Linekar wins the tax appeal
#31
(03-28-2023, 09:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-28-2023, 08:49 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: If it looks like a dog, and barks like a dog, then it is probably an employee trying to hide behind IR35 or a tax scheme.

I dispise people that use them. In my experience it's usually people that can afford to pay fair tax. Most people don't have that choice, due to PAYE.

Indeed.

No different to Starbucks et al who find “legal” loopholes to avoid paying tax. That’s exactly why they’re loopholes.

And today, we have some folk celebrating that Lineker wins this case. Incredibly, on the left side of politics. I despair, but it just shows how naive some people are. Or perhaps not naive, just desperate to get one over the “other side”, and in this case Labour supporters on social media cheering on a millionaire finding tax loopholes. Christ. Literally the rich being able to find loopholes (yes he’s won legally, that’s exactly why it’s a loophole!), and in this case PR their way to looking like the good guys. Which most of us plebs can’t do, as we’re not in the position to find the loophole, nor employ a top lawyer to defend ourselves.

Well done Lineker, you’re as morally upstanding as Starbucks and Amazon (who also pay the “right” amount of tax legally). FFS.

But Derek backs Lineker doing the same as Amazon and Starbucks who he rails against. 
Hypocrisy, Derek? Never.
Reply
#32
(03-28-2023, 05:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Or what a decent person he is, who is happy to support society through his taxes. 

I am happy to support society through taxes. Though I always try to pay the correct amount as my family comes before society at large (doesn't everyone's?). Does that make me less decent than St Gary?

Lineker's tax arrangements seem unique, and perhaps uniquely contrived. For what purpose I cannot guess - but clearly he's paying less tax than he might as a BBC employee and more than he might if he contracted through a limited company.

I just find it odd tbh.

(03-28-2023, 10:21 PM)GMBaggie Wrote: But Derek backs Lineker doing the same as Amazon and Starbucks who he rails against. 

To be fair to Derek, Amazon & Starbucks it's all a lot more complicated than that.

Amazon & Starbucks aren't really taking advantage of the tax system, by domiciling themselves in lower tax states or in Starbucks case operating on a system of franchises and royalties they're simply being rational and maximising shareholder value.
Reply
#33
Some great “facts” on this thread and wonderfully polarised views from some people who don’t quite understand tax.

For the record I’ve not seen anywhere that Linekar has entered a tax scheme. No talk of a DOTAS number on his tax return.

Proth, our sitting Thatcherite, is berating him for paying way too much tax, yet others accuse him of doing a Starbucks. Which is it?

The most interesting fact I’ve learnt is that the majority of HMRC workers are labour voters. Does anyone have a link detailing the poll conducted for that?

It seems Linekar has done nothing wrong, certainly could have been much more aggressive with his “tax planning” and saved more tax (via a limited company) but chose the LLP route and therefore pays Income Tax and Class 1 NIC on his income.

The bigger questions we all need to be asking is why MPs consistently allow the likes of Amazon and Starbucks to not pay tax when they are in charge of setting the rules that these companies are supposed to abide to.

Are they worried about their next consultancy or non-exec directorship? The videos this week have shown what a bunch of greedy, self serving wankers they really are.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#34
(03-29-2023, 08:35 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Proth, our sitting Thatcherite, is berating him for paying way too much tax

I take my hat off to him for doing so. 

There's a huge number of posters on here who always claim they'd be happy to pay more tax. Well here's your chance, structure your affairs in the bizzarre manner St Gary does.

Please post the evidence when you've done so.
Reply
#35
(03-29-2023, 08:39 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 08:35 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Proth, our sitting Thatcherite, is berating him for paying way too much tax

I take my hat off to him for doing so. 

There's a huge number of posters on here who always claim they'd be happy to pay more tax. Well here's your chance, structure your affairs in the bizzarre manner St Gary does.

Please post the evidence when you've done so.

I could set myself up on an IR35 and pay fuck all tax!  Mainly because I earn fuck all outside of my PAYE.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#36
I wouldn't object to paying more tax if it was properly allocated to public services that needed it and resulted in public service that was beneficial for all.

I do object to further lining the pockets of the current government.
Reply
#37
(03-29-2023, 08:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I wouldn't object to paying more tax if it was properly allocated to public services that needed it and resulted in public service that was beneficial for all.

You can always donate that excess income to charities who're by and large far better at allocating resources than any government.
Reply
#38
(03-29-2023, 09:01 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 08:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I wouldn't object to paying more tax if it was properly allocated to public services that needed it and resulted in public service that was beneficial for all.

You can always donate that excess income to charities who're by and large far better at allocating resources than any government.

But I thought charity donations are tax deductible, so he could end up paying less tax doing it that way!
Reply
#39
(03-29-2023, 08:35 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Some great “facts” on this thread and wonderfully polarised views from some people who don’t quite understand tax.

For the record I’ve not seen anywhere that Linekar has entered a tax scheme.  No talk of a DOTAS number on his tax return. 

Proth, our sitting Thatcherite, is berating him for paying way too much tax, yet others accuse him of doing a Starbucks.  Which is it? 

The most interesting fact I’ve learnt is that the majority of HMRC workers are labour voters.  Does anyone have a link detailing the poll conducted for that?

It seems Linekar has done nothing wrong, certainly could have been much more aggressive with his “tax planning” and saved more tax (via a limited company) but chose the LLP route and therefore pays Income Tax and Class 1 NIC on his income. 

The bigger questions we all need to be asking is why MPs consistently allow the likes of Amazon and Starbucks to not pay tax when they are in charge of setting the rules that these companies are supposed to abide to.

Are they worried about their next consultancy or non-exec directorship?  The videos this week have shown what a bunch of greedy, self serving wankers they really are.

I was going to respond to some of the bizarre logic shown on a few replies on this thread but you have done it far better for me CA. Have a merit for saving me time and energy to bother.
Reply
#40
(03-29-2023, 09:18 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 09:01 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 08:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I wouldn't object to paying more tax if it was properly allocated to public services that needed it and resulted in public service that was beneficial for all.

You can always donate that excess income to charities who're by and large far better at allocating resources than any government.

But I thought charity donations are tax deductible, so he could end up paying less tax doing it that way!

Donate through gift aid then you don't personally get the tax advantage it is given to the charity
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: