For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives
#31
I don't see Neil as being a less attractive choice than Wagner or Jokabnovic.

All of them have achieved promotion from the Championship to the Premiership.

All of them have managed in a season where their team has been relegated from the Premiership.

You might argue that Wagner's was the most noteworthy promotion with the unfancied Huddersfield and he did have a season of relative success in the premiership. But there again when Huddersfield came up they had a negative goal difference, that don't sound too clever to me.

Jokanovic has 2 promotions, but countered against that was a disastrous premiership campaign, that lasted only 4 months. Darren Moore won 3 times as many premiership matches in fewer games in charge.

Neil is the more steady eddie of the three an unspectacular promotion and an unspectacular relegation.

You pays your money and you take your choice.
Reply
#32
(04-11-2019, 09:32 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Feels right appointment to me. Excellent record at this level. Plays decent football, strong disciplinarian which we definitely need right now, young and ambitious. Lost his way after a brilliant first 12 months at Norwich but has pretty much over achieved throughout his managerial  career.

Good insight to him here.

https://thesetpieces.com/features/norwic...alex-neil/

Good post. 

Did brilliantly to get HA into the SPL - then won away at Celtic. 

Did a very good job at Norwich - given that their recent other promotions are/were Farke and Lambert in 2011.  Norwich sacked him when they were just outside the POs in 2016/2017.  

Imo, Jokanovic is a better option.  Neil is somewhere in the Johnson and Smith category of good Champo managers.  

Still far from a done deal mind
Reply
#33
(04-11-2019, 11:57 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Odd position Neil is in. A lot of assumptions being made?
The media was reporting he was Celtic bound. But atm it's all speculation.
We could do worse, depends if Jenkins and Dowling back him.
Who ever comes in has a massive task to complete.
We basically need a complete new team, we cannot continue with the failures we have.
Nice to see Shan stating hoof the ball out of defence stop messing about and I'm glad he has said it in public.
This puts the onus where it belongs with the players.

Just how do you propose we get a new team? Take the current ones to a car boot sale? Pop in Squads R Us? Shedding quality players is one thing but replacing is another ball ache game. We struggled to attract quality when we were top half of the Prem. All these shit players everyone keeps slagging off would be most welcome at other clubs. Majority on here were shouting to fuck off Rondon all last season. We won't get him back now and he's still our player ffs. They ain't as shite as you think. Players have been berated on here while being picked to represent their countries.
Reply
#34
I think the "underwhelming" comments come off the back of BD being sacked as promotion was the "be all" to the club.

There was then an expectation that a) we must have someone lined up and b) would have experience and a certain amount of gravitas.

What we've got instead is a "Simon Grayson" type appointment. How we all laughed at Sunderland 'til I Die, imagine how we'd look as a club under a similar spotlight.
Reply
#35
(04-11-2019, 01:05 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think the "underwhelming" comments come off the back of BD being sacked as promotion was the "be all" to the club.

There was then an expectation that a) we must have someone lined up and b) would have experience and a certain amount of gravitas.

What we've got instead is a "Simon Grayson" type appointment.  How we all laughed at Sunderland 'til I Die, imagine how we'd look as a club under a similar spotlight.

But who were / are the alternatives that when you strip away the sexy foreign names have a better CV then Neil that we can realistically attract? The parameters that some have set out is unrealistic. "We want a young, hungry, progressive manager, who has no blemishes on his CV, plays nice football and can deliver promotion". I imagine this person has a cape, a large letter S on his all in one catsuit and a kiss curl. 

DM was a popular choice because of the connection to the club not because of his managerial credentials which although impressive were limited at best.

(04-11-2019, 01:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 11:57 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Odd position Neil is in. A lot of assumptions being made?
The media was reporting he was Celtic bound. But atm it's all speculation.
We could do worse, depends if Jenkins and Dowling back him.
Who ever comes in has a massive task to complete.
We basically need a complete new team, we cannot continue with the failures we have.
Nice to see Shan stating hoof the ball out of defence stop messing about and I'm glad he has said it in public.
This puts the onus where it belongs with the players.

Just how do you propose we get a new team? Take the current ones to a car boot sale? Pop in Squads R Us? Shedding quality players is one thing but replacing is another ball ache game. We struggled to attract quality when we were top half of the Prem. All these shit players everyone keeps slagging off would be most welcome at other clubs. Majority on here were shouting to fuck off Rondon all last season. We won't get him back now and he's still our player ffs. They ain't as shite as you think. Players have been berated on here while being picked to represent their countries.

Don't ask reasonable questions.
Reply
#36
(04-11-2019, 01:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 01:05 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think the "underwhelming" comments come off the back of BD being sacked as promotion was the "be all" to the club.

There was then an expectation that a) we must have someone lined up and b) would have experience and a certain amount of gravitas.

What we've got instead is a "Simon Grayson" type appointment.  How we all laughed at Sunderland 'til I Die, imagine how we'd look as a club under a similar spotlight.

But who were / are the alternatives that when you strip away the sexy foreign names have a better CV then Neil that we can realistically attract? The parameters that some have set out is unrealistic. "We want a young, hungry, progressive manager, who has no blemishes on his CV, plays nice football and can deliver promotion". I imagine this person has a cape, a large letter S on his all in one catsuit and a kiss curl. 

DM was a popular choice because of the connection to the club not because of his managerial credentials which although impressive were limited at best.

(04-11-2019, 01:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 11:57 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Odd position Neil is in. A lot of assumptions being made?
The media was reporting he was Celtic bound. But atm it's all speculation.
We could do worse, depends if Jenkins and Dowling back him.
Who ever comes in has a massive task to complete.
We basically need a complete new team, we cannot continue with the failures we have.
Nice to see Shan stating hoof the ball out of defence stop messing about and I'm glad he has said it in public.
This puts the onus where it belongs with the players.

Just how do you propose we get a new team? Take the current ones to a car boot sale? Pop in Squads R Us? Shedding quality players is one thing but replacing is another ball ache game. We struggled to attract quality when we were top half of the Prem. All these shit players everyone keeps slagging off would be most welcome at other clubs. Majority on here were shouting to fuck off Rondon all last season. We won't get him back now and he's still our player ffs. They ain't as shite as you think. Players have been berated on here while being picked to represent their countries.

Don't ask reasonable questions.

Carry on fishing Big Grin

Say goodbye to Holgate - Murphy - Montero - Johansen - Tosin - Mears - Hoolahan - Mozza - Brunt - Barry - Gayle that's before we sell anyone. Can you smell the coffee? Or are you still fishing?
Reply
#37
(04-11-2019, 01:53 PM)Black penny Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 01:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 01:05 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think the "underwhelming" comments come off the back of BD being sacked as promotion was the "be all" to the club.

There was then an expectation that a) we must have someone lined up and b) would have experience and a certain amount of gravitas.

What we've got instead is a "Simon Grayson" type appointment.  How we all laughed at Sunderland 'til I Die, imagine how we'd look as a club under a similar spotlight.

But who were / are the alternatives that when you strip away the sexy foreign names have a better CV then Neil that we can realistically attract? The parameters that some have set out is unrealistic. "We want a young, hungry, progressive manager, who has no blemishes on his CV, plays nice football and can deliver promotion". I imagine this person has a cape, a large letter S on his all in one catsuit and a kiss curl. 

DM was a popular choice because of the connection to the club not because of his managerial credentials which although impressive were limited at best.

(04-11-2019, 01:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 11:57 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Odd position Neil is in. A lot of assumptions being made?
The media was reporting he was Celtic bound. But atm it's all speculation.
We could do worse, depends if Jenkins and Dowling back him.
Who ever comes in has a massive task to complete.
We basically need a complete new team, we cannot continue with the failures we have.
Nice to see Shan stating hoof the ball out of defence stop messing about and I'm glad he has said it in public.
This puts the onus where it belongs with the players.

Just how do you propose we get a new team? Take the current ones to a car boot sale? Pop in Squads R Us? Shedding quality players is one thing but replacing is another ball ache game. We struggled to attract quality when we were top half of the Prem. All these shit players everyone keeps slagging off would be most welcome at other clubs. Majority on here were shouting to fuck off Rondon all last season. We won't get him back now and he's still our player ffs. They ain't as shite as you think. Players have been berated on here while being picked to represent their countries.

Don't ask reasonable questions.

Carry on fishing Big Grin

Say goodbye to Holgate - Murphy - Montero - Johansen - Tosin - Mears - Hoolahan - Mozza - Brunt - Barry - Gayle that's before we sell anyone. Can you smell the coffee? Or are you still fishing?

I think it's a given that we shall lose the players on loan and some players are getting to the end of their career let alone their career with us. However are you advocating selling the whole squad if we don't go up? It's a shame that fans clamoured for an inexperienced coach to get the job given the importance of promotion this season.
Reply
#38
Your quite a knob at putting your twist on what they post, we're here again you trying to win a point. Stick with Dek he's great - I've lost your far to clever for me.
Reply
#39
Reading up on him. I'm sold.

I'm on the Neil hype train.
Reply
#40
(04-11-2019, 02:13 PM)Black penny Wrote: Your quite a knob at putting your twist on what they post, we're here again you trying to win a point. Stick with Dek he's great - I've lost your far to clever for me.

Perhaps you should ask Jacko as he asked the question about the idea of getting a completely new team. I agreed with him that it would be unrealistic to sell everyone and start afresh and that some of our players really aren't as bad as they are made out from time to time.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)