Ratings
#31
(10-16-2022, 08:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Yes he is, I’d say he’s 3rd on the list behind a thieving chairman and an incompetent CEO. He’s our senior striker yet he’s got no pace, no fight, struggles to control a pass, easily dispossessed, crap in the air and shit at taking penalties
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#32
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Yes he is, I’d say he’s 3rd on the list behind a thieving chairman and an incompetent CEO. He’s our senior striker yet he’s got no pace, no fight, struggles to control a pass, easily dispossessed, crap in the air and shit at taking penalties
So he is more of a problem than Zohore, Bartley, Furlong, Button, Matty Phillips' crisplegs? As said above, the only issue with Grant is that Bilic paid 400% too much.
Reply
#33
(10-16-2022, 05:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Thought Kelly was excellent today. 
Grant “looks interested”? Not from where I was sat, usual pretending to jump for the ball, easily snuffed out for his chance at the end
I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Yes he is, I’d say he’s 3rd on the list behind a thieving chairman and an incompetent CEO. He’s our senior striker yet he’s got no pace, no fight, struggles to control a pass, easily dispossessed, crap in the air and shit at taking penalties
So he is more of a problem than Zohore, Bartley, Furlong, Button, Matty Phillips' crisplegs? As said above, the only issue with Grant is that Bilic paid 400% too much.

Yes he is. Zohore is out in May while the other 4 have been replaced in the starting 11. But we’re relying on a 350k league 2 striker to cover for Grant’s inadequacies. You could argue it’s not Grant’s fault that we haven’t got anyone better to replace him, but the fact is that in the last 2 games 2 separate managers (admittedly one a numpty) have concluded that the 350k man is the better bet. As a result we are weak in one of the most crucial areas of the pitch
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#34
(10-16-2022, 06:22 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(10-16-2022, 05:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:I really don't know how we tell a player's mindset. Not being able to outjump a 6 foot 5 centre half is hardly a reasonable criticism.

Give him credit for his strengths. Which include putting the ball in the net more than anyone else at the club. 

And I noticed that Grant was the first on to the pitch delighted at Phillips' goal.  An excellent sign of team spirit, which has perhaps been lacking lately. That pleased me almost as much as the goal.

I've never bought into the "Grant isn't interested" mantra. He is very limited, but does try and is arguably making the best of what he has. Grant is nowhere near the top of our list of problems.

Yes he is, I’d say he’s 3rd on the list behind a thieving chairman and an incompetent CEO. He’s our senior striker yet he’s got no pace, no fight, struggles to control a pass, easily dispossessed, crap in the air and shit at taking penalties
So he is more of a problem than Zohore, Bartley, Furlong, Button, Matty Phillips' crisplegs? As said above, the only issue with Grant is that Bilic paid 400% too much.

Yes he is. Zohore is out in May while the other 4 have been replaced in the starting 11. But we’re relying on a 350k league 2 striker to cover for Grant’s inadequacies. You could argue it’s not Grant’s fault that we haven’t got anyone better to replace him, but the fact is that in the last 2 games 2 separate managers (admittedly one a numpty) have concluded that the 350k man is the better bet. As a result we are weak in one of the most crucial areas of the pitch
Agree with this BBB. The others have been discarded yet we are still trying to shoehorn Grant into the team despite him offering nothing wherever he plays. I'd bin him and have Cleary there - hopefully he'll work hard. That's all i want.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: