Would we be any worse off...
#31
(04-19-2019, 05:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote: This thread was started when we was losing I assume? Shock!

We are showing some really character lately coming behind from losing positions. We’re in good form and our best players are hitting form right at an important time.

Shans exceeding expectations, let’s get behind him.

He sure is. 15 points in 7 games.
Reply
#32
(04-19-2019, 03:22 PM)Duffers Wrote: Had we kept Moore?

I don't think he'd have won 5 in 7 do you?

And him and Smith had lost the plot and the dressing room - fact!
Reply
#33
Bottom line is that neither Shan nor Moore is the answer.

Shan has played the best striker in the division as a striker. It's not rocket science, but this eluded Big Dave, sadly.

DM is rightly a legend here, but he was appointed on the basis of not being as shit as Pardew. This wasn't hard. I wouldn't be as shit as Pardew.

We then relied on Harvey Barnes as a flat track bully to carry us through the first half of the season, and, despite conceding a shit load of goals by defenders thinking they were Beckenbauer, it worked.

Once we lost him, DM was out of ideas. Lovely man. Great man manager. Tactically, naive would be putting it nicely.

Shan has simply done what anyone with tactical nous would do, and played Gayle as a striker with sensible options behind him. Telling your defenders to not piss around at the back and playing your best striker as a striker rather than a left midfielder isn't exactly Shankly-esque.

At any point, if we could have a manager who was the best option, rather than the cheapest best option, that would be fucking lovely.
Reply
#34
(04-19-2019, 04:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Disagree, we were dreadful at home for months and looking like falling away with no idea how to halt the bad form. Fans can’t have it both ways, they can’t moan that games aren’t entertaining ad-nausea and thho helps out his defensive occasionallyen when games finish 4-1, 3-2 bemoan how we play.

Let’s be honest fans want clean sheets, lovely football and goals galore or they moan.

For me clean sheets are a must,lovely football would be nice,goals galore not so much.Just a goalkeeper who helps out his defense occasionally and I would be positively euphoric
Reply
#35
(04-19-2019, 07:31 PM)Mish Wrote: Bottom line is that neither Shan nor Moore is the answer.

Shan has played the best striker in the division as a striker.  It's not rocket science, but this eluded Big Dave, sadly.

DM is rightly a legend here, but he was appointed on the basis of not being as shit as Pardew.  This wasn't hard.  I wouldn't be as shit as Pardew.

We then relied on Harvey Barnes as a flat track bully to carry us through the first half of the season, and, despite conceding a shit load of goals by defenders thinking they were Beckenbauer, it worked.

Once we lost him, DM was out of ideas.  Lovely man.  Great man manager.  Tactically, naive would be putting it nicely.

Shan has simply done what anyone with tactical nous would do, and played Gayle as a striker with sensible options behind him.  Telling your defenders to not piss around at the back and playing your best striker as a striker rather than a left midfielder isn't exactly Shankly-esque.

At any point, if we could have a manager who was the best option, rather than the cheapest best option, that would be fucking lovely.

Would another, more expensive manager have yielded more points at this stage?
Reply
#36
(04-19-2019, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:31 PM)Mish Wrote: Bottom line is that neither Shan nor Moore is the answer.

Shan has played the best striker in the division as a striker.  It's not rocket science, but this eluded Big Dave, sadly.

DM is rightly a legend here, but he was appointed on the basis of not being as shit as Pardew.  This wasn't hard.  I wouldn't be as shit as Pardew.

We then relied on Harvey Barnes as a flat track bully to carry us through the first half of the season, and, despite conceding a shit load of goals by defenders thinking they were Beckenbauer, it worked.

Once we lost him, DM was out of ideas.  Lovely man.  Great man manager.  Tactically, naive would be putting it nicely.

Shan has simply done what anyone with tactical nous would do, and played Gayle as a striker with sensible options behind him.  Telling your defenders to not piss around at the back and playing your best striker as a striker rather than a left midfielder isn't exactly Shankly-esque.

At any point, if we could have a manager who was the best option, rather than the cheapest best option, that would be fucking lovely.

Would another, more expensive manager have yielded more points at this stage?

A more experienced manager may have, which costs more.  So I'm thinking yes.
Reply
#37
(04-19-2019, 07:35 PM)Mish Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:31 PM)Mish Wrote: Bottom line is that neither Shan nor Moore is the answer.

Shan has played the best striker in the division as a striker.  It's not rocket science, but this eluded Big Dave, sadly.

DM is rightly a legend here, but he was appointed on the basis of not being as shit as Pardew.  This wasn't hard.  I wouldn't be as shit as Pardew.

We then relied on Harvey Barnes as a flat track bully to carry us through the first half of the season, and, despite conceding a shit load of goals by defenders thinking they were Beckenbauer, it worked.

Once we lost him, DM was out of ideas.  Lovely man.  Great man manager.  Tactically, naive would be putting it nicely.

Shan has simply done what anyone with tactical nous would do, and played Gayle as a striker with sensible options behind him.  Telling your defenders to not piss around at the back and playing your best striker as a striker rather than a left midfielder isn't exactly Shankly-esque.

At any point, if we could have a manager who was the best option, rather than the cheapest best option, that would be fucking lovely.

Would another, more expensive manager have yielded more points at this stage?

A more experienced manager may have, which costs more.  So I'm thinking yes.

That suggests we would have won all of our games or at least drawn the two we lost? I think that’s a tall order for any manager, not impossible but I don’t see anything to suggest Shan has made mistakes that have cost us points, quite the contrary. 

Pardew was experienced for example. It’s ability that is the most important not how many games you’ve managed imo and who is to say Shan cannot be a successful manager? I’ve seen more tactical awareness since he took the reigns than I have most of the season.
Reply
#38
(04-19-2019, 07:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:35 PM)Mish Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:31 PM)Mish Wrote: Bottom line is that neither Shan nor Moore is the answer.

Shan has played the best striker in the division as a striker.  It's not rocket science, but this eluded Big Dave, sadly.

DM is rightly a legend here, but he was appointed on the basis of not being as shit as Pardew.  This wasn't hard.  I wouldn't be as shit as Pardew.

We then relied on Harvey Barnes as a flat track bully to carry us through the first half of the season, and, despite conceding a shit load of goals by defenders thinking they were Beckenbauer, it worked.

Once we lost him, DM was out of ideas.  Lovely man.  Great man manager.  Tactically, naive would be putting it nicely.

Shan has simply done what anyone with tactical nous would do, and played Gayle as a striker with sensible options behind him.  Telling your defenders to not piss around at the back and playing your best striker as a striker rather than a left midfielder isn't exactly Shankly-esque.

At any point, if we could have a manager who was the best option, rather than the cheapest best option, that would be fucking lovely.

Would another, more expensive manager have yielded more points at this stage?

A more experienced manager may have, which costs more.  So I'm thinking yes.

That suggests we would have won all of our games or at least drawn the two we lost? I think that’s a tall order for any manager, not impossible but I don’t see anything to suggest Shan has made mistakes that have cost us points, quite the contrary. 

Pardew was experienced for example. It’s ability that is the most important not how many games you’ve managed imo and who is to say Shan cannot be a successful manager? I’ve seen more tactical awareness since he took the reigns than I have most of the season.

Here’s a question for you Derek H, if we get promoted under Shan would you give him the job on a permanent basis?
Reply
#39
(04-19-2019, 07:49 PM)Albion Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:35 PM)Mish Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:31 PM)Mish Wrote: Bottom line is that neither Shan nor Moore is the answer.

Shan has played the best striker in the division as a striker.  It's not rocket science, but this eluded Big Dave, sadly.

DM is rightly a legend here, but he was appointed on the basis of not being as shit as Pardew.  This wasn't hard.  I wouldn't be as shit as Pardew.

We then relied on Harvey Barnes as a flat track bully to carry us through the first half of the season, and, despite conceding a shit load of goals by defenders thinking they were Beckenbauer, it worked.

Once we lost him, DM was out of ideas.  Lovely man.  Great man manager.  Tactically, naive would be putting it nicely.

Shan has simply done what anyone with tactical nous would do, and played Gayle as a striker with sensible options behind him.  Telling your defenders to not piss around at the back and playing your best striker as a striker rather than a left midfielder isn't exactly Shankly-esque.

At any point, if we could have a manager who was the best option, rather than the cheapest best option, that would be fucking lovely.

Would another, more expensive manager have yielded more points at this stage?

A more experienced manager may have, which costs more.  So I'm thinking yes.

That suggests we would have won all of our games or at least drawn the two we lost? I think that’s a tall order for any manager, not impossible but I don’t see anything to suggest Shan has made mistakes that have cost us points, quite the contrary. 

Pardew was experienced for example. It’s ability that is the most important not how many games you’ve managed imo and who is to say Shan cannot be a successful manager? I’ve seen more tactical awareness since he took the reigns than I have most of the season.

Here’s a question for you Derek H, if we get promoted under Shan would you give him the job on a permanent basis?

I don’t know, it would be a big decision given what happened with DM but the opportunity for a more proven manager would present itself with the larger budget, as would time to find that person if we were promoted. At present I don’t think there was a better option than Shan no matter how risky the appointment was / is.
Reply
#40
(04-19-2019, 07:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:49 PM)Albion Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:35 PM)Mish Wrote:
(04-19-2019, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Would another, more expensive manager have yielded more points at this stage?

A more experienced manager may have, which costs more.  So I'm thinking yes.

That suggests we would have won all of our games or at least drawn the two we lost? I think that’s a tall order for any manager, not impossible but I don’t see anything to suggest Shan has made mistakes that have cost us points, quite the contrary. 

Pardew was experienced for example. It’s ability that is the most important not how many games you’ve managed imo and who is to say Shan cannot be a successful manager? I’ve seen more tactical awareness since he took the reigns than I have most of the season.

Here’s a question for you Derek H, if we get promoted under Shan would you give him the job on a permanent basis?

I don’t know, it would be a big decision given what happened with DM but the opportunity for a more proven manager would present itself with the larger budget, as would time to find that person if we were promoted. At present I don’t think there was a better option than Shan no matter how risky the appointment was / is.

Fair answer. I like Shan. Think he speaks really well. Strikes me as a very coherent coach.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)