Ratings
#31
I like fellows but his defensive work needs to sharpen up on ....there no 3 was wide open numerous of times .
Reply
#32
I agreed that Manning was wide open at times but i think that was more to do with our system in that Fellows and Mikey pulled in to help shut down their playing out of the back. Fellows had Manning on toast when he attacked him as did Mikey with Walker-Peters, thought both of their full backs were good coming forward but struggled when we attacked them. Kudos to Carlos.
Reply
#33
(05-13-2024, 06:44 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: I like fellows but his defensive work needs to sharpen up on ....there no 3 was wide open numerous of times .

This was a tactical challenge rather than anything TF was doing wrong I think. 

They overloaded us in wide areas using their left/right hand CBs. Which meant in those wide areas we always had 3 players to mark. This is why I think Carlos dropped us into a 541 second half which took awya that numerical advantage but stopped us breaking out as well. We then started to manage our transitions a little better, especially through Grady and MJ who were tucked in as wide midfielders

It was a good tactical battle between the 2 coaches. But one I think Carlos won.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#34
(05-12-2024, 11:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-12-2024, 06:40 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Largely agree with Slice marks.  Thought we were excellent for first 15 and edged 2nd half.  For an open team - they took few risks. Thought we had better chances and deserved the win. Marks

Palmer 7.5. Largely untroubled but great save.  Distribution was good - could of communicated better a couple of times to prevent corners

DF 8. Excellent today and kept some good players v quiet.  Got crucial touches and blocks in that minimised their chances.

Townsend 7.5.  Like last week, aggressive and defended well. Might have supported MJ a touch more but won a number of corners

Bart 8.  The best game I’ve seen from him for a while. Kept AA v quiet and defended long balls well. Should of done better with headers  Less comfortable against subs

Kipre 7.5.  Solid and physical against their strikers. Got done couple of times by Mara. Might of done better with set piece chances

Okay 6.5. Solid first 45 but Leggy again 2nd half when their no 4 kept breaking. Won key defensive headers from their corners - that were all on the money

Mowatt. 7.5.  Quiet first half but got on the ball second. Good energy and barely gave it away. Might have got a few more shots off

Grady 6.5. Decent shift off the ball but didn’t move it quickly enough when on it. Got crowded a lot when a quick layoff was needed. Should of done better with both chances

Tom 7.  Some excellent crosses and cutbacks that should have been finished off. Disciplined against Manning - just got muscled a couple of times

MJ 6.5.  Good outlet first half but really wasteful with end product. Better after the break and central to our good spell. Overhit crosses even then however

BTA. 6. V difficult role in the heat against 3 c halves. In fairness, when he did get possession we were slow to support and he lost it. Just needs to make more runs when we do have it - just to make the pitch bigger

Jed 6. Good running and closing but limited impact. Was raging on Friday after being left out

Swift 6.  Tidy on the ball but no penetration with passes or end product. Need more from him

Semi 6.5. Solidified us after their attacking changes and used ball well. Bart may be a doubt Friday

Yann 6.5. Has looked sluggish but v aggressive in his cameo and put himself about and pressed really well

Reach 5.5. Slotted in ok for CT. Loses a mark for that ridiculous volley

These ratings are closer to how I saw it. I'm in a minority of one in that I'd put Kipre higher than Bartley. I base this on Kipre's reading of the game made his partner's job easier. Bartley won a good few headers in their box though and credit to him for that.

Not far off my thoughts Manc.

Before the game I would have been happy with the draw given our recent performances, record against RM and Southampton's squad vs ours, but as the match wore on, it felt a lot more like a chance we'd failed to take.

Thought it was a cagey and tactical affair, and despite being goalless, was a largely entertaining match. For all the piss taking of Martin, I thought he stood up well to CC and the two of them spent 90 minutes tweaking and changing systems to try an edge a tight game whilst also countering their opposite number's latest idea.

Really pleasing was how fast we came out of the blocks, we'd clearly learnt from the reverse earlier this season and weren't going to let them take the initiative, however for all our huffing and puffing, it didn't feel like we were going to score the early goal and then when Saints pushed their wingbacks higher and wider we were unable to have the same early joy we'd enjoyed down the flanks. 

Overall plenty of positives to take, and on balance of play I felt we ought to have edged it, as whilst the stats may have leaned slightly in Saints' favour, our final ball being so lacking meant that we didn't get the number of shots off, or even create the number of goal scoring opportunities we probably ought have. At the other end our whole back line were supurb... Bartley deserving special mention for a colossal display, whilst Kipre looked composed and classy. Really hope this isn't the last we see of him at the Hawthorns. 

The problems however for me came in middle. Grady was having to come a lot deeper due to Okay often dropping in as a third CB, and whilst Mowatt was his usual bag of energy, he didn't have his usual impact on the ball due to doing the running of 2 players. This lack of midfield meant that BTA was left probably more isolated than I've seen him all season, and with the wingers being forced to do a lot more defensive work than usual, he just wasn't fast enough on the ground or in his head to be well positioned on the occasions we did get the ball into dangerous areas.

Palmer - 7 - one great save, otherwise comfortable afternoon's work - 1 clean sheet down, 2 more to go!

Townsend - 7.5 - given a tough afternoon but stood up to it well... looked absolutely shot when subbed off.
Kipre - 8 - another excellent showing - used the ball very well too.
Bartley - 8.5 MOTM - won absolutely everything in the air, defensively outstanding - feared the worst when he started clutching his hamstring
Furlong - 7.5 - shame he didn't get a better connection on that chance - think it was an easier finish than it looked at the time

Okay - 6.5 - Sacrificed a lot of his game due to dropping into the third CB role for spells. We really missed his tenacity in the middle for me
Mowatt - 7 - Stuck well to a difficult task against Downs, Aribo and Smallbone - lots of running prevented a team that passes most sides to death taking control of the middle.

Johnston - 7 - Good defensive work, broke with purpose but was well managed by their CB/WB - wasn't allowed to cut in with his usual ease
Grady - 7 - anonymous first half, but as ever heavily involved in our best chances - again should have scored one of his 2 attempts.
Fellows - 6.5 - Surprised he stayed on as long as he did - struggled against their left hand side - Manning and Stephens are quality players with lots of experience for this level. 

BTA - 5.5 - 7/10 for effort, 4/10 for output - he tries hard, and didn't get the best of service today but he didn't help himself either. As much as I like Asante, you won't win promotion with him as your number one striker.

---

Subs were all much of a muchness really - 6.5s all round!

---

CC - 8 - did enough to win a tough game, and kept up with Martin for 90 minutes - far more nervous for Friday than I was yesterday's game as it feels like we may actually have a chance of going through this tie now!!!
Reply
#35
Thought that the ninety minutes summed up our season quite nicely.

Well drilled, organised, worked really hard and did pretty much everything that could be asked of them without having the required quality in the opposing penalty area to stick the ball in the net.

I certainly wouldn't be marking any player less than a six as they all ran themselves into the ground.
Reply
#36
(05-13-2024, 08:08 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Thought that the ninety minutes summed up our season quite nicely.

Well drilled, organised, worked really hard and did pretty much everything that could be asked of them without having the required quality in the opposing penalty area to stick the ball in the net.

I certainly wouldn't be marking any player less than a six as they all ran themselves into the ground.

Agree with that Ted, was a solid performance and, despite their clear quality, we contained them quite comfortably. 100% for effort across the board.
After 47 games we are pretty much saying the same as game 1, in that we are a decent striker short and that is telling.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: