15 pence a mile.
#31
Just let the Government install tracking devices in your personal transport, and then sell your data to Blackrock. It'll make the weather gooder.
Reply
#32
(09-21-2024, 12:30 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-21-2024, 12:24 PM)Hudds1 Wrote:
(09-21-2024, 12:08 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-21-2024, 11:50 AM)Hudds1 Wrote:
(09-21-2024, 11:34 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Well yeah, but fuel duty is the kind of pay per mile you describe, and road tax is a standing charge.

An average motorist pays way more fuel duty in 12 months than road tax, so it’s kind of the system we already have.
excise duty on road fuel is actually roughly a third of the cost of the product at the pumps.

It’s over a third. With VAT, taxation is over half the pump price. Has been higher.

fuel duty is still effectively pay per mile, and the average mileage motorist pays way more fuel duty thsn road tax overall.

Excise duty is not VAT.  Excise duty has been been frozen donkeys' years (reduced last time).  Excise duty is, in theoretical economic terms both a passed on cost to the final consumer and an inherent cost within the pricing (although that's where the theory falls down).  Broken down on a litre at say £1.35, the VAT fraction gives us 22.5 pence based on the value of the fuel cost (60p, plus 53p for the duty). Duty has been a lesser cost pf the product for years but the VAT take has increased with the higher wholesale costs plus margin.

Obviously excise duty isn’t vat! But the total taxation means we already have a sort of pay per mile system built into paying for fuel. That’s my point.

And taxation is over half of fuel price. When I said taxation has been a higher percentage, I mean overall of the price at the pump.

https://www.racfoundation.org/data/perce...the%20duty.
Beep beep - reversing
(see what I did there?)
Reply
#33
Why would any government want to get rid of road tax. 80% of it goes directly to the Government 20% invested into roads.
Just increase more and more. Now they've hoodwinked people into buying EV make them pay road tax as well. Should help cover the shortfall in women's dresses.
Reply
#34
(09-21-2024, 12:18 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Makes no sense to me whatsoever.
Logistics of monitoring is impossible.
Just makes sense to load the price of fuel to cover the costs. I suspect a increase in fuel duty of 10p a litre and EVs start pay road tax as they use the roads. That will bring a few billion into the chancellors pocket.
The 15p a mile charge would be £4-50 for a 30 mile trip. Never gonna happen IMO.

SHut up
Reply
#35
(09-21-2024, 01:04 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Why would any government want to get rid of road tax. 80% of it goes directly to the Government 20% invested into roads.
Just increase more and more. Now they've hoodwinked people into buying EV make them pay road tax as well. Should help cover the shortfall in women's dresses.

There is no road tax as such, it was abolished in 1935. It’s an emissions tax.Anyone who pays any kind of tax ,through earnings etc., pays for the upkeep of the roads . ( even if you don’t drive!)
Reply
#36
(09-21-2024, 01:05 PM)Hudds1 Wrote:
(09-21-2024, 12:18 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Makes no sense to me whatsoever.
Logistics of monitoring is impossible.
Just makes sense to load the price of fuel to cover the costs. I suspect a increase in fuel duty of 10p a litre and EVs start pay road tax as they use the roads. That will bring a few billion into the chancellors pocket.
The 15p a mile charge would be £4-50 for a 30 mile trip. Never gonna happen IMO.

SHut up

Oooo
Reply
#37
(09-21-2024, 01:04 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Why would any government want to get rid of road tax. 80% of it goes directly to the Government 20% invested into roads.
Just increase more and more. Now they've hoodwinked people into buying EV make them pay road tax as well. Should help cover the shortfall in women's dresses.

Similar to when everyone was pushed into diesels a few years ago.
Reply
#38
I couldn’t afford to buy an EV even if I wanted to but I do feel people have been mislead about “not having to pay road tax if you buy an EV”.

I wouldn’t mind paying per mile as such but I really can’t see it being anywhere near 15p a mile. That would almost price me out of going into and driving for work (even being able to claim business miles I barely break even as it is)!
Reply
#39
This could be workable if they were to scrap duty on fuel and road tax and replace it with a per mile charge.

No idea how to actually make it work though unless they change the MOT to every year (i.e. Remove the exemption for brand new cars and classic vehicles) and generate a bill based on last year's miles driven.

A system that generates the most revenue from the heaviest users seems logical at first glance, but those that live in rural areas (particularly the rural poor) could see this as unfair.

Transparency between revenue gathered for whatever 'road tax' is gathered and how it is spent on the roads is also needed as well as a think about how this is divided up across the country as should the most frequently used roads get the greatest share of the revenue? If so, what methodology do you put in place to measure this without adding to the costs of the project?

Overall, there aren't any easy answers or universally agreeable solutions here, but something needs to be done as there are really significant issues to tackle.
Reply
#40
(09-21-2024, 03:08 PM)spudgun Wrote: This could be workable if they were to scrap duty on fuel and road tax and replace it with a per mile charge.

No idea how to actually make it work though unless they change the MOT to every year (i.e. Remove the exemption for brand new cars and classic vehicles) and generate a bill based on last year's miles driven.

A system that generates the most revenue from the heaviest users seems logical at first glance, but those that live in rural areas (particularly the rural poor) could see this as unfair.

Transparency between revenue gathered for whatever 'road tax' is gathered and how it is spent on the roads is also needed as well as a think about how this is divided up across the country as should the most frequently used roads get the greatest share of the revenue? If so, what methodology do you put in place to measure this without adding to the costs of the project?

Overall, there aren't any easy answers or universally agreeable solutions here, but something needs to be done as there are really significant issues to tackle.

It would cost the same to drive a 30 year old diesel as it would a brand new EV.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: