01-30-2026, 12:02 AM
(01-29-2026, 10:55 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:(01-28-2026, 12:46 AM)Jacko Wrote:(01-27-2026, 06:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(01-27-2026, 05:12 PM)baggiedave85 Wrote: After being out for best part of 4 months we really shouldnt be relying on Williams at all...mind you I would sooner try and get Gilchrist out on loan and use Williams as RWB as Gilchrist doesnt suit that role and his confidence is on the floor
There's still a role for AG in our back 3 IMO - especially with Phillips looking so rusty. He's one of the only defenders we have capable of playing a higher line, and he's one of the only ones who is aggressive in coming and closing his man and pressurising early - something ER's teams have done a lot! I wouldn't be surprised to see him in the line-up soon.
Not for me, he's been miles off it every time he's played. He's a statistics only player at this stage of his career. Perhaps he'd look better at RCB, but he's too small especially given we've got a small weak keeper behind him imo and we have better options.
Jacko, he's 6 ft tall. Are you Pulis, with an Alton Towers style height gauge for every position in the team? Also he's only just 22. Yes, he might turn out to be a poor signing, but we don't know yet with the limited minutes he's played. You seem to delight in writing players off at the earliest opportunity.
He's absolutely shit. I was being generous in my last post. I can tell you if a player is any good after watching them for about half an hour. I'd had my fill at Watford after about 10 minutes. Only confirmed by the cup game at Swansea.
Regards his height, it was in response to him playing centre back. Unless you're a top talent like Baresi or Cannavaro, you need to he physically imposing.

