Jimmy Shan
#31
(06-29-2019, 05:04 PM)Artist Wrote: We only won one away game under Shan and we stumbled into the plays off with no momentum. He fixed some problems of the past regime but at the same time created new ones.

What new problems did he create out of interest?
Reply
#32
Over reliance on set pieces, conceding even more goals than before despite playing more defensive football, poor away form, lost to all the top teams we faced (Bristol City, Derby, Villa)
Reply
#33
(06-29-2019, 11:01 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:03 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Very disappointed to read this... I thought he did brilliantly last season and wouldn’t have been against him getting the job long term. We’ve taken just as big of a gamble with Bilic as we would have with Shan IMO, but a far more expensive one.

I hope we don’t live to regret letting him leave.

All appointments are a gamble to a degree but I think Bilic has more chance of attracting quality players than Shan, has a brilliant network and he is a very experienced manager who has managed at the highest level in 4 different countries, and at international level.  Do you think it's easy managing a club like Besiktas?  WBA will be like a tea-party by comparison. 

There is absolutely no comparison between Bilic and Shan.

I admire the positive spin, but speaking in facts, Bilic has had a patchy at best record at every club he's managed since leaving Croatia in 2012.

Lokomotiv; Spent a lot of money, led them to their worst league performance since the league was created.... they finished 9th, and were closer to relegation than CL qualification... the following season they finished 3rd.

Besiktas; Two third place finishes, including one where they were top of the league going into the final 5 games and won only 1 of their last 5 to fall to third. 

West Ham; Great first season, but form fell away and he openly admitted he couldn't motivate the players any more. David Moyes came in and got better results.... David Moyes.

Al-Ittihad; Sacked for poor results in a league where an ex Stockport County manager, the current Reading boss and Christian Gross were doing better than him... 

I like Bilic, and I think he is exactly the kind of personality we need to give the place a lift, and raise our profile now we're having to adjust to being the third club in the region, however I don't see anything that fills me with optimism he'll promote us this year.  He is a gamble in that we've given him a lot of control, are no doubt paying him a very decent salary for this league and will back him with cash. 

Shan showed last season he can manage at this level, can get results at this level, and can crucially get results from this squad. He was a bent ref away from promotion. I'd imagine for all Slaven's contacts, Shan will have a better knowledge of players in this division and below, and the youth scene which are key recruitment areas for us. 

I agree one is an experienced manager - although one with a questionable CV but who is passionate on the touchline and disruptive in the media so immediately attracts the praise of simpletons -and one is a young coach who is finding his way but to say they're incomparable is just ludicrous. They would both be a gamble, Bilic is just a more expensive one!

PS: and the idea of Julian Dicks joining as First Team Coach is not one I relish...

Shan interim managed WBA for 12 games in the Chump and took over in similar circumstances to Big Dave;  he did fairly well, but couldn't get us over the line. I think he gave up too quickly on automatic promotion.

He can't be compared to Bilic or any manager who has a similar track record because he has no track record/achievements in management.  We went down that route with Moore and it didn't work. 

There are a number of question marks about Bilic's career/management success, but apart from a handful of managers, there are about everyone,  as they all eventually fail and get sacked.  

I am certainly not getting carried away with Bilic, no-one really knows why he is here (££££) and how it will work out.  

But you can't deny it's given us a massive lift and some kudos and he will be able to get players that otherwise we wouldn't be able to sign because he's Bilic.  We just have to be positive and hope it's a success but there are no guarantees in football.

PS Bilic's version of what happened in Saudi is different to what generally has been reported. He has been quoted as saying he'd 'turned it round' and didn't understand why he'd been sacked though their owners are trigger happy and change managers often - just look at their Wiki profile.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)