Sunaks plan for “sick note culture “
#31
(04-22-2024, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well firstly stop wasting millions of pounds and making people’s lives a misery by constant reassessment of people who are by every definition never going to be able to work.

Secondly pay full time unpaid carers a full time living wage that means they don’t have to jump through hoops just to save the country millions in social care. In short the DWP and government need to think pragmatically and also have some morals because currently they are operating in a moral vacuum.

Thirdly don’t scrap schemes that are set-up to help the disabled back into work at the very same time as they making it harder for them to recieve benefits.

Go after tax fraud and avoidance it costs the country far more but I grant you it’s not as easy to scapegoat them as it is the disabled and ill.

Force big companies to offer better mental and occupational health support given the draconian way some of them operate it’s no wonder people are struggling physically and mentally.

The government to stop being xxxxs and creating a culture of blame and vindictiveness towards the disabled and those with mental health problems. How does that help with them? It helps the government because they can convince the stupid, nasty and gullible it’s someone else’s fault and not theirs the country is a complete mess.

Stop wasting millions on PR exercises like the Rwanda nonsense.

Aside from companies providing better support (most large companies now do) how will any of that get a single person signed off sick back into work?
Reply
#32
(04-22-2024, 02:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well firstly stop wasting millions of pounds and making people’s lives a misery by constant reassessment of people who are by every definition never going to be able to work.

Secondly pay full time unpaid carers a full time living wage that means they don’t have to jump through hoops just to save the country millions in social care. In short the DWP and government need to think pragmatically and also have some morals because currently they are operating in a moral vacuum.

Thirdly don’t scrap schemes that are set-up to help the disabled back into work at the very same time as they making it harder for them to recieve benefits.

Go after tax fraud and avoidance it costs the country far more but I grant you it’s not as easy to scapegoat them as it is the disabled and ill.

Force big companies to offer better mental and occupational health support given the draconian way some of them operate it’s no wonder people are struggling physically and mentally.

The government to stop being xxxxs and creating a culture of blame and vindictiveness towards the disabled and those with mental health problems. How does that help with them? It helps the government because they can convince the stupid, nasty and gullible it’s someone else’s fault and not theirs the country is a complete mess.

Stop wasting millions on PR exercises like the Rwanda nonsense.

Aside from companies providing better support (most large companies now do) how will any of that get a single person signed off sick back into work?

If someone is sick they're not meant to be at work, that's the point?
Reply
#33
(04-22-2024, 02:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well firstly stop wasting millions of pounds and making people’s lives a misery by constant reassessment of people who are by every definition never going to be able to work.

Secondly pay full time unpaid carers a full time living wage that means they don’t have to jump through hoops just to save the country millions in social care. In short the DWP and government need to think pragmatically and also have some morals because currently they are operating in a moral vacuum.

Thirdly don’t scrap schemes that are set-up to help the disabled back into work at the very same time as they making it harder for them to recieve benefits.

Go after tax fraud and avoidance it costs the country far more but I grant you it’s not as easy to scapegoat them as it is the disabled and ill.

Force big companies to offer better mental and occupational health support given the draconian way some of them operate it’s no wonder people are struggling physically and mentally.

The government to stop being xxxxs and creating a culture of blame and vindictiveness towards the disabled and those with mental health problems. How does that help with them? It helps the government because they can convince the stupid, nasty and gullible it’s someone else’s fault and not theirs the country is a complete mess.

Stop wasting millions on PR exercises like the Rwanda nonsense.

Aside from companies providing better support (most large companies now do) how will any of that get a single person signed off sick back into work?

What if they are too ill to work? Is the solution to just say they are fit to work? Brilliant.
Reply
#34
(04-22-2024, 05:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 02:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well firstly stop wasting millions of pounds and making people’s lives a misery by constant reassessment of people who are by every definition never going to be able to work.

Secondly pay full time unpaid carers a full time living wage that means they don’t have to jump through hoops just to save the country millions in social care. In short the DWP and government need to think pragmatically and also have some morals because currently they are operating in a moral vacuum.

Thirdly don’t scrap schemes that are set-up to help the disabled back into work at the very same time as they making it harder for them to recieve benefits.

Go after tax fraud and avoidance it costs the country far more but I grant you it’s not as easy to scapegoat them as it is the disabled and ill.

Force big companies to offer better mental and occupational health support given the draconian way some of them operate it’s no wonder people are struggling physically and mentally.

The government to stop being xxxxs and creating a culture of blame and vindictiveness towards the disabled and those with mental health problems. How does that help with them? It helps the government because they can convince the stupid, nasty and gullible it’s someone else’s fault and not theirs the country is a complete mess.

Stop wasting millions on PR exercises like the Rwanda nonsense.

Aside from companies providing better support (most large companies now do) how will any of that get a single person signed off sick back into work?

What if they are too ill to work? Is the solution to just say they are fit to work? Brilliant.

That's not the question or the issue at hand, unless you want to adopt the fatalistic position that once you've been signed off sick that's pretty much it.

Given that unemployment is far worse for an individual's mental health than employment, then surely it's a "good thing" to ensure as many people who can work, do work. The alternative is that you abandon hundreds of thousands on the scrapheap.
Reply
#35
Maybe we shouldn’t have shredded social care, the health service and the societal support structures like we have done. Maybe we shouldn’t have sold off the housing stock without replacing it and creating area where their are no examples of workers because everyone is the most in need. Maybe we shouldn’t have sold all of our public services to be reliant on private companies with no need to do what is right.


You are trying to solve a problem that conservatism (blue or red) didn’t need to create but it did anyway.
Reply
#36
(04-22-2024, 05:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 05:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 02:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well firstly stop wasting millions of pounds and making people’s lives a misery by constant reassessment of people who are by every definition never going to be able to work.

Secondly pay full time unpaid carers a full time living wage that means they don’t have to jump through hoops just to save the country millions in social care. In short the DWP and government need to think pragmatically and also have some morals because currently they are operating in a moral vacuum.

Thirdly don’t scrap schemes that are set-up to help the disabled back into work at the very same time as they making it harder for them to recieve benefits.

Go after tax fraud and avoidance it costs the country far more but I grant you it’s not as easy to scapegoat them as it is the disabled and ill.

Force big companies to offer better mental and occupational health support given the draconian way some of them operate it’s no wonder people are struggling physically and mentally.

The government to stop being xxxxs and creating a culture of blame and vindictiveness towards the disabled and those with mental health problems. How does that help with them? It helps the government because they can convince the stupid, nasty and gullible it’s someone else’s fault and not theirs the country is a complete mess.

Stop wasting millions on PR exercises like the Rwanda nonsense.

Aside from companies providing better support (most large companies now do) how will any of that get a single person signed off sick back into work?

What if they are too ill to work? Is the solution to just say they are fit to work? Brilliant.

That's not the question or the issue at hand, unless you want to adopt the fatalistic position that once you've been signed off sick that's pretty much it.

Given that unemployment is far worse for an individual's mental health than employment, then surely it's a "good thing" to ensure as many people who can work, do work. The alternative is that you abandon hundreds of thousands on the scrapheap.

I think, with the right type of government support people will come to realise that Work Will Set You Free.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#37
(04-23-2024, 09:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Maybe we shouldn’t have shredded social care, the health service and the societal support structures like we have done. Maybe we shouldn’t have sold off the housing stock without replacing it and creating area where their are no examples of workers because everyone is the most in need. Maybe we shouldn’t have sold all of our public services to be reliant on private companies with no need to do what is right.


You are trying to solve a problem that conservatism (blue or red) didn’t need to create but it did anyway.

No solution there either then.
Reply
#38
(04-23-2024, 11:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 09:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Maybe we shouldn’t have shredded social care, the health service and the societal support structures like we have done. Maybe we shouldn’t have sold off the housing stock without replacing it and creating area where their are no examples of workers because everyone is the most in need. Maybe we shouldn’t have sold all of our public services to be reliant on private companies with no need to do what is right.


You are trying to solve a problem that conservatism (blue or red) didn’t need to create but it did anyway.

No solution there either then.

When you set off on a journey that requires you to go north and you head south do you criticise those that told you were going in the wrong direction because you have made the destination further away?

The solution is a long road back that is going to involve some serious investment and big economic decisions such as rejoining the EU for a start.
Reply
#39
(04-23-2024, 12:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: When you set off on a journey that requires you to go north and you head south do you criticise those that told you were going in the wrong direction because you have made the destination further away?

The solution is a long road back that is going to involve some serious investment and big economic decisions such as rejoining the EU for a start.

No, I tend to concentrate on how we got here and on the way forward. To suggest that the rise in sickness claims is simply down to your perception of where government has failed is far too simplistic. Others on here have already made the link between rational behaviour to game the welfare system in the same way as others (including me) alter their behaviour to maximise the benefit derived and minimise losses from the tax system. If it's all tHE tOOrEeS fault you're also denying individuals their agency.

There's little doubt that that dynamic is in play here, as is underemployment to retain tax credits. Starmer's government will also know that the current situation is untenable.

We're going to need some creative solutions in an era when neither serious investment nor rejoining the EU are realistic options. I hope your message is going to be a bit better than that come the election.
Reply
#40
You are the one looking at this simplistically- I can’t be arsed to go into detail as I’m enjoying the shade in Egypt too much today and arguing with you is just shouting into the void. But when you take away the structures and support network of a rounded society then don’t get surprised when that society breaks down slowly. You need to look beyond the sick note culture created through sink estate living and ease of getting benefits without having an infrastructure to manage that system in place and invest in the future so that it won’t happen again.

Read some history and learn from it. Look at Germany post war and see how that was built from ruins using state and business working together, not one trying to replace another. The calamitous decisions made trying to turn us into a mini USA and head down the fully capitalist route has nearly destroyed us.

Changing the political landscape will take decades and we have only just started. Allowing the lies and corruption of the past parliament on a flimsy ‘least worst’ excuse isn’t going to solve the problem. It was clear that they shouldn’t have been voted for but they served a purpose to get Brexit through - shame on those that pushed for that. Changing leadership in the Labour Party was the 1st step, getting elected this year will be the second. Next we will need to take a good look at two key elements - undoing the damage Brexit has caused and renationalising the obvious ones - rail and water. Housing will need to be the focus’s of this parliament along with rebuilding the social care and NHS - not just farming it out to private organisations.

So many changes needed to get us to where we should have been heading in the 1st place.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: