Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(09-14-2026, 06:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Simple - if you’re ahead of the ball from a forward pass and there aren’t 2 players between you and the goal you’re offside. Get rid of the bollocks of interfering, touching the ball or second phase because a defender touched the pass. I think it was Jack Charlton, may have been Cloughie, who said “if you’re on the pitch and not interfering with play then I’ll sub them off”.
The perfected off-side trap was a thing of beauty!
Bruno/Foden. 2 yellows or 2 reds. Or red for Foden, yellow for Bruno kicking him and a retrospective ban for feigning injury to get a player sent off.
Man United weren’t crying when Maguire accidentally handled the ball a couple of games back. VAR is a blessing and a curse depending upon if the decision goes your way or not. Goal line technology and duck the rest of it off.
Had to be this - same punishment for both. Or if you're going to do one more harshly than t'other, Bruno instigated it all.
As for the goal, that enzo twat was clearly and obviously interferring with play. Even if he doesn't try and head it, he changes Martinez's decision making. Martinez runs towards Enzo to try and put him off. If Enzo isn't there, he would move backwards towards Haaland and probably intercept.
Pro Ref (if that a PGMOL replacement? Never heard of it before) have come out and said it was a mistake. Guarantee they wouldn't do that if it wasn't United.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
09-15-2026, 06:55 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-15-2026, 07:09 AM by Josh1873.)
https://x.com/ThomasClay3/status/2099535195355353100
Jay Bothroyd nailing it.
The frustrating thing about VAR is it's here to stay, isn't it? You can never go back to football with technology once it's been introduced. If it was up to me, majority of fans, and dare I say a large percentage of clubs, it would be binned off.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Posts: 2,915
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
(09-14-2026, 03:38 AM)Albionmad Wrote: (09-13-2026, 08:25 PM)KRO Wrote: (09-13-2026, 05:21 PM)Albionmad Wrote: (09-13-2026, 04:58 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (09-13-2026, 04:54 PM)Albionmad Wrote: Haaland World class finish but clearly in an offside position when the ball was played.
Assistant ref correctly puts his flag up so goal disallowed.
Referred to VAR and goal given.
Can anybody explain that to me (and Gary Neville)
For an ‘impartial’ co-commentator, Neville’s clear frustration is wonderful to behold.
A deflected cross I assume is the mitigation. But who cares?
Can’t stand Utd, their wanker fans or the owners they deserve. I truly hope City see this out. Especially after the first half incident. For an ‘impartial’ co-commentator, Neville’s clear frustration
I've found Neville to be pretty impartial TBF.
Sky have just posted the rules regarding offside.
Fernandez who was a yard offside made a clear attempt to make contact on the cross.
This impacted the keeper Martinez
So Neville's correct. The pro ref will need to make an apology.
I bet Man City will be gutted. 2 game ban for the whole team incoming
You’re the second person (on different sites) I’ve seen who has said Martinez was the keeper. Laments was the keeper, Martinez was the defender although both were impacted by that Enzo knob being offside and trying to head the ball.
Did you copy and paste your reply?
No. It was one of the commentators who mentioned Martinez. I thought he was referring to the keeper.
As it wasn't Albion I wasn't concentrating 100% on the game.
Please accept my humblest, heartfelt apologies. My post must have ruined your Sunday.
Sarcy old git.
Posts: 1,238
Threads: 76
Joined: Feb 2025
Reputation:
4
(09-14-2026, 06:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Simple - if you’re ahead of the ball from a forward pass and there aren’t 2 players between you and the goal you’re offside. Get rid of the bollocks of interfering, touching the ball or second phase because a defender touched the pass. I think it was Jack Charlton, may have been Cloughie, who said “if you’re on the pitch and not interfering with play then I’ll sub them off”.
The perfected off-side trap was a thing of beauty!
Bruno/Foden. 2 yellows or 2 reds. Or red for Foden, yellow for Bruno kicking him and a retrospective ban for feigning injury to get a player sent off.
Man United weren’t crying when Maguire accidentally handled the ball a couple of games back. VAR is a blessing and a curse depending upon if the decision goes your way or not. Goal line technology and duck the rest of it off.
Yes, but it has always been the case that you are offside in such a situation (apart from when it was three defenders and you could be offside in your own half) but it isn't an offence to be offside. If it were, the ref would be blowing constantly. You are only penalised for interfering with play. The problem is in what is "interfering with play". Look at our goal against Leeds a lifetime ago for how the ref was right but loads thought otherwise. I agree that it has now become unknowable in terms of certainty.
Shakespeare has just the turn of phrase for it. "Poxy".
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(09-15-2026, 02:38 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: (09-14-2026, 06:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Simple - if you’re ahead of the ball from a forward pass and there aren’t 2 players between you and the goal you’re offside. Get rid of the bollocks of interfering, touching the ball or second phase because a defender touched the pass. I think it was Jack Charlton, may have been Cloughie, who said “if you’re on the pitch and not interfering with play then I’ll sub them off”.
The perfected off-side trap was a thing of beauty!
Bruno/Foden. 2 yellows or 2 reds. Or red for Foden, yellow for Bruno kicking him and a retrospective ban for feigning injury to get a player sent off.
Man United weren’t crying when Maguire accidentally handled the ball a couple of games back. VAR is a blessing and a curse depending upon if the decision goes your way or not. Goal line technology and duck the rest of it off.
Yes, but it has always been the case that you are offside in such a situation (apart from when it was three defenders and you could be offside in your own half) but it isn’t an offence to be offside. If it were, the ref would be blowing constantly. You are only penalised for interfering with play. The problem is in what is "interfering with play". Look at our goal against Leeds a lifetime ago for how the ref was right but loads thought otherwise. I agree that it has now become unknowable in terms of certainty.
Shakespeare has just the turn of phrase for it. "Poxy".
You can be locked up and thrown in jail for being offside these days.
Posts: 1,238
Threads: 76
Joined: Feb 2025
Reputation:
4
(09-15-2026, 03:49 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (09-15-2026, 02:38 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: (09-14-2026, 06:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Simple - if you’re ahead of the ball from a forward pass and there aren’t 2 players between you and the goal you’re offside. Get rid of the bollocks of interfering, touching the ball or second phase because a defender touched the pass. I think it was Jack Charlton, may have been Cloughie, who said “if you’re on the pitch and not interfering with play then I’ll sub them off”.
The perfected off-side trap was a thing of beauty!
Bruno/Foden. 2 yellows or 2 reds. Or red for Foden, yellow for Bruno kicking him and a retrospective ban for feigning injury to get a player sent off.
Man United weren’t crying when Maguire accidentally handled the ball a couple of games back. VAR is a blessing and a curse depending upon if the decision goes your way or not. Goal line technology and duck the rest of it off.
Yes, but it has always been the case that you are offside in such a situation (apart from when it was three defenders and you could be offside in your own half) but it isn’t an offence to be offside. If it were, the ref would be blowing constantly. You are only penalised for interfering with play. The problem is in what is "interfering with play". Look at our goal against Leeds a lifetime ago for how the ref was right but loads thought otherwise. I agree that it has now become unknowable in terms of certainty.
Shakespeare has just the turn of phrase for it. "Poxy".
You can be locked up and thrown in jail for being offside these days. Arf
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
They've just played the whole audio from VAR and it's absolutely damning. Unbelievably they never even mention Enzo Fernandez being offside in the entire review other than to say he didn't touch the ball. They were so occupied with Haaland being offside.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(09-15-2026, 04:55 PM)Peachy Wrote: They've just played the whole audio from VAR and it's absolutely damning. Unbelievably they never even mention Enzo Fernandez being offside in the entire review other than to say he didn't touch the ball. They were so occupied with Haaland being offside.
Similar happened to Liverpool a couple of years ago. VAR were so focussed on the one aspect they didn't even think about anything else.
Which can happen. After all, they are only human beings and can make mistakes.
Which is what VAR is supposed to prevent...
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
09-15-2026, 05:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-15-2026, 05:56 PM by Josh1873.)
VAR has caused more controversy than it's solved. All it's done is highlight what we already knew - officiating is corrupt.
|