Vaughan
#31
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer

It's all so unfair isn't it ?
Reply
#32
(03-31-2023, 04:46 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer

Any banter, between mates, is unacceptable, when taken out of context.

This!
Nowadays - banter between mates can get people into all sorts of trouble if a bystander gets offended!
Reply
#33
(03-31-2023, 05:31 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer
8 out the 9 charges were accepted Vaughan’s charge was not only because there was confusion of the exact wording of the slight he’s a very very fortunate boy!!.
Bigger picture is that this proves real institutional racism and know hopefully can be addressed fully by the sport here!!.

I really can't agree with that Pind. I'd say he was a very, very unlucky boy. The whole case against him came down to one comment, initially mis-reported by the plaintiff, not confirmed by all of the witnesses who were interviewed and not investigated in any real depth. This whole sorry business establishes that racism was endemic at Yorkshire. But calling out high profile individuals for twice calling someone a "Paki" (wasn't that Hoggard's offence?) doesn't solve anything - it just provides scapegoats. There was a time when these people would be burned at the stake or hanged, drawn and quartered in front of a baying crowd.

I'd suggest that this case won't make much difference to the culture in English cricket at the top level. Most of the posh grammar school boys will carry on with their heads stuck up their arses until something like this or a failed drug test stops them in their tracks. I'm guessing that Yorkshire will carry on being very much the least inclusive county. The echoes of this case will make it easier for discrimination to be challenged, but there won't be a stampede of young cricketers flagging these issues up.

Only four black or Asian women have ever been picked for England in any format of the game. Apparently the last English born black man to debut for England's Test side was Michael Carberry in 2010. Those are surprising statistics which underline the issue. What Michael Vaughan may or may not have said in 2009 is just a sideshow. He doesn't deserve to be thrown to the dogs while the real issues are overlooked.
Reply
#34
(03-31-2023, 10:02 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 05:31 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer
8 out the 9 charges were accepted Vaughan’s charge was not only because there was confusion of the exact wording of the slight he’s a very very fortunate boy!!.
Bigger picture is that this proves real institutional racism and know hopefully can be addressed fully by the sport here!!.

I really can't agree with that Pind. I'd say he was a very, very unlucky boy. The whole case against him came down to one comment, initially mis-reported by the plaintiff, not confirmed by all of the witnesses who were interviewed and not investigated in any real depth. This whole sorry business establishes that racism was endemic at Yorkshire. But calling out high profile individuals for twice calling someone a "Paki" (wasn't that Hoggard's offence?) doesn't solve anything - it just provides scapegoats. There was a time when these people would be burned at the stake or hanged, drawn and quartered in front of a baying crowd.

I'd suggest that this case won't make much difference to the culture in English cricket at the top level. Most of the posh grammar school boys will carry on with their heads stuck up their arses until something like this or a failed drug test stops them in their tracks. I'm guessing that Yorkshire will carry on being very much the least inclusive county. The echoes of this case will make it easier for discrimination to be challenged, but there won't be a stampede of young cricketers flagging these issues up.

Only four black or Asian women have ever been picked for England in any format of the game. Apparently the last English born black man to debut for England's Test side was Michael Carberry in 2010. Those are surprising statistics which underline the issue. What Michael Vaughan may or may not have said in 2009 is just a sideshow. He doesn't deserve to be thrown to the dogs while the real issues are overlooked.

Jofra has played, surely? Agree, it does seem to have gone backwards though.
Reply
#35
(03-31-2023, 10:20 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 10:02 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 05:31 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer
8 out the 9 charges were accepted Vaughan’s charge was not only because there was confusion of the exact wording of the slight he’s a very very fortunate boy!!.
Bigger picture is that this proves real institutional racism and know hopefully can be addressed fully by the sport here!!.

I really can't agree with that Pind. I'd say he was a very, very unlucky boy. The whole case against him came down to one comment, initially mis-reported by the plaintiff, not confirmed by all of the witnesses who were interviewed and not investigated in any real depth. This whole sorry business establishes that racism was endemic at Yorkshire. But calling out high profile individuals for twice calling someone a "Paki" (wasn't that Hoggard's offence?) doesn't solve anything - it just provides scapegoats. There was a time when these people would be burned at the stake or hanged, drawn and quartered in front of a baying crowd.

I'd suggest that this case won't make much difference to the culture in English cricket at the top level. Most of the posh grammar school boys will carry on with their heads stuck up their arses until something like this or a failed drug test stops them in their tracks. I'm guessing that Yorkshire will carry on being very much the least inclusive county. The echoes of this case will make it easier for discrimination to be challenged, but there won't be a stampede of young cricketers flagging these issues up.

Only four black or Asian women have ever been picked for England in any format of the game. Apparently the last English born black man to debut for England's Test side was Michael Carberry in 2010. Those are surprising statistics which underline the issue. What Michael Vaughan may or may not have said in 2009 is just a sideshow. He doesn't deserve to be thrown to the dogs while the real issues are overlooked.

Jofra has played, surely? Agree, it does seem to have gone backwards though.

Born in the Windies. Tymal Mills was born in Yorkshire but hasn't played Tests.
Reply
#36
(03-31-2023, 10:26 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 10:20 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 10:02 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 05:31 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer
8 out the 9 charges were accepted Vaughan’s charge was not only because there was confusion of the exact wording of the slight he’s a very very fortunate boy!!.
Bigger picture is that this proves real institutional racism and know hopefully can be addressed fully by the sport here!!.

I really can't agree with that Pind. I'd say he was a very, very unlucky boy. The whole case against him came down to one comment, initially mis-reported by the plaintiff, not confirmed by all of the witnesses who were interviewed and not investigated in any real depth. This whole sorry business establishes that racism was endemic at Yorkshire. But calling out high profile individuals for twice calling someone a "Paki" (wasn't that Hoggard's offence?) doesn't solve anything - it just provides scapegoats. There was a time when these people would be burned at the stake or hanged, drawn and quartered in front of a baying crowd.

I'd suggest that this case won't make much difference to the culture in English cricket at the top level. Most of the posh grammar school boys will carry on with their heads stuck up their arses until something like this or a failed drug test stops them in their tracks. I'm guessing that Yorkshire will carry on being very much the least inclusive county. The echoes of this case will make it easier for discrimination to be challenged, but there won't be a stampede of young cricketers flagging these issues up.

Only four black or Asian women have ever been picked for England in any format of the game. Apparently the last English born black man to debut for England's Test side was Michael Carberry in 2010. Those are surprising statistics which underline the issue. What Michael Vaughan may or may not have said in 2009 is just a sideshow. He doesn't deserve to be thrown to the dogs while the real issues are overlooked.

Jofra has played, surely? Agree, it does seem to have gone backwards though.

Born in the Windies. Tymal Mills was born in Yorkshire but hasn't played Tests.

Ah, my mistake. Wink
Reply
#37
Good outcome.
Reply
#38
37% of English county cricketers were privately educated. Over 90% of England's footballers were state educated. The summer game is still in thrall to the public school elite who run the game and prefer it that way. The lack of home born Asian and black cricketers among the counties is scandalous, not least given they make up a huge proportion of those playing league cricket.

What is extraordinary is that the percentage of privately educated Aussies playing professionally is almost exactly the same! Bizarre.
Reply
#39
(03-31-2023, 06:47 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer

It's all so unfair isn't it ?

In your little bubble no doubt

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#40
(04-01-2023, 09:13 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 06:47 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 04:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Whole thing is a mess, Rafiq has apologised as he's changed his story/statement from the initial submission

We're talking years ago, not acceptable then or now frankly but the world was and is a different place

It's the "witch hunt" mentality I don't like

Rafiq for example has openly admitted calling Gary Ballance all sorts of derogitary and rasict tems about the colour of his skin, heritage, his weight and Ballance has admitted calling him a "P*ki"
Both admitted at the time it was banter between two good mates, Rafiq went to Balance's wedding, stayed at his appartment rent free etc yet now Ballance has to apologise and start a career elsewhere

Cuzer

It's all so unfair isn't it ?

In your little bubble no doubt

Cuzer
Burst yours though!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: