Italy v England
#31
(09-24-2022, 07:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(09-23-2022, 08:42 PM)Albionmad Wrote: We have exciting players. Kane, Foden, Sterling etc but Southgate has to set up the team because the defence is crap.

3 games without a goal

In 66 Ramsy's team was rock solid. 
In 70 we were undone by Banks food poisoning

Ever since then our defence had been found out.

I think we've had a strong tradition of competent defenders from Bobby Moore right up to EBJT. The supply seems to have run out. I've never rated Harry Maguire, his career to date has been the classic "Emperor's New Clothes" scenario. It's only Ten Hag who has finally declared him useless. No way should he be anywhere near an England starting XI, with his fragile confidence shredded. That's the kind of loyalty-based error of judgement that many coaches make in sport.

Eric Dier has played much of his career in midfield. I've no idea what Kyle Walker's strengths are. Surely there must be some conventionally competent defenders out there? Or has defence gone out of fashion? I thought it was just the Albion.

Dier has been at CH ever since Conte took over at Spurs and has been excellent for them by all accounts.
Reply
#32
Relegated, 5 games without a win, or goal from open play, seems Gareth might be following the Steve Bruce playbook, maybe he just told the lads to go out, &  enjoy themselves, & carress the ball.    Rolleyes
Reply
#33
Kyle Walker?

You mean the Kyle Walker who plays for Man City, who has often been Pep's go to man at right back. I think he may know a little more than anyone on here about the game.
Reply
#34
Am I on my own? Couldn't care less. Gave up watching at half time other than to flick channels. Not bothered about a Qatar world cup either. Not happy it's a blank weekend of proper football. A good Albion away day would suit me today far more than watching England.
Reply
#35
(09-24-2022, 10:49 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Am I on my own? Couldn't care less. Gave up watching at half time other than to flick channels.  Not bothered about a Qatar world cup either. Not happy it's a blank weekend of proper football. A good Albion away day would suit me today far more than watching England.

+1

Absolute waste of time, in a year when match time's tight anyway.
Reply
#36
(09-24-2022, 10:26 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Kyle Walker?

You mean the Kyle Walker who plays for Man City, who has often been Pep's go to man at right back. I think he may know a little more than anyone on here about the game.

What I mean is that he doesn't seem to have a "best" position, he just fits in sort of on the right of whatever's going on. I'm not dissing him in any way. I was brought up watching Charlton and Moore for England, McFarland and Todd for Derby, Wile and Robertson for Albion. In the modern game there seem to be neither the individuals nor the partnerships to give defensive stability. Perhaps it's just the modern way but England, like Albion, are so often chasing the game after conceding.
Reply
#37
(09-23-2022, 10:07 PM)Duffers Wrote: I’ve been one of Southgate’s biggest defenders, but I have also never been optimistic about our chances in Qatar. The timing and climate is against us and I can’t see how we can perform in the conditions over there, I’ve already written it off mentally.

People talk about agendas on here, and it’s pretty obvious that there has been one against Southgate, the OP on this thread was about him letting a RB take a free kick for fuck’s sake! People dislike Southgate because he’s pragmatic, thoughtful and not the jingoistic “passhun lads!!” manager that stupid people think is all you need to succeed at this level. People seem to think you just cram an XI full of the likes of Grealish, Foden, whoever else this week’s clamour is for and plain old English spirit will take care of the rest.

Whatever happens in Qatar he has been the most successful England manager in my lifetime, that is a fact. Compare where we are now and how far we’ve come to the shitshow he inherited. People think a semi and a final in two tournaments is somehow not good enough for a side who have routinely crashed out quarters at best for most of the last three decades. Southgate has been great for this country, and whilst I agree that it probably is time to move on he has laid solid foundations for the next guy to improve on…


… and no I could not give any less of a fuck about the Nations League.

Conversely, lots of people defend him unconditionally for exactly that reason and excuse poor performances because he's articulate and seems more likely to read a broadsheet than a tabloid. 

I would agree that his tournament record is excellent compared to his predecessors but at the same time, in the matches I've watched, we never look that good, either.

I will be paying as little attention to Qatar as possible. Nobody should be dying to build a World Cup stadium.
Reply
#38
(09-24-2022, 12:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-23-2022, 10:07 PM)Duffers Wrote: I’ve been one of Southgate’s biggest defenders, but I have also never been optimistic about our chances in Qatar. The timing and climate is against us and I can’t see how we can perform in the conditions over there, I’ve already written it off mentally.

People talk about agendas on here, and it’s pretty obvious that there has been one against Southgate, the OP on this thread was about him letting a RB take a free kick for fuck’s sake! People dislike Southgate because he’s pragmatic, thoughtful and not the jingoistic “passhun lads!!” manager that stupid people think is all you need to succeed at this level. People seem to think you just cram an XI full of the likes of Grealish, Foden, whoever else this week’s clamour is for and plain old English spirit will take care of the rest.

Whatever happens in Qatar he has been the most successful England manager in my lifetime, that is a fact. Compare where we are now and how far we’ve come to the shitshow he inherited. People think a semi and a final in two tournaments is somehow not good enough for a side who have routinely crashed out quarters at best for most of the last three decades. Southgate has been great for this country, and whilst I agree that it probably is time to move on he has laid solid foundations for the next guy to improve on…


… and no I could not give any less of a fuck about the Nations League.

Conversely, lots of people defend him unconditionally for exactly that reason and excuse poor performances because he's articulate and seems more likely to read a broadsheet than a tabloid. 

I would agree that his tournament record is excellent compared to his predecessors but at the same time, in the matches I've watched, we never look that good, either.

I will be paying as little attention to Qatar as possible. Nobody should be dying to build a World Cup stadium.

+1
Reply
#39
(09-24-2022, 10:49 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Am I on my own? Couldn't care less. Gave up watching at half time other than to flick channels.  Not bothered about a Qatar world cup either. Not happy it's a blank weekend of proper football. A good Albion away day would suit me today far more than watching England.

My sentiments  too , don't bother watching any internationals games ,and won't be watching W/Cgames either.I hope they dowelled for those who travel and have an interest but much rather be at the Hawthorns even though we are crap atm .
Reply
#40
(09-24-2022, 12:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-23-2022, 10:07 PM)Duffers Wrote: I’ve been one of Southgate’s biggest defenders, but I have also never been optimistic about our chances in Qatar. The timing and climate is against us and I can’t see how we can perform in the conditions over there, I’ve already written it off mentally.

People talk about agendas on here, and it’s pretty obvious that there has been one against Southgate, the OP on this thread was about him letting a RB take a free kick for fuck’s sake! People dislike Southgate because he’s pragmatic, thoughtful and not the jingoistic “passhun lads!!” manager that stupid people think is all you need to succeed at this level. People seem to think you just cram an XI full of the likes of Grealish, Foden, whoever else this week’s clamour is for and plain old English spirit will take care of the rest.

Whatever happens in Qatar he has been the most successful England manager in my lifetime, that is a fact. Compare where we are now and how far we’ve come to the shitshow he inherited. People think a semi and a final in two tournaments is somehow not good enough for a side who have routinely crashed out quarters at best for most of the last three decades. Southgate has been great for this country, and whilst I agree that it probably is time to move on he has laid solid foundations for the next guy to improve on…


… and no I could not give any less of a fuck about the Nations League.

Conversely, lots of people defend him unconditionally for exactly that reason and excuse poor performances because he's articulate and seems more likely to read a broadsheet than a tabloid. 

I would agree that his tournament record is excellent compared to his predecessors but at the same time, in the matches I've watched, we never look that good, either.

I will be paying as little attention to Qatar as possible. Nobody should be dying to build a World Cup stadium.

International tournament football is rarely about “looking good” though, rarely do teams hammer and swashbuckle their way through tournaments. Most of them are win by sides who are organised, hard to breakdown and are capable of nicking goals. That is what we’ve become under Southgate, which is a damn sight better than what we were before him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: