5 game report
#31
SW4Baggie - That's an excellent post. Really well put and balanced. I think the 6.5 score is fair. I'd have said 7/10 myself, but that's splitting hairs. I agree with most of what you say, not all, I'm not that nice, but most.
Reply
#32
(09-14-2025, 11:40 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: SW4Baggie - That's an excellent post. Really well put and balanced. I think the 6.5 score is fair. I'd have said 7/10 myself, but that's splitting hairs. I agree with most of what you say, not all, I'm not that nice, but most.

My first thought was 7 - 2 points per game is a decent start - but the more I thought about the issues, the less I thought 7 was fair. If we’d beaten Derby and lost at Stoke it would have probably been a 7,  but our inability to break down teams is too big of a concern to ignore for me.

Our next 5 games are much more challenging, but we should see more attacking intent from the opponents.  If we can come out of the next 5 games with 7-8 points I’d say we are about par for where we should be, but if not we’ll start to see the Derby and Pompey results as silly posts dropped.
Reply
#33
Good post by SW4, and it’s noticeable we’ve won by a goal, lost by a goal or drawn. Most of the games could have gone either way. I don’t think we’ll get battered this season ( overall good defenders at defending with a good structure) and we won’t batter anyone ( little creativity, pace or natural goal scorers ) the manager is making the best of his current resources and that’s fair enough. At the start of the season most of us were saying we were going to need to transition under a new manager with the team being refreshed under the scrutiny of financial limitations. We need to accept where we are, which is at the start of a significant rebuild and that it’s going to take time.
Reply
#34
Another good post.
Reply
#35
2ppg is good, but as stated we haven't played anyone likely to be in the top 10 yet.

Also it's going to be a long slog if Bany turns out to be shit, based on what I've read last couple of days. Big Grin
Reply
#36
(09-14-2025, 11:57 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Good post by SW4, and it’s noticeable we’ve won by a goal, lost by a goal or drawn. Most of the games could have gone either way.  I don’t think we’ll get battered this season ( overall good defenders at defending with a good structure) and we won’t batter anyone ( little creativity, pace or natural goal scorers ) the manager is making the best of his current resources and that’s fair enough.  At the start of the season most of us were saying we were going to need to transition under a new manager with the team being refreshed under the scrutiny of financial limitations.  We need to accept where we are, which is at the start of a significant rebuild and that it’s going to take time.

Yup agreed - I think we have to look at the money being spent by clubs around us which is sizeable. 

We are one of 10 teams fighting for 2 or 3 playoff spots, and like the other 9 we have weaknesses. My rating of the board and coach will be how well they minimise the impact of those weaknesses, and I think for me, we could have done a little more this window… but 5 games isn’t enough to judge. Let’s regroup after game week 10.
Reply
#37
We've got 3 really tough games coming up now against Middlesbrough, Leicester and Norwich. I think after them it'll be a bit of a fairer time to assess where we are. Mason has certainly had a good start. I feel he's very much more of a Carlos-style manager. What is pleasing is the side looks well organised and where there have been any failings it's not been a clueless Bruce/Mowbrayesque mess.

I think we're in for a season of relatively low entertainment. I think we will see quite a few 1-0s/0-1s. The squad Mason has been given really does have its strength in the defensive areas so you can't criticise him for basing everything on a tight backline. The biggest concern is where the goals will be coming from and be created by. There is huge pressure on Price and Johnston this season to be our main creative outlets. I'm still not sure yet really quite what sort of player Collyer is from his brief cameos. Ilung Junior looked very keen yesterday but needs to be played on the left. He simply doesn't have a right foot. Christ knows when Bany will actually be fit or if he's actually any good. We simply don't know.

It's depressing to still see the occasional post mentioning 'when Dike's fit'. I'm not criticising anyone but it just goes to show how we've not really addressed our forward options over the last few years. Admittedly the club has had a lot of areas to sort out but we look badly short of options. I really like Heggebo but think we need to be combining him with A.N. Other (I guess Maja) for a 60 min or so swapover in the the way we did with Dike and BTA a while back.

I think it's going to be a tough season. The overall quality of the division looks better balanced out from the bits I've seen so far this year. Some of the mid table dross definitely look to improved though the relegated sides really haven't hit the ground running at all though I feel Ipswich surely have the quality to surge up the table.
Reply
#38
I think the 6.5 is harsh.

Even just based on points accrued 10 of 15, means it should be at least a 6.666 Big Grin
Reply
#39
(09-14-2025, 12:58 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: We've got 3 really tough games coming up now against Middlesbrough, Leicester and Norwich. I think after them it'll be a bit of a fairer time to assess where we are. Mason has certainly had a good start. I feel he's very much more of a Carlos-style manager. What is pleasing is the side looks well organised and where there have been any failings it's not been a clueless Bruce/Mowbrayesque mess.

I think we're in for a season of relatively low entertainment. I think we will see quite a few 1-0s/0-1s. The squad Mason has been given really does have its strength in the defensive areas so you can't criticise him for basing everything on a tight backline. The biggest concern is where the goals will be coming from and be created by. There is huge pressure on Price and Johnston this season to be our main creative outlets. I'm still not sure yet really quite what sort of player Collyer is from his brief cameos. Ilung Junior looked very keen yesterday but needs to be played on the left. He simply doesn't have a right foot. Christ knows when Bany will actually be fit or if he's actually any good. We simply don't know.

It's depressing to still see the occasional post mentioning 'when Dike's fit'. I'm not criticising anyone but it just goes to show how we've not really addressed our forward options over the last few years. Admittedly the club has had a lot of areas to sort out but we look badly short of options. I really like Heggebo but think we need to be combining him with A.N. Other (I guess Maja) for a 60 min or so swapover in the the way we did with Dike and BTA a while back.

I think it's going to be a tough season. The overall quality of the division looks better balanced out from the bits I've seen so far this year. Some of the mid table dross definitely look to improved though the relegated sides really haven't hit the ground running at all though I feel Ipswich surely have the quality to surge up the table.

I think one of the other things is that I'm just a bit bored of this solid, defensive football. Since relegation, it's all we've had. Val was aggressive but shite on the eye, Bruce was clueless, Carlos was pragmatic but successful... Now we have Mason and again it's disciplined, controlled, workmanlike football. I understand the need to be defensively resolute, but fuck me, is it too much to ask for some fucking entertainment for  a season?
Reply
#40
My way of looking at it is that it’s a good wake-up call at the right time. Defensively we are fine in my view. The problems begin where games are won and lost - midfield. Expecting the Mowatt and Moulumby combo to bear fruit is a naivety, Price is being impeded by their collective ability to all tread on each other, and Heggebo is simply too goal shy. Yesterday’s set-up was perfect for an away game against a good opposition - but a home one against poor? No. It all fell apart in the final third.

I’m confident Mason will reflect upon all of this, but we could have played all night yesterday and not scored. Goals win games - not canny defensive signings alone.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)