Messi
#31
Signed?
Reply
#32
(06-17-2026, 12:39 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(06-17-2026, 12:24 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(06-17-2026, 12:19 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(06-17-2026, 12:07 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't particularly like the arguments about the state of the pitches or how the game was played in a different era. Are we really saying the best players of this generation wouldn't have adapted to those pitches or been able to produce their magic? That's nonsense.

Similarly, I see arguments going the other way, claiming that 'players are fitter and more professional now' - as if the likes of Best and Maradona would struggle to adapt to the modern game. If they were brought up as kids in today's system, they'd still come out on top.

It's an interesting debate, but I think it's wrong to use playing conditions as an argument for or against a player's raw talent. True geniuses adapt, no matter the era.

Really!

How would Messi have adapted if he'd had his legs broken like Maradona? The protection afforded in the modern game has allowed the right conditions for Messi to be tearing it up still at 38. He's be on a knee replacement now if he played in the 80s.
All Messi has had in his 20 years is a broken bone in his foot and a few hamstring tears etc.
Look at Laurie Cunningham who knows what he could have become if he'd not been physically battered by hatchet men.
We haven't even touched on medical science and the stewardship afforded to players now. Barcelona completely set up a fortress of all things to ensure Messi became what he is, from the moment he signed.
Maradona was left to go off the rails as it was a very different time. 
Messi is the greatest based on longetivity, being so good for 2 decades, but the game has changed so much. Sports science, better medical care, better stewardship, better pitches, better nutrition, better players around him.

I can appreciate Messi and Maradona equally, whilst realising the comparisons can only match to a certain standard.

I will never ever appreciate Maradona, not ever. He's the player version of Colin for me.

Don't know your age, but do you remember 1986? My guess is you don't.

He was flawed unquestionably, but that is part of what makes the legend around him so compelling. 

Messi is a wondrous talent and the comparisons as a player with Maradona makes so much sense, with them being the same nationality an added factor.

Messi is also a beneficiary of a modern age that has more video evidence.

Let's face it how many of us really know how good Pele was also. Only those well beyond pension age can testify, based on limited TV appearances.

True that. (re Pele).  TBH telly clips don't really settle things, they're sparse and from just one angle. I saw Charlton a number of times but I was a kid on a terrace packed with adults so really couldn't say if he was as good as everyone agreed. George Best's TV clips are mostly of him on his decline as MOTD used to get wiped. I think if Best had played for a different nation he would have been part of this thread. All said and done, it's Maradona for me, one of his world Cup wins came with a team that probably wouldn't have made the semis without him.
Reply
#33
Messi is such a wonderfully talented and gifted footballer that people overlook the fact he’s just as dedicated and hard working as Ronaldo, the latter has just built his brand more around being laser focused whereas Messi just makes everything look easy.

Ronaldo shades it for me, just because he’s done it in several leagues, whereas Messi (understandably) stayed in his comfort zone in Barcelona for his whole career (Ligue Un and MLS barely count), but both are absolutely the GOATs and I probably prefer watching Messi play.

That being said, Messi absolutely should have been sent off last night, and had it been an Algeria player they’d have been down to 10. Not that FIFA would dare send off Messi when he’s the golden boy of the MLS and deprive those high paying fans their chance to see him!
Reply
#34
(06-17-2026, 06:17 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Messi is such a wonderfully talented and gifted footballer that people overlook the fact he’s just as dedicated and hard working as Ronaldo, the latter has just built his brand more around being laser focused whereas Messi just makes everything look easy.

Ronaldo shades it for me, just because he’s done it in several leagues, whereas Messi (understandably) stayed in his comfort zone in Barcelona for his whole career (Ligue Un and MLS barely count), but both are absolutely the GOATs and I probably prefer watching Messi play.

That being said, Messi absolutely should have been sent off last night, and had it been an Algeria player they’d have been down to 10. Not that FIFA would dare send off Messi when he’s the golden boy of the MLS and deprive those high paying fans their chance to see him!

I don't ever get this argument?

So what? Plenty of top players stayed at one club for all or most of their careers. Ronaldo has also had a negative effect on teams, like derailing Solkjaers United rebuild which was working, Ronaldo turned it into his one man show, manager got sacked, United carried on making mistakes hunting for some magical answer.

Is Maldini a worse defender for staying at AC Milan? Of course not.

If anything, it shows how clutch Messi was to Barca, that as the squad evolved, he stayed crucial, different styles and strategies and he was phenomenal throughout.
Reply
#35
(06-17-2026, 06:27 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-17-2026, 06:17 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Messi is such a wonderfully talented and gifted footballer that people overlook the fact he’s just as dedicated and hard working as Ronaldo, the latter has just built his brand more around being laser focused whereas Messi just makes everything look easy.

Ronaldo shades it for me, just because he’s done it in several leagues, whereas Messi (understandably) stayed in his comfort zone in Barcelona for his whole career (Ligue Un and MLS barely count), but both are absolutely the GOATs and I probably prefer watching Messi play.

That being said, Messi absolutely should have been sent off last night, and had it been an Algeria player they’d have been down to 10. Not that FIFA would dare send off Messi when he’s the golden boy of the MLS and deprive those high paying fans their chance to see him!

I don't ever get this argument?

So what? Plenty of top players stayed at one club for all or most of their careers. Ronaldo has also had a negative effect on teams, like derailing Solkjaers United rebuild which was working, Ronaldo turned it into his one man show, manager got sacked, United carried on making mistakes hunting for some magical answer.

Is Maldini a worse defender for staying at AC Milan? Of course not.

If anything, it shows how clutch Messi was to Barca, that as the squad evolved, he stayed crucial, different styles and strategies and he was phenomenal throughout.

Absolute madness argument isn’t it.

Messi really would have struggled at Everton or Burnley.
Reply
#36
My daughter’s infant class, are currently having this argument.
Reply
#37
Ee ay cumin.
Reply
#38
(06-17-2026, 06:27 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-17-2026, 06:17 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Messi is such a wonderfully talented and gifted footballer that people overlook the fact he’s just as dedicated and hard working as Ronaldo, the latter has just built his brand more around being laser focused whereas Messi just makes everything look easy.

Ronaldo shades it for me, just because he’s done it in several leagues, whereas Messi (understandably) stayed in his comfort zone in Barcelona for his whole career (Ligue Un and MLS barely count), but both are absolutely the GOATs and I probably prefer watching Messi play.

That being said, Messi absolutely should have been sent off last night, and had it been an Algeria player they’d have been down to 10. Not that FIFA would dare send off Messi when he’s the golden boy of the MLS and deprive those high paying fans their chance to see him!

I don't ever get this argument?

So what? Plenty of top players stayed at one club for all or most of their careers. Ronaldo has also had a negative effect on teams, like derailing Solkjaers United rebuild which was working, Ronaldo turned it into his one man show, manager got sacked, United carried on making mistakes hunting for some magical answer.

Is Maldini a worse defender for staying at AC Milan? Of course not.

If anything, it shows how clutch Messi was to Barca, that as the squad evolved, he stayed crucial, different styles and strategies and he was phenomenal throughout.

I’m not arguing, I’ve simply said I prefer Ronaldo as he has played and performed in multiple big leagues. It doesn’t make a Messi a lesser player, they can’t both be my favourite so I have to choose something wholly subjective to decide. It’s like arguing why one supermodel is more attractive than the other because she’s get better tits and you prefer tits. It doesn’t mean the ones with cracking arses don’t have valid merits.
Reply
#39
(06-17-2026, 07:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My daughter’s infant class, are currently having this argument.

Shame as surely they should be moaning about politics instead like any good football messageboard should.

The World Cup is on and a light-hearted debate about the merits of different players from different eras getting nostalgic over current players over the tournaments of our youth is only to be expected.

No one can ever prove who is the best in any era, but it's a bit of nice distraction as so much online stuff is quite intense now.
Reply
#40
We have been lucky to have Ronaldo and Messi vying for the modern day greatest title. Hard to split but just about Ronaldo for me.

The greatest in my lifetime was Maradona. That period between 86 and 90 for Argentina and Napoli was remarkable, pretty much carrying both teams to success with otherwise average players.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)