function.

I agree, on both counts and particularly the latter

Anybody ending a post with "That's checkmate to me. You're welcome. Apology accepted" is proof enough of its usefulness.

Aw, upset are you because your mate's argument was totally defeated? I'll ignore you as well.

Piltdown Man great to have you back. Who is first against the wall?
Reply
#40
There's been a lot of back and forth on this, but we appear to just be going around in circles.

Parliament is usually shut around these dates anyway for conference season. They were saying that this year that closure was going to be abandoned due to the weighty issue of Brexit.

However Brexit hasn't stopped any of them going on their summer holidays, so maybe they should have put them on hold too until it was resolved.

Parliament has had three years to resolve this, but hasn't - in fact, it has voted down every single plan or idea put before them about how to do it.

We need to leave because that's what people voted for, but Parliament continue to kick the can down the road and fail to deal with it.

For what it's worth, I think Boris is just posturing to try and get the EU to back down. No Deal is the one bargaining chip we have - it's essentially mutually assured destruction - but I don't think it's what he really wants.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: